Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Margaretville, NY
Sluiter Agency is a service-oriented general insurance agency dedicated to providing personalized products and services to individuals, families, and businesses in the central Catskill Region and beyond. Established in 1914, we specialize in property, casualty, life, and related financial products, prioritizing fair dealings and fostering partnerships with quality companies based on mutual respect and integrity. Our deep roots in Margaretville, NY, span over 70 years, during which we have served the insurance needs of more than 2,200 individuals and families and 300 businesses. We pride ourselves on understanding the unique needs of our clients, offering tailored insurance and financial solutions that provide protection, security, and peace of mind.Our commitment to the Catskill community is reflected in our personalized service and expertise, which have earned us recognition as a 10-time winner of the Catskill Mountain News Readers Best Service Award. Whether you require auto, boat, homeowners, commercial, or life insurance, our team combines local knowledge with industry expertise to ensure your needs are met with professionalism and care. We value long-term relationships, as evidenced by clients who have trusted us for decades, and remain dedicated to adapting to the evolving needs of our community while maintaining the highest standards of service and integrity.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Workers Compensation
Details
- Year established: 1914
Highlights and features
- We offer over 70 years of experience serving the Catskill Region.
- Our team provides personalized insurance solutions tailored to your unique needs.
- We combine local expertise with partnerships with reputable insurance companies.
- We deliver comprehensive coverage for individuals, families, and businesses.
- We are a 10-time winner of the Catskill Mountain News Readers Best Service Award.
What people say
Prompt attention
Amazing job
Friendliness, experience, knowledge
One to one customer service
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions tailored to protect drivers and their vehicles. Our policies cover liability, collision, and comprehensive risks, ensuring financial security in case of accidents or damage. With personalized service, we help clients select coverage that aligns with their driving habits and budget.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance safeguards properties against risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. Policies include coverage for structural damage, personal belongings, and liability claims. We work closely with clients to customize policies that reflect the unique value and needs of their homes in the Catskill Region.
Commercial Insurance
We offer tailored commercial insurance for businesses of all sizes, covering property, liability, and operational risks. Our solutions protect against disruptions, ensuring continuity for sole proprietors and large employers alike. With expertise in industry-specific needs, we provide policies that align with business goals and regulatory requirements.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance products provide financial protection for families and dependents. Options include term and permanent policies designed to meet long-term needs, such as income replacement, mortgage coverage, or estate planning. We guide clients in selecting policies that ensure their loved ones' financial stability.
Workers Compensation
We offer workers' compensation insurance to protect businesses and employees from costs associated with workplace injuries or illnesses. Our policies cover medical expenses, lost wages, and legal liabilities, ensuring compliance with state regulations while safeguarding business continuity and employee well-being.
People
Matt Sluiter
President
Matt joined Sluiter Agency in 1995 and earned his Certified Insurance Counselor designation in 2016. He focuses on new sales opportunities and client needs, leading the Financial Services department with expertise in family and business insurance planning.
Peter Sluiter
Director
Peter has spent 40 years serving clients and advancing his insurance knowledge. Though retired from daily operations in 2025, he continues to consult on management and special projects, leveraging decades of industry experience.
Ryan Sluiter
Vice President
Ryan joined the agency in 2019 with a background in business administration and holds licenses in property, casualty, life, and health insurance. He specializes in commercial and personal insurance sales and client service.
Wendy O'Reilly
Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative
Wendy has over 30 years of insurance experience and earned her Certified Insurance Counselor designation in 2018. She manages claims and commercial accounts, serving as a Notary Public to support client needs.
Diana Campbell
Customer Service Representative
Diana joined Sluiter Agency in 2016 and earned her Certified Insurance Service Representative designation in 2021. She focuses on personalized service, ensuring clients receive tailored insurance solutions that meet their specific requirements.
Questions
How do I get an insurance quote?
Contact us at (845) 586-2641 or visit our office to discuss your needs. We provide accurate, competitive quotes tailored to your specific requirements.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, homeowners, commercial, life, workers' compensation, and specialty insurance for recreational vehicles, boats, and valuable items.
Why choose Sluiter Agency?
With over 70 years of local expertise, personalized service, and partnerships with reputable insurers, we deliver comprehensive coverage and award-winning client support.
How can I file a claim?
Report new claims through our Client Hub or call us directly at (845) 586-2641. Our team guides you through the process to ensure timely resolution.
Are you open to the public?
Yes! Visit our office at 761 Main Street, Margaretville, NY, Monday-Friday, 8:30am-4:30pm, or contact us remotely.
Do you serve businesses?
Yes, we provide commercial insurance for businesses of all sizes, including property, liability, and workers' compensation coverage tailored to industry needs.
Reviews (1)
Joe Damone
Feb 15, 2019
Report
I have been a customer of the Sluiter Agency for over a decade. Their service is tops and prices are competitive. A great local company!
