Business Details
Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Dayton, OH
Wagner Insurance has been independently owned and locally operated for four generations, providing tailored insurance solutions across Ohio and surrounding states. Our team combines decades of industry experience with a commitment to personalized service, working closely with families and businesses to identify coverage that aligns with their unique needs. We partner with top-rated insurance carriers to offer competitive rates on auto, home, life, business, and specialty insurance products while maintaining a client-first philosophy rooted in trust and transparency.Our offices in Dayton, West Milton, and Lebanon serve as hubs for community-focused insurance guidance, supported by a staff trained in risk management and policy optimization. We prioritize long-term relationships over transactions, ensuring clients receive informed recommendations and responsive support during claims or policy adjustments. This approach has earned us recognition as a Certified Insurance Counselor and member of professional associations that uphold industry excellence.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Medicare Plans
Renters Insurance
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Flood Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer four generations of local insurance expertise and continuity.
- Our independent agency status provides access to multiple carrier options.
- We specialize in customized coverage for unique personal and business needs.
- Our staff maintains advanced industry certifications and training.
- We provide dedicated claims assistance and policy review services.
Associations and certifications
- Independent Insurance Agents Association
- Professional Insurance Agents
- Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC)
What people say
Excellent service
Prompt claim handling
Knowledgeable staff
Long-term satisfaction
Personalized approach
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance specialists help Ohio drivers find affordable policies with comprehensive protection. We compare rates from multiple carriers to ensure proper coverage for personal and commercial vehicles. Policies include liability, collision, and comprehensive options with flexible deductible choices.
Home Insurance
We provide customized homeowners insurance with coverage for dwellings, personal property, and liability protection. Our agents help clients understand policy details and select appropriate limits for their Dayton area homes. Available discounts apply for safety features and multi-policy bundling.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect Ohio companies with tailored liability, property, and specialized coverage options. We serve diverse industries including contractors, nonprofits, and professional services with risk assessment and policy recommendations from top-rated carriers.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance policies to protect families and business interests. Our advisors help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts and policy types that align with their financial goals and budgetary constraints.
Medicare Plans
Our certified Medicare specialists provide free consultations to help seniors evaluate prescription drug plans and supplemental coverage options. We explain annual changes and help clients select plans that balance premium costs with out-of-pocket expenses.
People
Pete Purcell Sr.
Health Advisor
Certified Medicare specialist with 18 years of experience helping seniors navigate insurance options. Provides personalized plan comparisons and annual coverage reviews to ensure optimal benefits and cost efficiency.
Questions
How do you help clients find competitive insurance rates?
We compare policies from multiple carriers to find the best coverage at competitive rates tailored to each client's specific needs.
What areas do you serve?
We provide insurance services throughout Ohio and are licensed in Michigan, Kentucky, Indiana, West Virginia, Georgia, Florida, and Tennessee.
What insurance products do you offer?
We offer auto, home, life, business, Medicare, and specialty insurance products for both personal and commercial clients.
How do you handle insurance claims?
We provide direct assistance with claims filing and work with carriers to ensure timely processing and fair resolution of covered losses.
Do you offer online policy management?
Yes, we provide online access for policy changes, payments, and document requests through our secure service center portal.
What sets your agency apart from others?
Our four-generation legacy combines local expertise with independent carrier options and personalized service focused on long-term client relationships.
Videos
Reviews (4)
Deborah Judge
Jun 05, 2022
Report
Kyle, went above and beyond to meet my insurance needs; he exceeded my expectations in regards to customer care. Thanks! Deborah
Sharon Aytes
Apr 05, 2022
Report
My name is Sharon and I just became a member of Wagner insurance I had the pleasure of talking to Kyle he walked me through everything I needed to know on my insurance for my car and my renter's got me a great rate on both of those with better coverage on both of those so kudos to the Wagner insurance family for hiring a very respectful and helpful person thank you Wagner insurance
Elissa Fox
Sep 21, 2021
Report
I just finished talking with my new local insurance agent, Kyle Bergman, and was very excited to discover because of my savings he presented to me, I now am carrying rental insurance, as well! He clearly knows the business of Auto and RentalHomeowners Insurance and presented it in terms that were easily understood. The transition from moving from one area of the state to another has been made easier. I am pleased to report that quality Customer Service is alive and well through this Company, and this agent. I am blessed to have found Wagner Insurance Agency along with their agent, Kyle Bergman.
Austin Lee
Aug 03, 2021
Report
Helped me find a lower insurance rate, when I thought for sure it couldn't be done. Thank you Kyle and the Wagner Insurance team!
