Penwell Insurance and Erie Insurance are dedicated to maintaining a high level of excellence and founding a strong relationship of mutual trust and service to all of our customers. Penwell Insurance is situated in Cicero, Indiana, and serves customers in Indiana and Illinois.

Contact Details

  City Cicero , IN
  Zip Code 46034
  Address 30 South Peru Strt
  Phone Number (317) 984-3300

  • I would recommend this business

At my age, I've worked with a few insurance companies and agents, but never have I received the special attention that Craig Penwell and his team have provided. My wife and I are business owners and protection is key. We trust Penwell Insurance with everything from our personal, auto and home insurance needs as well as our business policies. Penwell Insurance's focus and attention to detail to our specific needs is why we refer everyone we know to them!

Value for money
Service & support
Overall ratingExcellent