Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Services in Buford, GA
Sutter McLellan & Gilbreath operates as an independent insurance agency dedicated to fostering strategic partnerships among clients, carriers, and the local community. Our approach emphasizes tailored services and transparent communication, ensuring programs are designed to meet client expectations. Since 1953, we have served businesses and families across Metro Atlanta and Georgia, expanding our offerings to include commercial, personal, life, and health insurance. Our commitment includes claims management, loss control, and cost-effective solutions by consolidating coverages into cohesive programs. We prioritize simplified pricing, proactive cost communication, and customized strategies to enhance client programs.In 2022, we joined Alera Group, a national firm, to further our growth and service capabilities. Our clients benefit from our deep regional knowledge, combined expertise, and a focus on addressing evolving insurance needs with clarity and precision. We maintain rigorous standards in negotiations, account administration, and client education, ensuring alignment with industry best practices. With a team of licensed professionals, we deliver comprehensive solutions backed by decades of local and national experience.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Builders Risk Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Employee Benefits
Details
- Year established: 1953
Highlights and features
- We offer over 70 years of experience in insurance solutions for Georgia clients.
- Our team provides personalized strategies through strategic client-carrier partnerships.
- We consolidate coverages to eliminate redundant costs and simplify pricing.
- Our affiliation with Alera Group enhances our national service capabilities.
- We prioritize proactive communication to avoid unexpected insurance costs.
What people say
Knowledgeable staff
Great coverage options
Personalized service
Competitive rates
Professional team
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance policies tailored to individual and commercial needs. Our coverage includes liability protection, collision and comprehensive coverage, uninsured motorist protection, and custom options to suit diverse driving risks. With access to multiple carriers through our independent agency status, we offer competitive rates and specialized solutions for personal vehicles, fleets, and high-risk drivers.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect residential properties against common risks like fire, theft, and weather damage. Coverage includes dwelling protection, personal property coverage, liability protection, and additional living expenses during displacement. We offer customizable options for standard homes, high-value properties, and unique structures, ensuring tailored protection aligned with Georgia's specific risk landscape.
Life Insurance
We offer term, whole, and universal life insurance products to meet various financial planning needs. Our solutions provide death benefit protection, cash value accumulation, and estate planning benefits. With guidance from our licensed agents, clients can select policies that protect dependents, cover mortgages, or support long-term wealth transfer strategies through trusted carrier partnerships.
Health Insurance
Our health insurance offerings include individual plans, family coverage, and Medicare solutions. We assist clients in selecting policies that balance premium costs, deductibles, and provider networks to meet healthcare needs. With expertise in ACA-compliant plans and supplemental insurance, we help navigate enrollment and coverage changes while ensuring access to necessary medical services.
Builders Risk Insurance
We specialize in builders risk policies protecting construction projects during development. Coverage includes structural damage protection, theft, vandalism, and weather-related losses for residential and commercial construction. Our policies accommodate varying project sizes, timelines, and risk profiles, with options for soft costs and equipment coverage to safeguard investments throughout the building process.
People
Drew Gilbreath
Managing Partner
Drew Gilbreath leads Sutter McLellan & Gilbreath as Managing Partner, overseeing strategic operations and client relationships. With extensive insurance experience and a CIC designation, he ensures the agency maintains high service standards while adapting to industry changes. His leadership focuses on strengthening carrier partnerships and expanding service capabilities through innovation.
Judy Shaw
Senior Partner
Judy Shaw, a Senior Partner, brings decades of insurance expertise to Sutter McLellan & Gilbreath. Holding a CIC designation, she specializes in commercial risk management and client advocacy. Her career focuses on developing tailored insurance strategies for Georgia businesses, leveraging deep market knowledge to deliver cost-effective solutions and exceptional client service.
Chris Taylor
Account Executive
Chris Taylor serves as an Account Executive with CIC, CRM, and CPCU designations. He specializes in commercial insurance solutions, working closely with clients to identify risks and implement comprehensive coverage strategies. His approach emphasizes clear communication, proactive problem-solving, and leveraging industry expertise to optimize client protection.
Becky Nigh
Commercial Lines Manager
Becky Nigh, Commercial Lines Manager, holds AU, AIC, and CISR designations. She focuses on commercial insurance programs, balancing client needs with carrier requirements. Her expertise includes risk assessment, policy structuring, and claims advocacy, ensuring Georgia businesses receive tailored protection while maintaining cost efficiency and regulatory compliance.
Brady Barron
Employee Benefits Broker
Brady Barron specializes in employee benefits as a broker, helping businesses design competitive insurance packages. With expertise in health, dental, and retirement plans, he focuses on cost-effective solutions that meet employer goals and employee needs. His approach combines industry knowledge with personalized service to optimize workplace benefits strategies.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, health, builders risk, commercial, and employee benefits insurance tailored to Georgia clients.
How do you differ from online insurance providers?
As an independent agency, we offer personalized service, multiple carrier options, and local expertise unavailable from automated platforms.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote online through our website or contact us directly via phone for personalized assistance.
Do you serve commercial clients?
Yes, we specialize in commercial insurance for Georgia businesses, including construction, manufacturing, and professional services.
What areas do you cover?
We primarily serve Metro Atlanta and throughout Georgia from our Buford headquarters.
How do I file a claim?
Contact your assigned agent or call us directly for claims assistance and guidance through the process.
Reviews (2)
Craig Sears
Feb 10, 2019
Report
Lisa Bloch with Sutter, McLellan & Gilbreath is one of the most experienced and professional insurance agents I have met in my 22 years in business. She and the team at SM&G have been there for me and my company for nearly 20 years, consistently delivering value and expertise. I have referred multiple colleagues to Lisa and SM&G, and they have all been very satisfied with the products and services they received as well.
Greg Boomershine
Dec 21, 2017
Report
Todd Souto brought me over from one of the monster insurance companies and saved me a ton of money each month on auto. I appreciate him very much and highly recommend Sutter, McLellan & Gilbreath.
