Insurance Companies in New Castle, IN

Comprehensive list of New Castle, Indiana based auto, life, home, business and health insurance brokers and companies.

Business Listings

Situated in New Castle, Indiana, The Pfenninger Agency has served customers across the midwestern US since 1902. Unlike captive agents who only represent one firm, our agency gives you a choice of insurance firms so that we can tailor fit your requirements to the correct insurance firm. We provide you appropriate coverage with competitive prices.


Are you driving a vehicle without proper insurance? Do you feel like you're paying too much for the insurance you carry? Are you in search of low rates on quality home insurance? If you answered yes to any of these questions, A. F. Stevens & Associates are here to aid.


Whatever you choose to call it, we supply the proper protection and service that you deserve. We provide a huge range of horse insurance products on a national basis. Our horse farm insurance program is available in forty-four states, and our liability and equine mortality insurance programs are available in forty-nine states.



Situated in the Old Earl Everett home on the banks of White River and easily accessible from all areas of Muncie the converted home fits with the emphasis on old fashion client support. Naze Perry Insurance has been managed by the same family for two generations. Owners Dick and Kathy Naze are pleased to represent firms they believe share that dedication to their clients.


Since January,1984, Randy Hayden has been aiding the Delaware County community with all their insurance requirements. Hayden Insurance supplies guidance in purchasing and handling auto, home, and business insurance. Randy is a life-time resident of Muncie. A Muncie Central graduate, he gained a degree in marketing from Ball State University.


Burnett Benefits is a complete website for your personal and tiny group health insurance requirements. We provide FREE instant online insurance quotes and applications from major health insurance carriers.


Payne Insurance Agency has been helping families and businesses in Indiana with all of their insurance requirements for over 49 years. We supply our clients old fashioned client service utilizing several of today's newest technologies to supply you the individual service that you deserve.


Our agency is truly a one-stop insurance center. All of your individual, business, life or health insurance requirements can be met with one visit to our office. We will tailor a specific insurance program to suit your specific requirements. We want a long-term relationship with you, so our focus is on quality products and perfect service. Let us show you how we can be of service to you.