Business Details
Faith-Based Insurance Solutions in Abilene, KS
Founded in 1885, Brethren Mutual Aid Agency began as a faith-based mutual insurance society rooted in Brethren principles of community support and shared responsibility. Originally formed by nine individuals in Northeastern Kansas, our organization started with humble beginnings around kitchen tables, providing aid through collective resource-sharing during times of crisis. Over 140 years of operation have transformed our reach while preserving our core mission: to provide high-quality insurance solutions through a model that prioritizes community welfare and mutual aid. Our team of licensed professionals brings extensive experience in risk management and client service, with specialized expertise in church, auto, home, renters, and farm insurance.We demonstrate authority through our long-standing reputation and commitment to responsible stewardship of financial resources. As a trusted partner for Church of the Brethren congregations and members, we maintain strict ethical standards by donating portions of premiums to humanitarian causes through our Share Fund program while delivering comprehensive coverage options. Our operational history, transparency in practices, and personalized approach to client relationships underscore our commitment to trustworthiness in every aspect of our service.
Services
Church Insurance
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Renters Insurance
Farm Insurance
Umbrella Policies
Highlights and features
- We operate with Brethren principles of mutual aid and community support since 1885
- Our insurance solutions include charitable contributions through the Share Fund program
- We provide specialized insurance for faith-based organizations and rural properties
- Our team combines modern insurance expertise with traditional values
- We maintain transparency through clear policy terms and community impact reporting
What people say
Faith-aligned values
Community-focused approach
Personalized service
Long-standing reputation
Meaningful outreach programs
Services
Church Insurance
Our Church Insurance program protects religious organizations including congregations, denominational offices, camps, and related ministries. This comprehensive coverage addresses property damage, liability, and specialized needs of faith-based institutions. We combine traditional insurance protection with our unique program of mutuality that supports community outreach initiatives.
Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance policies protect drivers and passengers against financial loss from accidents, theft, or damage. Our policies provide liability coverage, collision protection, and comprehensive benefits tailored to individual needs. We emphasize personalized service while maintaining competitive rates for standard and specialty vehicles.
Home Insurance
Home Insurance covers property damage to residential structures and personal belongings. Our policies protect against common risks like fire, storms, and theft while offering customizable options for different property types. We balance thorough coverage with affordability for homeowners across various risk profiles.
Renters Insurance
Renters Insurance protects personal property in leased residences and covers liability claims. Our policies complement landlord insurance by covering tenants' belongings and providing personal liability protection. We offer flexible terms with clear explanations about coverage limitations and benefits.
Farm Insurance
Farm Insurance provides specialized coverage for agricultural properties including equipment, livestock, and structures. Our policies address unique risks associated with rural properties and farming operations. We combine traditional insurance protection with understanding of agricultural business needs and community support principles.
People
Kimberly Rutter
General Manager
With extensive leadership experience including banking sector roles and over a decade at Brethren Mutual Aid Agency, Kimberly directs operations while maintaining client-focused service standards. Her management approach combines strategic vision with hands-on oversight of daily operations.
Heather Riffel
Client Services Manager
Bringing experience from education and customer service sectors, Heather manages client policy needs since 2021. Her patient, compassionate approach helps policyholders navigate insurance requirements while maintaining operational efficiency in service delivery.
Kristy Sare
Operations Manager
Specializing in farm services and internal operations since 2018, Kristy manages system operations and information accuracy. Her background in animal sciences and office management supports efficient policy administration while maintaining technical proficiency.
Joseph Friend
Account Manager
With prior insurance experience, Joe serves ministry and personal lines clients since 2023. His approach emphasizes client safety and comprehensive coverage while balancing technical knowledge with personalized service for diverse policyholders.
Naomie Nichols
Account Manager
Joining Brethren Mutual Aid Agency in 2023 after special education and hospitality roles, Naomie provides front-line client support. Her calm demeanor and service-oriented approach help clients with policy inquiries while maintaining accessibility for all client needs.
Questions
What makes Mutual Aid Agency different from other insurance companies?
We combine traditional insurance protection with a faith-based mutual aid model that directs portions of premiums to humanitarian causes through our Share Fund program.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide church/ministry insurance, auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance, farm insurance, and umbrella policies tailored to individual and organizational needs.
How does the Share Fund program work?
When you purchase insurance through MAA, a portion of premiums and profits fund the Share Fund, which distributes grants to individuals and organizations in need within our community.
Do you only serve religious organizations?
While we maintain strong ties to Church of the Brethren congregations, we provide insurance services to all individuals and organizations that share our values of mutual support.
What areas do you serve?
We primarily serve Church of the Brethren members nationwide while providing insurance solutions to individuals and organizations that align with our mutual aid philosophy.
