Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Oklahoma
Sullivan Insurance, founded in 1946, is a family-owned independent insurance agency based in Ardmore, Oklahoma. We serve clients across Oklahoma, Texas, Kansas, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Wyoming. Our agency specializes in commercial and personal insurance coverage, including tailored programs for Native American tribes and enterprises, agribusinesses, contractors, and religious institutions. With three generations of continuous leadership, we maintain a strong commitment to personalized service, competitive pricing, and comprehensive risk management solutions. Our team of certified professionals brings decades of combined experience in insurance product selection, policy customization, and customer support.We represent multiple insurance carriers to ensure clients receive optimal coverage at the most favorable rates while maintaining our focus on exceptional customer service. Our tribal insurance programs provide comprehensive protection for both tribal governments and enterprises, supported by a dedicated team with specialized knowledge. For agribusiness clients, we offer coverage solutions for feed mills, commercial fertilizer operations, and feedlots, leveraging industry-specific expertise. Our small business clients benefit from integrated coverage options including workers' compensation, general liability, employee benefits, and property insurance. With a legacy of over 75 years in the industry, we combine tradition with modern insurance practices to meet evolving client needs.
Services
Business Owners Policy
Commercial Auto
Workers Compensation
Tribal Insurance Programs
Agribusiness Insurance
General Liability
Commercial Property
Group Health Insurance
Personal Umbrella
Details
- Year established: 1946
Highlights and features
- Founded in 1946 with three generations of continuous insurance expertise
- Dedicated team specializing in tribal government and enterprise programs
- Licensed to serve clients across 13 states including Oklahoma and Texas
- Independent agency model compares 15+ carriers for optimal pricing
- Certified professionals with CIC, CRM, and CISR designations
What people say
Second to none service
Top notch and first class
Professional and responsive agency
Spectacular treatment of clients
Positive during difficult times
Services
Business Owners Policy
Our Business Owners Policies combine essential protections including property coverage, liability insurance, and business interruption protection tailored to small and medium-sized businesses. With customizable options and risk management consultations, we help Oklahoma-based businesses maintain compliance while protecting their assets. Our agents work with multiple carriers to ensure competitive pricing while maintaining comprehensive coverage.
Tribal Insurance Programs
Specialized insurance solutions designed for tribal governments and enterprises, including coverage for casinos, cultural facilities, and tribal business operations. Our team maintains deep understanding of tribal regulatory requirements and provides dedicated account management to ensure complete protection for sovereign entities across multiple states.
Agribusiness Insurance
Customized protection plans for agricultural operations including feed mills, commercial fertilizer facilities, and feedlots. We address unique industry risks with coverage for equipment, livestock, storage facilities, and liability protection. Our team combines insurance expertise with practical understanding of agricultural operations to deliver comprehensive solutions.
Workers Compensation
Statutory compliance coverage for workplace injuries and occupational illnesses, with tailored plans for Oklahoma businesses across construction, manufacturing, and service industries. We offer risk assessment services and safety training resources to help maintain lower premiums through proactive workplace safety programs.
Commercial Auto Insurance
Protection for business vehicles including cars, trucks, and heavy equipment with coverage options for liability, collision, and cargo protection. Our plans accommodate varying fleet sizes and usage requirements, with specialized options for contractors, delivery services, and transportation businesses operating in Oklahoma and Texas.
People
John F. Sullivan Jr.
Owner
Third-generation insurance professional with over 50 years industry experience, specializing in commercial risk management and tribal program development.
Stacy A. Sullivan
Tribal and Large Commercial Account Executive
25+ years of expertise in tribal insurance programs, holding CIC and ASCR designations, with specialized knowledge of tribal enterprise risk management.
Lena Treanor
Account Executive
Commercial lines specialist with CIC and CRM certifications, managing business insurance solutions since joining the agency in 2003.
Donna Nunley
Commercial Account Executive
Experienced commercial insurance advisor focusing on construction, manufacturing, and distribution industry coverage solutions.
Jennifer Fryar
Commercial Lines Account Manager
Certified insurance specialist (CIC, CISR) providing client support for business insurance needs since joining the agency in 2015.
Questions
What types of business insurance do you offer?
We provide Business Owners Policies, Commercial Auto, Workers Compensation, General Liability, Commercial Property, and specialized Tribal Insurance Programs.
Do you specialize in Native American tribal insurance?
Yes, we offer comprehensive tribal insurance programs covering both government operations and enterprises with dedicated account management.
Which states do you serve?
We serve clients in Oklahoma, Texas, Kansas, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Wyoming.
What about after-hours claims assistance?
Yes, we provide 24/7 claim reporting through carrier emergency numbers, with our office handling claims during regular business hours.
Can you help with Agribusiness insurance needs?
Yes, we specialize in agribusiness coverage including feed mills, commercial fertilizer operations, and feedlots with tailored risk management solutions.
Reviews (4)
American Patriot Biker
Mar 10, 2022
Report
Would never do business with a woman that hates this country so much and hates the people that deliver supplies all over the United States. I honestly cannot believe that you went out on Facebook and bad mouthed all the truckers that deliver all your supplies and things that you use and have in your life. Unbelievable.
Natosha Custard
Mar 07, 2022
Report
Shame on Stacey Sullivan and the way she had mouthed the very people that keep her supplied in almost every area of her life?! To have so little respect for a group of hard working people is despicable and honestly it's people like her who make this world the way it is! Shame shame shame Sullivan insurance
Glenn De Lancy
Dec 27, 2020
Report
This office of workers are very professional and get done what is asked of them in precise efficiency.
Kristina Lynn
Nov 30, 2015
Report
Everyone has alway been great to work with and more then happy to find an answer to your questions. Candice Richard has helped us with our commercial insurances needs for the past 4 year and Emily has recently helped us with our personal insurance. Highly Recommend them to everyone.
