Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Key West
Fullers Insurance has been a trusted, family-owned insurance agency serving the Florida Keys and Key West for over 45 years. Our deep-rooted commitment to personalized customer service ensures clients receive tailored home and auto insurance solutions that meet their unique needs. With specialized knowledge of Monroe County's distinct insurance regulations, we prioritize proper coverage to protect clients during losses.

As a locally-owned agency, we pride ourselves on understanding the communitys specific requirements, offering walk-in convenience without the need for appointments and ample parking to serve clients effortlessly. Our teams dedication to transparency, ethical practices, and long-term client relationships has solidified our reputation as a reliable insurance partner in the region.
Services
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Flood Insurance Windstorm Insurance Homeowners Insurance
Highlights and features
  • Family-owned agency with over 45 years of experience in Key West.
  • Specialized knowledge of Monroe County's unique insurance regulations.
  • Offering personalized service with no appointments required for walk-ins.
  • Committed to ensuring proper coverage for all clients.
Services
Home Insurance
Home insurance from Fullers Insurance protects clients' properties in the Florida Keys against damage or loss. Tailored to Monroe County's specific regulations, policies ensure comprehensive coverage for homeowners. Our local expertise helps residents navigate unique insurance requirements, providing peace of mind during emergencies.
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance policies at Fullers Insurance offer tailored protection for vehicles in Key West and the Florida Keys. Designed to meet local driving conditions, coverage includes liability, collision, and comprehensive options. Our team works closely with clients to ensure adequate protection and support during claims.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance services address the heightened risk of water damage in coastal areas like Key West. Fullers Insurance partners with leading providers to offer policies that cover flood-related losses. Our agents guide clients through the process of securing coverage and filing claims with companies such as American Bankers and Hartford.
Windstorm Insurance
Windstorm insurance at Fullers Insurance safeguards properties against hurricane and storm damage, a critical need in the Florida Keys. We collaborate with carriers like Heritage and Velocity to provide tailored policies. Clients benefit from streamlined claims assistance and localized risk expertise.
Questions
What types of insurance does Fullers Insurance offer?
Fullers Insurance provides home, auto, flood, and windstorm insurance to residents and businesses in the Florida Keys.
How can I file a claim with Fullers Insurance?
To file a claim, contact Fullers Insurance directly or reach out to the insurance company using the numbers provided on our website.
Are there payment options for insurance premiums?
Yes, you can pay premiums via credit card or personal check when purchasing policies from Fullers Insurance.
Do I need an appointment to visit the agency?
No, Fullers Insurance does not require appointments for walk-in visits during business hours.
What areas does Fullers Insurance serve?
Fullers Insurance serves Key West, Monroe County, and the broader Florida Keys region.
How does Fullers Insurance protect customer privacy?
We protect customer privacy by not sharing personally identifiable information with third parties unless authorized, and by securely handling all data.
Reviews (5)
Richard Westfall
Jun 23, 2021 Report
Been working with Jackie on a relocation and she has been great! Extremely helpful to a newcomer to KW.
Jimmy Venuto
Jun 08, 2021 Report
Wonderful staff, have giving me a break a few times when I was running a day late, also the best rate I found for insurance, also it's good to support your local insurance companies versus the big companies
Judy McGill Batchelor
May 03, 2020 Report
Been their customer since 1978. Responsive, friendly, have been huge help through several hurricane losses. Have lived in other areas of country.no one compares when it comes to customer service.
Bruce Boros
Apr 07, 2020 Report
Wonderful company to work with. Normal tells it like it is, works hard for his clients and gets the job done. Stays on top of his clients annual needs as well.
B. Evans
Jun 29, 2019 Report
Very friendly staff, but man did the quotes come in high for homeowners, wind and flood. $3k higher than other local insurance brokers, so we had to go with somebody else.