Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Garden City, NY
Petschauer Insurance has built a legacy of trust and expertise over six decades, offering tailored insurance solutions designed entirely around client needs. Our approach combines deep industry knowledge with a commitment to optimizing total cost of risk through comprehensive assessments and innovative strategies. We prioritize open dialogue and client feedback to ensure our services deliver measurable value, leveraging decades of market experience to secure coverage from A-rated carriers globally.Our dedicated team of professionals invests in continuous training and cutting-edge tools like ClientConnect to provide proactive, personalized service across personal, business, life, and employee benefit insurance sectors. With a heritage rooted in family values and client-centric service, we remain steadfast in our mission to protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Term Life Insurance
Commercial Bonds
Cyber Insurance
Workers Compensation
Homeowners Insurance
Annuities
Flood Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Long Term Care
Details
- Year established: 1965
Highlights and features
- We offer 60+ years of insurance expertise with A-rated carrier partnerships
- Our Total Cost of Risk Assessment optimizes coverage and cost efficiency
- Dedicated team provides proactive policy management and personalized service
- We maintain 24/7 client accessibility for urgent insurance needs
- Continuous investment in innovative tools like ClientConnect for policy transparency
What people say
Responsive and professional
Like family support
Saved money annually
Proactive renewals handled
Expertise in complex coverage
Services
Term Life Insurance
Petschauer Insurance offers customizable term life insurance policies that provide financial protection for your loved ones. Our solutions balance coverage duration and premium costs while maintaining flexibility for future adjustments. With access to multiple top-rated carriers, we help clients secure appropriate death benefits that align with their family's needs and financial goals.
Cyber Insurance
Our cyber insurance solutions protect businesses from digital threats through comprehensive coverage for data breaches and cyber attacks. We assess each client's unique risk profile to create policies covering incident response, legal liabilities, and business interruption losses. Our team stays current with evolving cyber threats to ensure adequate protection for modern businesses.
Commercial Bonds
Petschauer Insurance provides various commercial bond solutions that guarantee contractual obligations between businesses and clients. Our offerings include contract bonds, license bonds, and court bonds tailored to specific industry requirements. We work with clients to determine appropriate bond amounts while ensuring compliance with regulatory and contractual mandates.
Workers Compensation
Our workers' compensation insurance programs protect businesses and employees from work-related injury or illness costs. We offer policies that cover medical expenses, lost wages, and legal liabilities while helping clients maintain compliance with state regulations. Our team provides risk management resources to minimize workplace incidents and control premium costs.
Homeowners Insurance
Petschauer Insurance offers comprehensive homeowners insurance that safeguards against property damage, personal liability, and additional living expenses. Our policies cover standard risks like fire and theft while offering optional endorsements for specialized needs. We help clients determine appropriate coverage limits based on property value and individual risk factors.
People
Heidi Petschauer
President
Heidi Petschauer directs professional development programs and manages personal lines departments. A St. John's University graduate with a Certified Insurance Counselor designation since 1997, she leads the agency's social media strategy and team training initiatives while maintaining active client relationships.
Erwin Petschauer
Vice President
Erwin Petschauer provides risk management services to corporate clients. With an Electrical Engineering degree and Associate in Risk Management designation since 2012, he brings technical expertise to business insurance solutions while maintaining client relationships developed over three decades in the industry.
Ingrid Petschauer
Founder
Ingrid Petschauer established the agency and continues to influence its culture. As a founding member, she set the standard for client service and professional conduct that continues to shape the firm's approach to insurance consulting and community engagement.
LuAnn C. Schook
Commercial Lines Manager
LuAnn Schook manages commercial lines operations with over 25 years of insurance industry experience. A St. John's University Risk Management graduate, she specializes in commercial lines management, marketing, and underwriting while mentoring team members in best practices for business insurance solutions.
Mathew Kryder
Insurance Advisor
Mathew Kryder advises clients on life and long-term care insurance solutions. With an MBA in Finance from Baruch College, he joined Petschauer in 2018 to build on his passion for family and business protection, developing customized insurance strategies that address both immediate and future needs.
Questions
What types of insurance does Petschauer offer?
Petschauer provides commercial insurance (cyber, workers' comp, property), personal insurance (auto, home, umbrella), life insurance (term, permanent), annuities, and specialty coverage like classic car insurance.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Report claims directly to Petschauer through their website or contact their office. The team will guide you through documentation requirements and coordinate with insurance carriers to process your claim efficiently.
Do you offer online policy management?
Yes, Petschauer provides ClientConnect - an online portal for policyholders to access documents, make payments, and manage insurance data securely from any location.
What areas do you serve?
While based in Garden City, NY, Petschauer serves clients nationwide with insurance solutions tailored to specific state regulations and regional risk profiles.
How are policy premiums determined?
Premiums depend on coverage type, risk assessment, policy limits, and client-specific factors. Petschauer's team analyzes these elements and shops multiple A-rated carriers to find competitive pricing.
Can I get multiple insurance policies bundled?
Yes, Petschauer offers multi-policy bundling options that often provide cost savings. Their consultants help identify complementary coverages that work together efficiently for personal or business needs.
Videos
Reviews (5)
Denise Whittam
Aug 31, 2021
Report
Heidi and Alison were so professional; extremely focused, but most of all patient and compassionate. They both were prompt in answering my questions, and explained things in a simple manner, which I found very comforting! Excellent customer service, professional and knowledgeable!
Ann Kittredge
Jul 23, 2021
Report
My Rep, Sherri, is the bomb. Have been working with her for almost 2 decades. She really is attentive and responsive and takes the time to review my policies to see if she can get me better rates. I am SOOOOO lucky to have her.
Susan Adams
Jun 25, 2021
Report
We've been dealing with this company for many, many years and have been extremely pleased with the service we receive. We've moved out of town and then moved back and wouldn't dream of having anyone but Petshauer take care of our insurance needs. Lori Halloran has been our agent and at this point it's like speaking with a close friend! She is super personable, efficient and returns calls or emails promptly! Don't look anywhere else! This is the insurance company for you!
Carol Mills
May 15, 2021
Report
Petschauer always takes care of all my insurance needs. Especially when I call last minute. With a smile! They are very good about answering all my questions. I would absolutely recommend them.
Kerry Bowen
May 07, 2021
Report
We have been with Petshcauer for 30 years largely due to our agent Lori Halloran. She is pleasure to deal with, always professional and responds to all our inquiries in a very timely manner.
