Business Details
50 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Monroeville, PA
Since 1976, Verrico Insurance Agency has been dedicated to providing comprehensive insurance solutions to businesses, families, and individuals in the Pittsburgh area and beyond. As an independent insurance broker, we prioritize helping clients secure tailored coverage at competitive rates while maintaining a commitment to prompt and courteous service. Our team of experienced professionals specializes in personal and commercial insurance products, including homeowners, auto, health, life, umbrella, and business insurance. We are proud to be a Ramsey Trusted Provider, reflecting our adherence to excellence in customer service and ethical business practices. With decades of local expertise, we guide clients through the complexities of insurance, ensuring they receive personalized support during both policy acquisition and claims resolution.Our 24/7 claims reporting system and partnerships with trusted carriers enable efficient claim processing, including lifetime repair guarantees through selected providers. We emphasize transparency in policy details and maintain open communication throughout the client journey, from initial quote to ongoing coverage adjustments. Our office hours are structured to accommodate client needs during standard business operations, with emergency services available outside these times. Through continuous education and industry engagement, our agents stay current with evolving insurance trends to better serve our community. This enduring commitment to client welfare and professional integrity has sustained our agency across generations.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Health Insurance
Commercial Property
Renter's Insurance
Employment Practices Liability
Landlord Protection
Details
- Year established: 1976
Highlights and features
- We offer 50+ years of local insurance expertise in the Pittsburgh area
- Our independent brokerage provides access to multiple top-rated carriers
- Ramsey Trusted Provider status ensures ethical business practices
- 24/7 claims reporting with lifetime repair guarantees available
- Personalized policy guidance from experienced insurance professionals
Associations and certifications
- Ramsey Trusted Provider
Services
Home Insurance
We provide comprehensive homeowners insurance protecting against property damage, liability claims, and living expenses during repairs. Our policies include customizable coverage options for dwelling protection, personal property, and additional structures. With local expertise in Pittsburgh area risks, we help clients secure appropriate limits and deductibles while maintaining competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships.
Business Insurance
Our commercial insurance solutions protect businesses against property damage, liability claims, and operational disruptions. Offerings include Business Owners Policies, commercial auto coverage, employment practices liability, and hired/non-owned auto liability. We specialize in creating customized risk management strategies for Pittsburgh area businesses, with access to specialized carriers for unique industry needs and property types.
Auto Insurance
We offer auto insurance policies covering liability, collision, and comprehensive damages for personal and commercial vehicles. Our services include assistance with claim reporting, lifetime repair guarantees through network providers, and rental car arrangements. With expertise in Pennsylvania insurance requirements, we help clients optimize coverage while maintaining affordable premiums through competitive carrier comparisons.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance offerings include term and permanent policies designed to protect families and business interests. We provide personalized consultations to determine appropriate coverage amounts based on financial obligations, future needs, and estate planning goals. As independent agents, we compare multiple carriers to find policies that balance premium costs with long-term benefits and policyholder security.
Umbrella Insurance
We offer umbrella insurance policies providing additional liability coverage beyond standard home, auto, and business policies. These plans protect against catastrophic losses and lawsuits exceeding primary policy limits. Our agents help clients assess risk exposure and select appropriate coverage tiers, ensuring comprehensive protection for personal assets and business operations through major carriers in Pennsylvania.
People
Anthony Verrico
President/Agent
Leading the agency with decades of insurance experience, Anthony oversees operations while maintaining direct client relationships. He ensures adherence to Ramsey Trusted Provider standards and guides strategic direction for the Monroeville office.
John Costa
Agent
Specializing in insurance solutions, John assists clients with policy selection and risk assessment. He brings extensive knowledge of Pennsylvania insurance regulations and maintains focus on personalized client service.
Christina Pollino
Agent/CSR (Personal Lines)
Christina manages personal insurance policies while providing customer service support. Her dual role enables efficient policy administration and client communication for homeowners, auto, and life insurance products.
Kerrie Banke
Agent/CSR (Commercial Lines)
Focusing on business insurance, Kerrie develops commercial coverage strategies while handling client service needs. She specializes in translating complex business risks into appropriate insurance solutions for Pittsburgh area companies.
Sherrie Montgomery
Agent (Commercial Lines)
Sherrie provides specialized commercial insurance expertise, helping businesses navigate liability protection and property coverage options. She works closely with clients to ensure comprehensive risk management tailored to specific industry requirements.
