Insurance Companies in Carthage, IL

Comprehensive list of Carthage, Illinois based auto, life, home, business and health insurance brokers and companies.

Business Listings

Our goal is to supply personalized service to our clients with broad coverage at competitive prices, which promote stability and continuous growth for our firm. The idea of Mutual insurance came out of a long history of neighbors helping neighbors in adversity. Although mutual insurance has grown and changed over time, the basic concept is still the same.


Greater Midstates Insurance Agency is by design an exceptional cluster. The ownership rests with three independent agencies all situated in the State of Illinois. The three owners have a common desire to remain independent and to address personal markets, products, cost, containment, automation, etc. The four owners serve the Corporation in various capacities as an officer, manager or both.



It has been built to help you with all your requirements. Our agency serves clients in West Central Illinois with farm, crop, home, auto, high-risk auto, motorcycle, recreational vehicles, health, Medicare supplements and commercial insurance. We pride ourselves in giving more individual service to our clients.


Yingling & Nuessen Insurance Agency was set up in April of 1996 as part of a group of seven independent insurance agencies serving West Central, Central and Southern Illinois called the Insurancenter Group. The purpose of the Insurancenter Group is to supply superb insurance service and products to insurance consumers through major firms that smaller agencies would not have approach to alone.


Willis Insurance Agency is the continuance of several Independent Insurance Agencies that have conducted insurance business in the Brown County area for many years, the oldest agency dating back to 1916. Insurance service can be accessed through our office at 101 W Main St., Mt. Sterling or you may contact Brian Floyd who makes sure his customers have approach to his cell phone at all times.


Cason, Huff & Schlueter is an independent insurance agency that has been in business since 1923. We work with several A rated insurance firms in order to supply you adequate coverage at an competitive price. We pride ourselves with delivering superb client service to our clients.


The DeSollar & Wessler Bros Agency is an independent agency licensed in the State of Illinois, that is capable to deliver full coverage service to our customers. No need to shop around for different kinds of insurance; we sell and service all kinds. Our mission is to supply the best quality insurance and real estate related services possible to the people who have been our neighbors and friends for

  • Some of the best insurance I have ever had. Make sure that you ask for WILL DeSOLLAR when

To supply our customers with superb service and an expert experience of the many products available in the insurance marketplace today. To supply quality products at a reasonable price. We aim to gain your trust that we'll stand between you and loss.