Amherst Insurance Agency Inc. began as The Nathan Agencies in 1969 when Ron Nathan founded the company. Ron moved The Nathan Agencies to its current location in 1978 and the following year purchased Amherst Insurance, expanding the types of insurance we carry. Since then, Amherst Insurance has steadily grown into one of the leading full-service insurance agencies in Western Massachusetts. At Amherst Insurance, we pride ourselves on treating all of our clients with respect, competence and accountability.
Follow us
Services
The Nathan Agencies began in 1969 when Ron Nathan founded what was called The Nathan Agency. The agency initially worked primarily with life insurance and investment products and in 1978 it moved to its current location on Gatehouse Road in Amherst. The following year Ron Nathan purchased the Amherst Insurance and Real Estate Agencies and the name became The Nathan Agencies.
Anna Holhut joined the Amherst Insurance in 1987 and is the President and owner of Amherst Insurance Agencies, Inc. A graduate of Central Connecticut State University, Anna holds a brokers license in the areas of property, casualty, commercial, life and health insurance. With over 30 years experience in the insurance field, Anna is a member of the Pioneer Valley Insurance Group (MA).
The personal lines staff at the Amherst Insurance has the experience and knowledge to handle your auto insurance needs. Properly protecting you against financial loss when you are involved in an accident is our top priority. It is imperative that you maintain the appropriate level of coverage for your particular situation.
Amherst Insurance serves individuals and families throughout Massachusetts by providing insurance for homeowners, condominium owners, and apartment dwellers. The biggest investment most people will ever make is their home. It is vital to protect this sizable financial investment with a comprehensive homeowners insurance plan.
Reviews (10)
Dan B.
May 17, 2022
Dick Teresi
Jun 15, 2021
Scott Plotkin
May 05, 2021
I have my house and three vehicles insured here. i have a couple of claims regarding storm damage which were resolved was quickly. when a tree fell on the house they waved the deductible. something about a regional storm event or something. Anne always follows up to make sure there were no problems and to see how we are doing.
Crystal Galbraith
Jun 14, 2019
Ken Kleinman
Nov 10, 2018
Howard Schultz
Jan 07, 2018
We were loyal customers of Amherst Insurance for 30 years. Last year we temporarily lived in another state for several months while on sabbatical. We informed Amherst Insurance, but somehow they made mistakes, which resulted in the insurance companies canceling all of our policies. Amherst Insurance would not take responsibility for their mistakes and reinstate our policies. So we move to another agency.
Lauri Finch
Jan 02, 2018
Madcow
Nov 11, 2017
Courtney Tate
Oct 05, 2017
Tammy Day
Jun 21, 2017
I have had Amherst Insurance for a few years now with no real issues until today. I purchased a new vehicle from a local dealership, the process was awesome, went right through the financial portion of it and was told the final step was waiting for my RMV-1 form to be stamped by my insurance company. An hour passes and my salesmen made several attempts to contact Amherst insurance.
When he finally reached the receptionist it was explained that they did not receive the fax, he confirmed the fax number and faxed it for the third time. When I called it was explained to me that they we short staffed today and did not have anyone authorized to stamp my form so I could take my brand new car today. NO ONE QUALIFIED?! I WAS SHOCKED!
I have been waiting here coming on two hours to find out they were wasting my time. Thank you Amherst Insurance for your un-professionalism, were you scared to be honest with a customer and say you could not do this right up front?! Instead of wasting my time? You made up my mind today I am switching to an alternative insurance company that cares about it's customers. I will let anyone who will listen know the horrible experience I have had with you.
When he finally reached the receptionist it was explained that they did not receive the fax, he confirmed the fax number and faxed it for the third time. When I called it was explained to me that they we short staffed today and did not have anyone authorized to stamp my form so I could take my brand new car today. NO ONE QUALIFIED?! I WAS SHOCKED!
I have been waiting here coming on two hours to find out they were wasting my time. Thank you Amherst Insurance for your un-professionalism, were you scared to be honest with a customer and say you could not do this right up front?! Instead of wasting my time? You made up my mind today I am switching to an alternative insurance company that cares about it's customers. I will let anyone who will listen know the horrible experience I have had with you.
