Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Gibbel Insurance Agency Owning a rental property can be an excellent investment opportunity. In fact, over 11% of the U.S. population are landlords. This group of over 28 million American investors have realized the income potential of renting out single family homes, multi-unit apartments, and dwellings of all sorts. Selling your home can be a stressful process, especially when it doesn't move quickly.

With a new job looming, you may have no choice but to leave the home vacant for a short time until it sells. The problem? Vacant homes fall under different insurance rules and can leave you at risk.
Follow us
Services
In the 1920's the Harleysville Mutual Insurance Company contracted with Hershey & Gibbel for their services as Managing General Agents. This relationship grew and prospered for over 60 years. While serving the Lititz community, the Hershey & Gibbel local insurance agency developed into a professional, full service, independent insurance office.
Ethan Gibbel serves as President and 4th generation owner of Gibbel Insurance. He is focused on commercial insurance and employee benefits business development. He has been part of the Gibbel team since 2004. Ethan is a 2002 alumni of Juniata College with a BS in Business Management. His favorite part of his role at Gibbel Insurance is building relationships in the community and partnering with business owners to protect their assets and control their costs.In his spare time, Ethan and his wife can be found traveling, riding trails on their mountain bikes, doing triathlons, and every once in a while getting to the beach to ride some waves.
Gibbel Insurance Agency is proud to provide outstanding insurance products at unbeatable rates to Lancaster County and beyond. Whether you're looking for Auto Insurance Coverage, Homeowner's Insurance Coverage, or Life Insurance Coverage, we have you covered and know how to protect your personal liability!
Your home is one of the most important investments you will ever make, so be sure to protect it with the right property insurance. At Gibbel Insurance we help you create a policy centered around your unique needs and budget, but we also make sure that your home is insured so that you can rebuild if a claim ever occurs.
Reviews (12)
Write a Review
Alicia Labuski
Jan 14, 2022
While purchasing a new home, Gibbel Insurance was recommended by my real estate agent. I was looking into two other agencies when I originally talked to Bill Barshinger about setting up a homeowner's policy. Bill was the only agent to get back to me in a timely manner and provide me with an affordable policy. During a time when everything is automatic and owned by large corporations, it is refreshing to work with a local company and talk to local people.

While I hope I do not have to file any claims in the near future, I am confident that my future interactions with Gibbel Insurance will be as pleasant as my original interaction with Bill, and I will recommend their services.
Rebecca Spatz
Jun 19, 2021
Gibbel Insurance has been our insurance agency/broker for more than 14 years. They have always been responsive and provided great customer service. Carol is absolutely the best! She takes the time to answer your questions, explain coverage options and keeps your interest in mind all while remaining calm & professional. Rates are competitive and customized coverages are provided.
Darylanne Boyle
Apr 25, 2021
I've used Gibbel Insurance for years and years. Always a great company to deal with and so professional! Today I had the pleasure to start my day with Beverly Leontis! She emailed me reminding me of my upcoming auto policy renewal. She said she could save me hundreds and that's exactly what she did! . My upcoming bill was $845.00 for 6 months. now it's $495.00!

With the same company no less! Happy Friday to me! Beverly was absolutely wonderful! Worked most of her day on my policy with the utmost professionalism and knowledge and a wonderful personality! Bev was my angel for today! Thank you Bev!
Jack Rutt
Apr 20, 2021
Having recently moved to Lititz from another state I was, of course, needing to establish new property, casualty and general liability personal insurance. My research identified a number of very reputable agencies in and around Lititz. I made inquiries to three and all came back promptly with very professional and competitive proposals. Then a friend asked if I had inquired with Gibbel Insurance here in town.

I had not, so I used their website to request a proposal. I soon received a phone call from Ethan who asked questions that gave him more details of my situation but also indicated he wanted to make sure he would have products that would offer a competitive proposal, which would be my fourth to consider. When I received Ethan's proposal soon after our phone call, it was clear that he had thoughtfully considered all of our personal insurance needs and proposed a company and products that were even more competitive than the others I had previously received.

I then researched the company he was proposing which confirmed they were in good standing with their business practices and customer service in the community. I can recommend the Gibbel agency without hesitation.
Margaret Conner
Feb 24, 2021
Mr. Gibbel was able to assist me in both my auto and homeowners insurance needs for years. I recommend Gibbel Insurance Agency to everyone! They care about their customers and take the time to make sure all your needs are taken care of in a timely and professional matter.
Synergy Auto
Jan 22, 2021
The level of service I receive from Gibbel Insurance Agency exceeds that of any vendor I've worked with. The team is top notch, and I cannot recommend them highly enough.
Dan Oberholtzer
Jan 19, 2021
Thanks to carol for keeping an eye on my existing auto insurance and finding me an alternative policy with the same coverage and great savings!
Jana Becker
Jul 07, 2020
Fantastic customer service. Each person I've dealt with here has went above and beyond to help me get the best rate and provides all of the information I need to make a decision. Highly recommend working with GIbbel Insurance!
Michael Manthei
Nov 06, 2019
Switching to Gibbel Insurance literally saved me thousands of dollars! I love that they work with many different carriers so they can shop for the best rate/coverage for my specific needs. Twice in the last year, when renewal came up, instead of renewing the same coverage, they had found me a better carrier for less money! Great service, I am grateful!
Valonda Banks
Sep 19, 2019
I have appreciated working with Ethan. His quotes, were timely, well-explained and cost effective! He was patient with questions, made great referrals and was the best to work with when stacked against the other agencies we called. He was a referral from our attorney and it was a GREAT one!
Michael Brenneman
May 15, 2018
We have all of our insurance policies through Gibbel Insurance. That includes our homeowners, auto, and hazard insurance on all of our rental properties. There's also an umbrella policy to cover us in case of a really serious liability. Plus we have errors and omissions insurance for one of our businesses, and workman's comp and liability for the other business.

The staff at Gibbel Insurance is pleasant and professional, and they respond quickly any time I have a question or concern. And if that weren't enough, when I first brought my business to Gibbel Insurance, they saved a significant amount of money compared to what I had been paying. If you haven't engaged Gibbel Insurance to review your existing insurance needs, I highly recommend that you do so.
Takisha
Jan 10, 2017
Super professional and courteous agents! Gibbel Insurance Agency is wonderful! They gave us a FREE quote and comparison chart for a policy we were paying too much for, and we were UNDER insured! They saved us $300 AND gave us BETTER coverage! We also reviewed our rental property policy and we were apparently paying DOUBLE and way OVER insured! They were able to get us the correct coverage and saved us over $1000!