Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Crofton, MD
Carrollton Insurance Agency has proudly served the insurance needs of Crofton, Upper Marlboro, and all of Maryland since 1969. Founded by Robert McMahon, our independent agency was built on the principle of providing convenient, tailored insurance solutions to complement real estate services. Today, we continue to offer comprehensive coverage options including auto, home, business, life, and boat insurance, while maintaining our deep roots in the local community. Our team understands the unique needs of residents and businesses in Maryland, Virginia, and Pennsylvania, and we leverage our independence to match clients with carriers that best align with their goals.

We prioritize quality coverage, exceptional service, and long-term relationships, ensuring our clients receive personalized attention and competitive rates. As active members of the communities we serve, we are committed to delivering reliable insurance solutions that protect what matters most to our clients.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance Life Insurance RV Insurance Renters Insurance Flood Insurance Umbrella Insurance Commercial Auto Workers Compensation
Details
  • Year established: 1969
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 50 years of experience serving Maryland communities.
  • Our independent agency provides unbiased comparisons across top carriers.
  • We specialize in tailored insurance solutions for local needs.
  • Our team prioritizes personalized service and long-term relationships.
  • We provide free, no-obligation quotes for all insurance types.
Services
Auto Insurance
Protect your vehicle with customizable auto insurance policies tailored to Maryland drivers. We offer liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options from top-rated carriers. Our independent agents compare rates to ensure competitive pricing while meeting state requirements and individual needs.
Home Insurance
Safeguard your home with policies covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability risks. We provide homeowners and renters insurance with flexible coverage limits and endorsements for unique needs like flood or vacant property protection across Maryland, Virginia, and Pennsylvania.
Business Insurance
Secure your business with tailored commercial policies including BOPs, general liability, and workers' compensation. We serve Maryland businesses with property protection, auto fleet coverage, and surety bonds to mitigate operational risks and ensure regulatory compliance.
Life Insurance
Plan for your family's future with term and permanent life insurance solutions. Our agents help Maryland residents select policies that provide death benefits, cash value growth, and estate planning advantages through trusted insurance providers.
Flood Insurance
Obtain specialized flood coverage for properties in high-risk areas through the National Flood Insurance Program. We assist Maryland homeowners and businesses in securing policies that cover structural and content damage from flooding events beyond standard policy limits.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We serve Maryland, Virginia, and Pennsylvania, with a focus on Crofton, Upper Marlboro, and surrounding communities.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a free, no-obligation quote online or call us at 301-350-6205 to speak with an independent agent.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, life, RV, renters, flood, umbrella, commercial auto, and workers' compensation insurance.
Are you an independent agency?
Yes, we're independent and partner with multiple carriers to find coverage that best fits your needs.
Can I manage my policy online?
Yes, existing customers can manage policies through our partner insurance company portals.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
Our office hours are Monday-Friday 9 AM-6 PM, but carriers provide 24/7 claims assistance for emergencies.
Reviews (3)
Chris Malachowski
Jun 27, 2021 Report
I have been with Carrolton Insurance Agency for many years. Mr. Robert McMahon walked me patiently through my options about my car insurance about 30 years ago. Their service and support was always exceptional, especially when I was involved in the car accident in the past. I have all my cars, my home and my life insurances managed by this family team for all these years without any problem. Kevin and Bryan are very friendly and quick to help. Professional and reliable company. I would recommend this company to anyone who needs professional and trustworthy long-term business relationship about their insurances.
Walt Schoenborn
Dec 29, 2018 Report
Trustworthy, easy and friendly. If you need insurance in Prince George's county or insurance in the upper marlboro area, I strongly recommend you call Carrollton Insurance
JettaJimm V.
Nov 18, 2014 Report
If you want nice friendly service go here! They will work with you and give you the best rates out there. Also their customer service is top notch and always there when you need them. I have been with them since 1988 when I purchased my first car and my parents have been with them since 1973. I am very happy with them and always recommend Carrollton Insurance Agency, Inc. to all of my family and friends.