Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Anderson Insurance Agency The Anderson Insurance Agency was founded more than 50 years ago & has deep roots in the Long Beach Island & Manahawkin, New Jersey communities. Our mission is to help our clients understand their insurance program while offering them the best service & competitive prices. Our greatest resource is our employees. Our staff of professionals includes Certified Insurance Counselors, Certified Insurance Service Representatives and Accredited Customer Service Representatives. More importantly, they're great people who are happy to help you with your insurance needs.
Services
Anderson insurance agency was formed in 1967 with its headquarters on Long Beach Island and Manahawkin New Jersey. Our mission is to provide our clients with a choice of coverages from a variety of insurance companies to best fulfill their insurance needs and budget. Unlike others, we won't simply refer you to an 800 number.
Great insurance protects the things that matter most, whether you're out on the water or relaxing at home. Anderson Insurance Agency specializes in all things insurance, offering superior coverage from more carriers than any other local agency. Not only will you love our great rates - you'll immediately see the difference that comes from working with our dedicated insurance professionals. Whether you have a waterfront, rental, vacation home or primary residence, we can help you secure the protection you need.
Protect the financial investment you've made in your primary residence or vacation home with comprehensive homeowners plans from Anderson Insurance. Insuring property along the New Jersey coast can be a challenge for many insurance agents and companies. Anderson Insurance Agency started writing coverage at the New Jersey coast in 1967, providing our clients with superior coverage through quality insurance companies. Over the years, our commitment and promises to our clients has been tested and proven.
Your home is an investment deserving the protection that only an experienced insurance professional can provide. Let us help you decide the best coverage that is right for you. A homeowners policy is a form of package policy as it includes property and liability insurance in one policy. The first coverage part is the property insurance for the house, detached structures and contents, which include furniture, appliances and clothing. The policy provides coverage for loss caused by a wide variety of perils including windstorms, fire, lightning, smoke, hail, theft and much more.
Reviews (10)
Write a Review
Charlie Bruno
Jun 23, 2022
During my Sandy Storm renovation one of your agents, Isabel, really went above and beyond, doing lots of leg work to get things done and issues resolved with insurance carriers. It was a very stressful and trying time back then and having her working on my behalf was very reassuring.
Mary Scott-Willis
Jun 23, 2022
Excellent service and very professional. Marilyn Groom is very knowledgeable and customer oriented.
Richard J. Pappas
Jun 21, 2022
We are more than pleased with Anderson Agency since we have been with them over 50 years. They have set the standard for insurance companies giving us the best rates and customer service.
Anthony Armenti
Jun 20, 2022
This insurance agency is top notch. Whenever you call them someone answers to help you. We have been with them when hurricane Sandy hit our home and the adjuster was at our home in a timely manner.
Mark S.
Apr 05, 2022
Patricia Mathis, I got to say that I am really p*ssed off at you and the Anderson Insurance Agency. I had sent you an email on, March 9, 2022, letting you know that the check was sent out in the mail, on the same day for $2,089.50, the extra amount due for the McMahon Agency's insurance audit. Not only did you threaten to cancel our policy, but you collected the payment two times from us.

I received an email from you on March 18, 2022, saying that you didn't receive the extra payment for the McMahon Agency's insurance audit, however on March 16, 2022, two days earlier then your email, Anderson Insurance had already cashed the check that I had sent. Proof of both payments are attached. If I didn't check my bank statement, Anderson Insurance would've kept the extra $2,089.50 paid, without doing anything, unless we brought it to your attention.

As late as March 21, 2022 you still said that you would send the check back, when you received it, but of course, you couldn't because you cashed it already. I am totally exasperated by the way Anderson Insurance Agency handled this and tried to cover it up as if nothing was do wrong on your part.
Rosemarie Deal
Mar 06, 2022
Marilyn Groom has handled our Flood Insurance for many years. However since 1992 we had Liberty Mutual for all our various other policies, and have become increasing dissatisfied with them on many levels. Based on our past experience with Marilyn and Anderson, we decided to turn all our policies over to them. Our first policy is slightly complicated. Marilyn provided several quotes, then revised quotes as needed.

Ultimately her efforts resulted in higher limits of coverage and at a reduced premium from that we had been paying! In addition, Marilyn was a delight to work with, very professional, and no number of questions we had, were too many to ask! Much thanks to Marilyn and the Anderson Agency.
MaryEllen Foley
Nov 28, 2021
Marie is fabulous! She is always available to promptly answer questions and ALWAYS looks out for the best interests of her clients! And if for any reason she isn't available, her teammates step in to help. Marie makes sure we have the best coverage possible. Our family has been with AIA for over 40 years! Needless to say, I highly recommend AIA!
James Sausto
Nov 07, 2021
Truly outstanding service! Patti Potterton was my agent and she couldn't have been more helpful. Fast, friendly and efficient.my experience was seamless. I will continue to be a customer here in the future. Sincerely, Jim Sausto
Julianne Venezia
Sep 19, 2021
Simple. We were with Anderson Agency, rep Patti P. and left to try to save $'s at Progressive.nightmares began and never ended.zero customer service. Went back to Patti @ Anderson Agency after 1 year with Progressive. She took care of all our insurance needs. One stop, professional, personable, wonderful, easy insurance shopping. :o Back at my happy place. The Anderson Agency.
Patricia Strauch
Jan 02, 2021
Patti at Anderson is always looking out for us! She is so responsive to our calls. And works diligently to be sure that we have the best current policy for both our homeowners and flood policies, with the best rates available. Always take the time to explain the differences between the different options and makes sure that I am comfortable with making the correct choice.