Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Terrace Park, Ohio
Proctor Insurance has been serving clients since 1952, offering over 70 years of combined experience in the insurance industry. We specialize in providing customized insurance solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of individuals and businesses across multiple states. Our commitment to quality service is reflected in our personalized approach, ensuring clients receive comprehensive coverage options from financially strong carriers.We offer a wide range of insurance products including auto, home, life, health, and commercial policies, with a focus on competitive pricing and exceptional claims support. Licensed in 12 states, our agency combines local expertise with national resources to deliver reliable protection and peace of mind to our clients.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Life Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Umbrella Coverage
Details
- Year established: 1952
Highlights and features
- We offer over 70 years of combined insurance experience
- Our team provides personalized coverage solutions
- We partner with financially strong national carriers
- We operate in 12 states with local expertise
- Our agency maintains dedicated claims support
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. Our policies protect against property damage, bodily injury, and uninsured motorists while offering flexible deductible options. Specialized coverage includes teen driver programs and GAP protection.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance covers structural damage, personal belongings, and liability claims. Policies include protection for additional living expenses during covered losses and specialized coverage for valuable items like jewelry and electronics.
Life Insurance
We offer term life, universal life, and whole life insurance policies to meet diverse financial protection needs. Our solutions provide death benefit protection while some policies accumulate cash value for long-term financial planning.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance packages include general liability, professional liability, and employment practices liability coverage. We provide tailored solutions for businesses with options ranging from $100,000 to $1,000,000 in liability limits.
Umbrella Coverage
We offer personal umbrella policies providing additional liability protection beyond standard insurance limits. This coverage protects against major claims from accidents involving property damage, vehicles, or personal liability situations.
People
Stewart Proctor
Owner/Agent
Stewart Proctor leads our agency with decades of insurance experience, focusing on personalized client service and community-based solutions for personal and commercial insurance needs.
Shelia Wilson
Personal Lines/Commercial
Shelia Wilson specializes in personal lines and commercial insurance, providing tailored coverage solutions while maintaining our agency's commitment to exceptional customer service.
Lisa Timmerding
Accounting
Lisa Timmerding manages our financial operations with precision, ensuring smooth administrative support for policyholders while maintaining accurate records for our insurance services.
Questions
What insurance types do you offer?
We offer auto, home, life, commercial, umbrella, boat, motorcycle, and long-term care insurance policies.
Do you cover college students' property?
Yes, 10% of your contents coverage extends to children away at college while remaining residents.
How do I report an accident?
Contact your account representative immediately and obtain an estimate from your preferred repair shop.
Can I pay premiums by credit card?
Yes, we accept Visa, MasterCard, and Discover for automatic or one-time billing.
Is jewelry covered under homeowners policies?
Jewelry coverage is limited; discuss scheduling valuable items with your account representative.
Do you offer commercial liability insurance?
Yes, we provide general liability, EPLI, and professional liability insurance for businesses.
Reviews (4)
Cory Walker
May 21, 2020
Report
Have home insurance with those place through USDA. Roof started leaking after a bad storm we got and leaked into our ceiling which caved in. 24 days after adjuster came and took pics and sent to them. We get a letter saying nothing is covered. Says it was "Normal wear and year"? Ok if I have auto insurance and a storm comes and blows my window out. Guess what?. Insurance covers it.don't waste your time with this place. Just a place that has a license but are not worth a hill of beans. If I could have given no stars I would have. Wasted space.crooks!
Tyrone Riley
Jan 05, 2020
Report
Had home owners with them very unethical will add coverage you dont need like earthquake insurance if you dont keep an eye on them over priced check other companies first Allstate over one hundred fifty dollars less beware stay away from this company proctors is a RIP off
Gadsden Patriot
Nov 04, 2017
Report
I've been with Proctor Insurance for around 30 years now. They've treated me well, they've been quick on claims, they're also flexible and their coverage & prices are good. I have coverage through them for my home, truck, and camper. Lastly, my girlfriend and my daughter also pay for their coverage. Overall a good personable mom and pop company that won't rip you off.
Eddie Lopez
Jan 22, 2014
Report
This is the most unprofessional company I've ever dealt with. I would not recommend this company. They do not return your phone calls and ignore customers. They take your money and do nothing. The insurance companies they deal with is even worse and do not provide good customer service.