Questions
What types of insurance does Verrico Insurance Agency offer?
We provide home, auto, life, health, umbrella, renter's, and business insurance including commercial property, liability, and specialized business policies.
Are you available for emergency claims outside business hours?
Yes, our claims reporting system operates 24/7 with representatives typically contacting clients within two hours of claim submission.
How do you help clients find affordable insurance?
As independent agents, we compare multiple carriers to find competitive rates while tailoring coverage to individual risk profiles and budget requirements.
What makes Verrico Insurance Agency different from other providers?
Our Ramsey Trusted Provider status, local expertise since 1976, and personalized service approach distinguish us in the Pittsburgh insurance market.
Can I get insurance coverage for unique business needs?
Yes, our commercial insurance specialists create customized solutions for specialized industries and unique business exposures through multiple carrier partnerships.
How does the claims process work?
Report claims 24/7 through our carriers, receive prompt representative contact, schedule inspections at your convenience, and get lifetime repair guarantees through network providers.
Reviews (7)
Anjelica Kopsahilis
Jun 11, 2022
Report
If anyone is looking for insurance I would highly recommend Justin Ballew! My fiance and I have both had insurance claims in the last couple years. The last claim is finally coming to an end today, it wasn't fun and dealing with insurance never is. Justin handled each call with grace and was extremely quick to jump in. Calling a claim in is never a good time and like most consumers you just hope your coverage is good enough.
We have been more than covered on all aspects every time. I am glad this journey is coming to an end but honestly who knows how long it could have been dragged out without Justin going to bat against the insurance when necessary. If there's a time to work with someone you trust it's definitely when it comes to insurance. I am so grateful we were connected with Justin and look forward to continue working with him.
We have been more than covered on all aspects every time. I am glad this journey is coming to an end but honestly who knows how long it could have been dragged out without Justin going to bat against the insurance when necessary. If there's a time to work with someone you trust it's definitely when it comes to insurance. I am so grateful we were connected with Justin and look forward to continue working with him.
Nikki Lyn
Dec 02, 2021
Report
100/10 customer service and loyalty! He has been so helpful finding me the best rates to fit all the services I need between, home, vehicle and business insurance. Anytime I have called, he has answered immediately and answers all possible questions. Highly recommended!
Marisa Ciora
Mar 06, 2021
Report
I have been using Verrico Insurance Agency for over 15 years. 2 homes and 5 plus cars later, Anthony and his team saved me literally thousands of dollars on insurance policies. Anthony is truly AMAZING! He always finds me the best deal possible and just when he finds me a deal, he calls me back to say he found an even better one! His clients are his # 1 top priority and that never goes unnoticed. Nicole is just as amazing!
She ALWAYS goes above and beyond to help and do all that she can to assist me. Christina is just as helpful. I can't say enough about the Verrico Team! They are exceptional and I would feel lost without them. I absolutely LOVE Verrico Insurance Agency, and I promise, anyone that uses them would feel the same way.
She ALWAYS goes above and beyond to help and do all that she can to assist me. Christina is just as helpful. I can't say enough about the Verrico Team! They are exceptional and I would feel lost without them. I absolutely LOVE Verrico Insurance Agency, and I promise, anyone that uses them would feel the same way.
John Hamilton
Jan 14, 2021
Report
Literally the best experience I have ever had! Justin saved my company and personal insurance needs over $3,000 per year, with better coverage. I couldn't recommend him enough! Easy to work with, thorough, honest and quick to respond! Justin is the man you need to talk to if you have any desire to understand the insurance you need/have and how to save money! Do it, trust me, you won't regret it!
Melvin Wojtowicz
Dec 19, 2020
Report
Top notch insurance company. Will get you ur monies worth in insurance. Courteous n pleasant people work there. They will find you what you need
Barbara Beckert Sheffield
Jul 20, 2020
Report
After being with our agent since 1991, we were shocked that Justin was able to save us over $1000 per year for our home and auto Justin was thorough, easy to work with and fun to work with. The coverage has been amazing! Start a conversation with Justin, you won't be disappointed.
Jerrod Foster
Feb 03, 2019
Report
My family has been insured by the Verrico Insurance Agency for several years. We have always been happy with the service and continue to hold our business within their agency. As I look into additional lines of insurance for business and personal insurances they will definitely be my one stop shop for my needs. Highly suggested!
