Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Located in Titusville, Allen-Duncan Agencies serves Port St John, Sharpes, Mims, Wiley, and surrounding communities. An independent insurance agency, we sell insurance policies from many insurance companies - not just one or two companies. That gives us a competitive advantage when quoting your specific needs. We can insure almost anything you need, from autos to homes to boats to motorcycles to businesses and even life and flood insurance. Allen-Duncan Agencies, Inc. provides quality coverage tailored to fit your insurance needs and budget.
Services
With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Some of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.
We are very sorry for your loss and hope that the damage to your home and family is minimal. The claims departments of each company are ready to help resolve your claim as quickly and efficiently as possible. Find the claim number for your insurance company call to file a claim promptly. If you have any questions or concerns, we will be here as soon as possible to answer them.
Reviews (10)
Write a Review
Travis Rigsby
Jun 04, 2022
I called as a businessman leaving my name a message and my phone number THREE times. When I finally received a call back MELISSA the owner told me the only reason she called me back is because of my Persistency otherwise she would have never spoken to me. I was simply trying to help a family friend and a client of mine communicate effectively to understand insurance information.

She is an older widow and does not know if she is being SCAMMED or not. MELISSA the owner was incredibly rude to me on the phone because she did not want to talk to me to begin with. She yelled over top of me saying I don't have to talk to you you are not my client. When I told her she was being unprofessional she copied everything I said and told me she was going to tell everyone I was rude and disrespectful.

At least I let her talk she did not have the same respect for me. I would never recommend a person like this to anyone. I did not cuss, I did not tell, all I did was try to ask questions, but because I was not her client I was a nobody that she was too bothered to talk to. Quite frankly this was an embarrassing moment in my life and a complete waste of my time trying to solve problems with someone who wants to collect forms and money but not answer questions. I DID NOT ASK ANY POLICY RELATED QUESTIONS
Ana Barbara Vieira
May 20, 2022
Very attentive staff. Matter of fact we are switching our insurance agents bc our old ones were rude and never picked up the phone, even when it was to do business. We definitely had a great experience with Melissa, she was always there to answer our questions and was always very professional. Thank you
T. Reimer
Mar 26, 2022
Allen-Duncan is saving me thousands! Extremely helpful and responsive to all my questions. After a 65% increase in my homeowners policy, I asked my current agent to please see what he could do. No response and no help even after I replaced the roof. Tired of being ignored and decided time to find someone who would focus on me. Shelby has been great, answering every question and even advising me on how to save in the future when it's time for renewals.
Tim Costello
Mar 17, 2022
I'm a busy Realtor and have used Shelby 3 times so far this year for home owners policy. Amazing service! Definitely going to keep referring them my customers and will be using them for my own house.
Kelly Collyott
Mar 15, 2022
Shelby Has been so helpful with the process of changing my homeowners and car insurance. And what a quick turnaround! This was completed in less than a week. Thank you so much Shelby!
Justin Patrick WheelyView
Jan 27, 2022
I have used Allen Duncan for many years for auto and home. I shop my own rates occasionally to see what is out there and I always seem to be getting the best rates through Allen-Duncan. The key is that it is also stress free and nearly zero effort to get new quotes. A quick phone call and I have new rates awaiting me. They are always professional, kind and very quick to respond.

I highly recommend. Special thanks to Shelby for the help over the years as well. Go check them out! Using this agency helps keep insurance companies on their toes and keeps them all competitive since it is easier than ever to shop quotes more frequently.
Bill Banks
Jan 17, 2022
Shelby was very helpful and knowledgeable. She helped me in every way possible. She made my transition very smooth and easy. Would highly recommend to anyone!
Mark Poff
Jan 14, 2022
I recently realized that one of my insurance policies had lapsed and needed to be renewed immediately. Shelby Greenhill of Allen-Duncan was very responsive, finding and securing an appropriate policy within a couple of hours time. I've used AD for over 20 years for my insurance needs, and this is another example of the fine service I've received from them over the years.
Tyler
Jan 11, 2022
Have been with this agency off and on for years, they are top notch. Shout out to Melissa Duncan who has always treated me with kindness, fairness, and respect and also this year for Shelby G. who has provided excellent, prompt service and found an aggressive price as well. Highly recommend this agency.
Mj
Nov 05, 2021
I emailed Shelby to request a home owners insurance quote after we were not satisfied with our previous insurance company. She gave me a fair estimate less than 24 hours later, and even offered to insure our vehicles as well. The entire process start to finish took only a few days and was handled professionally and with incredible speed and efficiency.

I've already recommended to several of my coworkers and family members. Thank you again for all your help. A great agent truly makes a world of difference in choosing the right company to protect your home.