Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
State Automobile Insurance Agency We take pride in providing our commercial insurance customers with excellent coverage and great service. Coyne Insurance is dedicated to providing quality insurance products that keep you protected. Contact Coyne Insurance Agency customer service via email, online, phone, or in person today! Since 1921, we have provided Ohio consumers and businesses with outstanding personal service and competitive, comprehensive insurance protection.

We'll help you take the mystery out of insurance buying, provide clear answers and provide sensible solutions to your coverage needs.
Services
With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you. Some of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.
You have saved me money, with many different insurance options and policies, I feel like you care about saving me money and getting me the best coverage. Stephen has been a great help to us. He was able to lower our premiums for us when we first started with Coyne Insurance, and has continued to provide us with very reasonably priced insurance.
Reviews (14)
Write a Review
Melvin Jenkins
May 23, 2022
Very nice and pleasant staff, very professional, truly clean and organized building, looks great inside and out everyday. Rates for car insurance, since last November last year, suddenly became doubled in cost - for no apparent reason. Thank goodness for competition, I was able to find insurance with a major company, for one half the cost. I hated to leave Coyne after 45 plus years with coverage with them for car insurance, but money is tighter these days, and every penny matters.
Jennifer Kirby
Dec 29, 2020
Easy to work with and very personable! We have had our business liability and auto coverage with Coyne Insurance for more than 5 years. We have since added some other policies with Coyne. Stephen and the staff have been super to work with. They have been very thorough with our coverages; helping us find the right protection for our budget. Stephen is quick to respond to our questions and needs, which come up more often than you would think. Insurance is one of my least favorite things to deal with but Stephen, Emma and Amanda make it not so bad.
Cyndi Hotaling
Dec 22, 2020
When my old insurance company opted out of the private insurance business I started looking around for new coverage. Coyne found me BETTER insurance at a rate below what I had previously been paying. Amanda Archer is very responsive to her customers, she answered all my questioned and made my transition to their office seamless. I highly recommend this office to anyone.
Tracey Shonkwiler
Nov 21, 2020
They got me BETTER coverage for about the same price I was paying before. Very friendly and went out of their way to find me the best deal without so many out of pocket expenses.
Alex Hesse
Nov 07, 2020
Working with Stephen and Coyne Insurance has been a great experience. Being in insurance myself, it is a pleasure to be able to trust someone to do what is right in any situation. It is obvious that Stephen and this group are always there for their clients and will do what they can to put their clients in the best circumstances possible.
Spencer Ribar
Oct 18, 2020
I have always received great help when I needed to get insurance for my apartment. They make the experience easy, and what's even easier is re-upping the following year! I called to change my policy and to make sure I had enough coverage, and the entire process took minutes. I would really recommend Coyne Insurance Agency for your insurance needs!
Jay Clawson
Sep 01, 2020
Emma went above and beyond on this memorial day weekend. I needed my declaration page to take receipt of a car prior to purchasing. She went in on a Sunday and sent it to the dealer. I have an insurance agency for life. Thank you very much.
Jessica Cutter
Aug 13, 2020
I recently switched from Progressive to USAA but while I had Progressive this agency was very polite and helpful
Eileen Girdwood
Jun 30, 2020
We have done insurance business with Coyne Insurance Agency since 2001. Recently Stephen Johns and his wife took over the agency and we have been so pleased with the seamless transition. They handle all of our insurance needs from business, to auto, to home, to liability. They are alert for any changes we may need in coverage as our business and family needs change and they shop the best rates for us. Highly recommend Stephen Johns and Coyne Insurance Agency!
Jeromy M. Johnson
May 22, 2020
Amazing staff and responsiveness. Coyne offers great service and is wonderful to work with.
Barry Bagels Kettering
Nov 10, 2019
Coyne Insurance treats us very well - we're not just another number to them, rather a relationship and a partnership. We appreciate that Stephen visits our business and takes the time to explain our coverages and benefits. Coyne Insurance supports us as one small business to another.
Paula Burlile
Nov 09, 2019
The company continually and proactively seeks comparable coverage across Providers for best cost savings on their own accord. If a situation changes and they can offer better price, they reach out to you with the new data automatically without you having to ask them. The business is transparent in options to choose that are not only available but what makes sense to the customer to ensure peace of mind and affordability.

My questions are never dismissed and usually quickly handled by the very hands-on Owner himself. I am very thankful to have found Coyne Insurance Agency!.and yes.they insure boats too, yea!
Pete St Jean Ohio
Nov 07, 2019
We have been with Coyne Insurance since 2004. They take care of all our business and personal insurance needs. They give outstanding customer service and are always very nice. I would highly recommend!
Jennifer Long
Oct 23, 2019
We have been working with Coyne Insurance for our personal & professional insurance needs for many years and have always been very pleased with their service. They are responsive & professional when dealing with claims or questions about coverage and always willing to go the extra mile.