Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
The Most Insurance Agency is a family run and operated Insurance Agency in the Tampa Bay area. We have proudly served Tampa Bay since 1973, are a proud representative of several major firms, and are licensed in the state of Florida to sell insurance. It is the desire of the Most Insurance Agency to supply superior service and products for our clients, new and old alike.
Reviews (13)
Write a Review
Bill N.
Jun 09, 2022
Our home was insured with Most as our Broker. We received an email from Most that or home insurance company was "being ordered to liquidate" and that our insurance would continue for only 24 more days. Also in the email "Do not worry! We are working to secure replacement coverage for you and your account manager will be reaching out shortly to review options with you." I did not hear from Most and called them a few days the date our insurance was supposed to disappear and asked them about the replacement coverage.

They said they sent an email (which I never received) saying they couldn't find replacement coverage because my roof was too old. They were uninterested in helping me and finally hung up on me. I'm afraid most failed me as my broker and would not recommend them.
Anne Zietlow
Mar 20, 2022
Extremely high rates given to me as "best quotes, " terrible communication, error-prone work. I thought it was just the agent I had, so I switched to another, only to be given even higher quotes. Do not waste your time; I wasted a year of mine.
Cheryl Martin
Dec 28, 2021
Melissa is always been very professional she's always gone the extra mile to help every time I call in a panic she's always straightened it right out she just awesome amazing I couldn't be so lucky thanks Melissa for all your hard work
Carol Edgerley
May 30, 2021
I had an unique problem with my home insurance and had been frustrated by my efforts to secure new insurance. Without any appointment I walked into Most Insurance and Melissa Furr spent a great deal of her time and energy in finding a company to insure me. Melissa was kind, caring and professional and I am very grateful that within the space of a few hours of one day my insurance problem is no longer a problem.
ONick Wielander
Mar 21, 2021
Tammy represents your company VERY WELL! Tammy is fast in getting me information. She responds quickly and follows through and does not let details slip through the cracks. I have never had to call and "remind" Tammy about what I need. She calls and reminds me when it is renewal time. Just this past week I needed To add an additional insured to the policy and I connected to me by email to my customer and she took care of everything! I AM SO GRATEFUL! Tammy is fast and very professional! Tammy makes working with Most Insurance a pleasure! I am recommending Most Insurance to my friends!
Max & Kendra Llama
Jan 02, 2021
Tammy Guy at Most Insurance was very helpful, friendly, and very prompt. She got us a great quote for our new church. We are very relieved and happy with our policy.
Naomi Gee
Nov 09, 2020
Melissa Furr at Most Insurance provided me with Exceptional Customer Service!. She listens well to my needs, provided alternative solutions and suggested the best insurance solution. She's very professional, understanding, friendly and very knowledgeable. I definitely recommend Most Insurance to family and friends. I've been with Most Insurance for over 10 years where I've always received the BEST CUSTOMER SERVICE ever! Thank you Melissa and Most Insurance
Ken Farley
Jun 01, 2020
Most Insurance was very professional and knowledgeable about every aspect of my insurance needs. I am so grateful for Melissa Furr and her consultation in helping me choose the best coverage for my family and business. The money that I am saving in premiums is unbelievable. Again, Thank You, Melissa and Most Insurance for everything. Highly Recommended!
Clay Walkup
Mar 07, 2020
I have had good service and I have had great service but until I worked with Jennifer McKenzie, I didn't know what phenomenal service was. She always goes above and beyond in every way to help me. I can't say enough about how caring and concerned she is that you are treated right and get the best coverage at the best price. If you need insurance, and who doesn't, go see Jennifer at Most Insurance!
Jesse Burchill
Dec 01, 2019
Jennifer was so helpful and prompt in helping evaluate options for our home insurance. She took the time to explain every step in the process and make sure that we had the needed coverage for the worst case scenario, which, let's face it, you need in Florida! She definitely made me feel like she personally cared about making sure we had the right coverage with the right provider at the best price rather than just writing the policy that would benefit her most! Thanks for being awesome, Jennifer!
David T.
Oct 05, 2018
Jennifer at Most Insurance helped me find auto insurance quickly, with the right coverage, from a reputable company and at the best price. I've been using Most Insurance from when I lived in Tampa nearly 20 years ago and they have always treated me right.
Matt R.
Dec 22, 2017
Great insurance company. When I first moved to FL I searched for an insurance agent and Google turned up Most Insurance. I took a ride over and while explaining to the receptionist my situation having just moved to FL the owner Bob overheard our discussion and came out of his office, shook my hand, and introduced himself. From there I was turned over to Corey who helped set me up with a new policy for the state of FL.

Quick and easy. From then on whenever I had a question or needed to update my policy Corey was only a phone call or email away and would get things taken care of with the quickness. Great dude. Since they've relocated their office I've been dealing with Jennifer and I couldn't ask for a better agent. Simply put she is amazing at what she does and has saved me a bunch of money. Very friendly and funny too. I highly recommend Most Insurance and I will remain a customer as long as I live in the Tampa Bay area.
Daniel R.
Feb 08, 2013
Eric, You guys have a great team. Jenn is always very helpful and very attentive. You all do a great job keeping up with my needs and are always offering good advice as well as great customer service. I enjoy being one of your customers. Dan Roberts