Business Details
22 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Newburgh, IN
Self Insurance Services has been dedicated to meeting the insurance needs of individuals and businesses since 2004. Our agency, based in Newburgh, Indiana, specializes in providing personalized coverage solutions across Indiana, Kentucky, Illinois, and Tennessee. With decades of combined experience, our team prioritizes competitive pricing, comprehensive protection, and exceptional customer service. We offer a wide range of insurance products, including property and casualty coverage, life insurance, employee benefits, health insurance, and commercial policies.Our mission is client-centered, ensuring that each policyholder receives tailored guidance and support. We maintain partnerships with major carriers to deliver reliable, cost-effective solutions. Our agents are committed to staying proactive in addressing evolving client needs, offering after-hours assistance when required. Through transparency, integrity, and a personalized approach, we strive to protect families and businesses while building lasting relationships within the Tri-State community.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Commercial Auto
Employee Benefits
Renters Insurance
Whole Life Insurance
General Liability
Details
- Year established: 2004
Highlights and features
- We offer 20+ years of experience in the insurance industry with a focus on personalized service.
- Our team provides access to multiple major carriers for competitive pricing and coverage options.
- We deliver 24/7 after-hours support for urgent insurance needs and emergencies.
- We specialize in proactive policy reviews to ensure ongoing cost savings and coverage improvements.
- Our locally-owned agency combines community knowledge with nationwide insurance expertise.
What people say
Competitive pricing
Excellent customer service
Significant savings
Honest and helpful
Improved coverage
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Homeowners Insurance safeguards your property against risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. Our policies provide coverage for structural damage, personal belongings, and liability protection. With tailored options and competitive rates, we ensure your home remains secure while offering expert guidance for policy customization.
Business Insurance
Business Insurance protects companies from financial losses due to accidents, lawsuits, or disruptions. We offer comprehensive packages including liability, property, and workers' compensation insurance. Our solutions are designed to meet the unique needs of small to large businesses, ensuring operational continuity and risk mitigation.
Life Insurance
Life Insurance provides financial support for your loved ones in the event of your passing. We offer term and whole life policies tailored to individual needs, ensuring long-term stability for families and businesses. Our agents help you choose coverage that aligns with your financial goals and future plans.
Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance covers vehicle-related risks such as collisions, theft, and liability claims. Our policies include options for personal and commercial vehicles, with competitive rates and flexible coverage limits. We help drivers maintain compliance while minimizing out-of-pocket expenses during accidents or damages.
Employee Benefits
Employee Benefits packages include health, dental, vision, and life insurance for businesses. We assist employers in finding affordable, comprehensive plans that attract talent and support workforce well-being. Our services ensure compliance with regulations while prioritizing cost-effective solutions for small and large corporations.
People
Charles E. Self
Principal Agent
Charles Self founded Self Insurance Services in 2004, bringing over two decades of insurance expertise. He specializes in property, casualty, and life insurance, holding the LUTCF designation. Charles focuses on competitive pricing and exceptional service, earning industry recognition for production excellence.
Angie Petts
Life & Health Specialist
Angie Petts has over 35 years of experience in life and health insurance. Formerly with Transamerica Life Insurance, she was recognized as the nation's top agent in 2013 and 2014. Angie excels in creating customized solutions for clients' long-term financial security.
Candice Orndorff
Insurance Agent
Candice Orndorff holds property, casualty, life, and health licenses since 2019. Her approach prioritizes education and transparency, helping clients understand complex coverage options. With a focus on customer service, she ensures clients feel confident in their insurance decisions.
Will McEuen
Senior Services Specialist
Will McEuen brings 20 years of insurance experience, specializing in senior services and life insurance. He previously built three successful agencies before joining Self Insurance Services. Will emphasizes value-driven solutions while volunteering for community initiatives like the local food bank.
Hannah Wilson
Property & Casualty Agent
Hannah Wilson has been in the insurance industry since 2012, holding a P&C license. She focuses on educating clients about their insurance needs while maintaining a proactive approach to policy management. Hannah's local knowledge benefits homeowners and drivers in the Evansville area.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide homeowners, auto, life, health, commercial, and employee benefits insurance. Coverage includes liability protection, property damage, and financial security solutions tailored to individual and business needs.
How can I get a free insurance quote?
Visit our website or contact us directly at (812) 490-RATE for a personalized quote. Our team will review your needs and provide competitive pricing options for your insurance requirements.
Do you offer 24/7 emergency services?
Yes, our team is available after hours for urgent matters like roadside assistance or claims reporting. Call our main line for immediate support or guidance.
Can you help with business insurance needs?
We specialize in commercial policies including general liability, workers' compensation, and property insurance. Our agents tailor solutions to protect businesses of all sizes while optimizing cost savings.
How do you ensure competitive pricing?
We partner with multiple carriers to shop rates annually, ensuring clients maintain the best possible coverage at lowest costs through proactive policy reviews and market comparisons.
Reviews (7)
K. Bridges
May 24, 2021
Report
I had been searching for a new insurance company after I felt like I was being taken by another one. I just so happened to mention this to a friend of mine and she told me to contact Self Insurance, and believe me I'm so glad I did that was the best move I've ever made in my life. The staff were so helpful and acted in such a timely manner. To this day if I have any questions they r on top of it.
Anyone looking to change insurance companies I highly recommend Self Insurance they saved me so much money I walked out of that office that day felt like I was walking on Cloud 9. I recommended my sister to Self Insurance and she has signed on with them. They are the best. I'm never looking for another Insurance Company. They answered my Prayers.
Anyone looking to change insurance companies I highly recommend Self Insurance they saved me so much money I walked out of that office that day felt like I was walking on Cloud 9. I recommended my sister to Self Insurance and she has signed on with them. They are the best. I'm never looking for another Insurance Company. They answered my Prayers.
Brian E. Buxton
Feb 20, 2021
Report
I was receiving terrible customer service from a local agent that I had been with for years, to the point of me having some necessary licenses for one of my businesses expire and the agent doing nothing over 2-3 weeks to correct it. I have been friends with Charles Self for years and honestly should have received a quote from him earlier. In less than 24 Self saved me quite a bit of money, gave me excellent customer service and resolve all the issues with my dealers license. A++++ service and prices and I enjoy supporting local businesses! I highly recommend Self Insurance and Cindy for all your insurance needs.
China Grigsby
Apr 26, 2020
Report
Kasondra was amazing! She was super informative when it came to my policies and what coverage worked best for my families needs. I highly recommend her for you insurance services! Will continue to do business with this company
Charlie Mcmahon
Apr 15, 2020
Report
The folks at Self Insurance Services very professional. They have helped me with many of my insurance needs and have saved me time and money. I would highly recommend Self Insurance. Do yourSELF a favor and give them a call.
Will Jackson Jr
Apr 05, 2020
Report
Kasondra is an amazing agent! She worked with me with my budget and helped me find the best price. I felt like much more than a client. I definitely would advise anyone going for insurance to deal with her.
Sheilamaggard
Mar 24, 2020
Report
I want to say this company is awesome. Every issue I've had was resolved in a timely manner. This company puts customer service first. Cindy is a great asset to this company. She is Friendly and Professional. I enjoy my relationship with Self Insurance. Will Clardy and Sheila Maggard
Haranadh Babu
Mar 04, 2020
Report
I have always been finding insurance options myself until I came across Self Insurance. Their team has been really helpful in suggesting me the right combination of products and service providers to get me the best value. They have been always responsive, committed and approachable.
