Business Details
40 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner on Long Island
Marlin Insurance Agency has been serving Long Island communities since 1986, providing comprehensive insurance solutions tailored to both personal and business needs. Our agency specializes in matching clients with optimal coverage options across auto, home, life, commercial, and specialty insurance products, including waterfront properties and recreational vehicles. With access to multiple carriers, we prioritize competitive pricing while maintaining personalized service through direct communication with live representatives during business hours.Our team proactively reviews existing policies to ensure cost-effective coverage and resolves client requests promptly, combining decades of industry experience with modern insurance practices to deliver reliable protection and exceptional customer support.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Umbrella Liability
Flood Insurance
Life Insurance
Watercraft Insurance
Event Coverage
Workers Compensation
Cyber Liability
Details
- Year established: 1986
Highlights and features
- We have over 35 years of experience serving Long Island insurance needs.
- Our team proactively reviews policies to maintain competitive pricing.
- We provide personalized service through live representatives during business hours.
- Our agency resolves client requests promptly and professionally.
- We offer coverage options for specialty properties including waterfront homes.
What people say
Excellent customer service
Best prices for insurance
Timely information access
Helpful and courteous
Proactive policy reviews
Services
Auto Insurance
We offer comprehensive auto insurance solutions with multiple carrier options for preferred, standard, and collector vehicles. Our policies include liability coverage and uninsured motorist protection while maintaining competitive pricing through proactive policy reviews.
Homeowners Insurance
Our agency provides coverage for primary residences, secondary homes, and waterfront properties on Long Island. Policies protect both physical structures and personal property with options for rental properties and condominiums.
Commercial Insurance
We offer tailored commercial insurance packages including business owners policies, professional liability, cyber liability, and workers compensation. Our solutions address unique risks for retail, wholesale, and office-based operations.
Umbrella Liability
We provide personal and business umbrella liability policies that extend beyond standard coverage limits. These policies offer additional protection for high-value assets and complex commercial operations.
Flood Insurance
Our flood insurance solutions through FEMA and private markets protect residential and commercial properties against water damage. Policies cover both building structures and contents in high-risk areas.
People
Gary Carruthers
Vice President
With decades of experience, Gary Carruthers leads our team in delivering personalized insurance solutions while maintaining the agency's founding principles of integrity and client-focused service.
Scott Lobel
Co-Owner
Scott Lobel has dedicated his career to protecting Long Island residents and businesses, combining industry expertise with a commitment to finding clients the best possible coverage options.
Theresa Manganello
Insurance Specialist
Theresa Manganello provides expert guidance to first-time homebuyers and policyholders, known for her responsiveness and ability to simplify complex insurance requirements for clients.
Questions
How do I get an insurance quote?
Contact us directly via phone or email to speak with a representative who will assess your needs and provide a customized quote.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, commercial, flood, umbrella liability, and specialty insurance for watercraft and special events.
How are policy changes processed?
Submit requests through our website or contact a representative - changes take effect after review and confirmation via email.
Do you handle insurance claims?
Yes, our dedicated team provides direct support for claims processing during normal business hours with live representatives.
Can you help with specialty insurance needs?
We specialize in unique coverage requirements including waterfront properties, recreational vehicles, and commercial specialty policies.
Reviews (6)
Arfhur Rosen
Feb 23, 2022
Report
I have always been treated like family by Scott and his crew. The prices are good and they always check to see I get the best deal. I've recommended them many times and still do. They always look out for me.
Mike Falco
Aug 26, 2021
Report
I have been using Marlin Insurance for the last for years for my homeowners, car and business insurance, Very proffesional company. Gary always finds the the right covrage for the right price. The staff in the office are also wonderful.
Reggie Saint Laurent
Jan 14, 2021
Report
Marlin Insurance Agency and their staff is great. I've been with them for a few years and always recommend them to anyone looking for the best insurance at the best rates. Shaneaka has been very helpful with helping me find the best policy to save me money without sacrificing the best coverage possible. I appreciate her patience and taking the time to help.
Jason Weinfeld
Jun 29, 2020
Report
Excellent service and knowledgeable staff. Works hard for you either to gain your business or keep your business. Always willing to help.
Ashley W.
Jun 06, 2018
Report
The owner of this insurance company is horrible. Never seen such an unprofessional business owner in my life. Mean and nasty to his only female staff. Yells at her and treats her like he is better then her. Definitely does not know how to handle his staff in a proper manner. Would never recommend this insurance company to any one, due to the fact that the owner comes off as sexist and creates a hostile work environment.
Lindsay Cucchiaro
Nov 29, 2016
Report
I worked with Ken Johnston at Marlin insurance. First let me say that Ken worked diligently to get me the absolute best coverage for my home owners insurance at the absolute best price! Was a pleasure!
