Business Details
17 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Elizabethville, PA
Keystone-Deibler, Straub & Troutman Insurance has been a trusted partner in risk management since 2009, serving Pennsylvania communities with comprehensive insurance solutions. As an independent agency, we leverage relationships with multiple carriers to deliver personalized coverage and competitive rates tailored to individual and business needs. Our team of certified professionals, including CIC and CWCA designees, specializes in auto, home, health, life, and commercial insurance, including niche areas like contractors' liability and event coverage. With a focus on proactive client education and policy optimization, we simplify insurance decisions while maintaining a local, family-oriented approach. Our partnership with Keystone Insurers Group, the second-largest insurance agency network in the U.S., enhances our ability to secure favorable terms for clients.We prioritize transparent communication, prompt claims assistance, and annual policy reviews to ensure evolving needs are met. Recognized by Trusted Choice for industry excellence, our agency combines national resources with hometown service. From personal lines like flood insurance to complex commercial packages, we deliver peace of mind through customized protection strategies. Our commitment to continuous professional development ensures clients receive informed guidance aligned with regulatory standards and market trends. For over 15 years, we've built lasting relationships by prioritizing client needs over carrier interests.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Medicare Insurance
Commercial Auto
General Liability
Workers' Compensation
Event Insurance
Flood Insurance
Details
- Year established: 2009
Highlights and features
- We offer personalized insurance solutions tailored to Pennsylvania residents' unique needs.
- Our agency holds Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and Certified Workers' Comp Associate (CWCA) designations.
- We secure competitive rates through partnerships with multiple top-tier insurance carriers.
- Our team provides dedicated claims support and annual policy reviews for evolving needs.
- We maintain A+ ratings with the Better Business Bureau for ethical business practices.
Associations and certifications
- Trusted Choice
What people say
Great coverage at affordable prices
Immediate responses to questions
Pleasant young lady with smile
Quick claims processing within hours
Dedicated team of professionals
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect Pennsylvania drivers with customizable liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options. We offer specialized plans for classic cars, motorcycles, and commercial fleets while maintaining competitive rates through carrier partnerships. Our agents help clients navigate state requirements and select appropriate coverage limits.
Home Insurance
We provide homeowners and renters insurance covering property damage, liability, and additional living expenses. Our policies include options for flood, earthquake, and windstorm coverage in high-risk Pennsylvania areas. Annual policy reviews ensure protection evolves with property value changes and client needs.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions include BOP policies, general liability, and workers' compensation for Pennsylvania companies. We specialize in contractors' insurance, event liability, and industry-specific packages for restaurants, healthcare providers, and technology firms. Risk assessment services help businesses identify and mitigate potential losses.
Medicare Insurance
We assist Pennsylvania residents with Medicare Part A/B enrollment and supplemental policy selection. Our specialists explain coverage options, prescription drug plans, and cost-sharing requirements while providing ongoing support for policy adjustments during open enrollment periods.
Commercial Auto
Our commercial auto policies cover business vehicles including trucks, delivery vans, and service vehicles. We offer garage keepers insurance, cargo coverage, and specialized plans for food trucks and transportation companies operating throughout Pennsylvania.
People
Thomas Troutman
Agency Principal
With over 25 years in insurance, Thomas Troutman holds CIC and CWCA certifications. He oversees agency operations and strategic direction while maintaining active client relationships. His expertise includes commercial risk management and workers' compensation solutions.
Robin Straub
Agency Principal
Robin Straub, a CIC-certified professional with 20+ years experience, specializes in business insurance solutions. She focuses on construction industry coverage and commercial property risk assessment for Pennsylvania clients.
Nathan Troutman
Commercial Agent
Nathan Troutman, holding CIC, CWCA, and AAI designations, manages commercial accounts with emphasis on manufacturing and logistics insurance. He has developed specialized coverage solutions for Pennsylvania's agricultural sector.
Tara Schueck
Home & Auto Team Lead
As team lead, Tara Schueck oversees personal lines insurance with CISR certification. She specializes in homeowners insurance for high-value properties and flood risk mitigation strategies across central Pennsylvania.
Robert Gill
Commercial Insurance Agent
Robert Gill, a CIC and CWCA-certified agent, focuses on contractors insurance and small business coverage. He has helped over 500 Pennsylvania businesses implement tailored liability and property protection plans.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, Medicare, business, and specialty insurance including contractors' liability, event coverage, and commercial auto policies.
How do you find competitive insurance rates?
As an independent agency, we compare policies from multiple carriers to find optimal coverage at competitive prices tailored to your specific needs.
Do you offer Medicare enrollment assistance?
Yes, our specialists help with Medicare Part A/B enrollment, supplemental policies, and prescription drug plan selection for Pennsylvania residents.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Contact us directly at 717-362-8600 or use our online portal to initiate a claim. Our team will guide you through the process and coordinate with adjusters.
What areas do you service?
We serve Elizabethville, Harrisburg, Millersburg, Lykens, Dauphin, and all Pennsylvania counties with both personal and commercial insurance solutions.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Shane H. Ressler Sr
Jun 01, 2021
Report
They're alwayz there when you need them most! What more needz to be said? Their personnel iz friendly and feelz like family, very professional! Michelle iz an ace and I highly recommend her for your personal agent!
Mark Green
Apr 29, 2021
Report
I have been a customer for many years. I have received nothing but top notch service. I work mainly with Tara and she is awesome! I would recommend no other place for insurance than here!
Super Donkey
Mar 01, 2021
Report
We have been very pleased with the coverage choices that we have for our Home and Auto Policies. We have great coverage at affordable prices. I was very happy that Jessica called to review our coverages as it is a good reminder to tweak things/add items annually. Thank you, Jessica for full customer service!
Wendy Strohecker
Jan 08, 2021
Report
Every year at renewal time they take the time to shop around for you. And they saved me a lot of money again. You should definitely take the time to call them for an insurance quote.
Delores Hines
Dec 05, 2020
Report
My family has been insured with Deibler and company for the last 5 years. The service is top notch. We get immediate responses to our questions and we always talk with a live person. We've been asked to look at other insurance companies but we don't want to give up the incredible relationship we've established with Tara and her associates. Every chance we get we refer someone to them.
Sue Bashore
Nov 24, 2020
Report
I contacted my agent, Jessica Areford, regarding wind damage to my property. She put the claim in ASAP, and I received a call from an adjuster, Vera, within three hours. The claim is moving along quicker than I anticipated. I'm very happy with the response.
Team Rudy
Dec 11, 2019
Report
Been working with Dane for years and we couldn't be happier. We changed insurance agents every couple of years until we came here. Dane is always professional and helpful. We recommend Keystone to anyone who needs insurance.
