Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Springfield, MO
At Fortner Insurance, we are a family-owned agency based in Springfield, Missouri, dedicated to providing personalized insurance solutions for churches, businesses, nonprofits, and families across the state. With over two hundred years of combined experience, our team prioritizes transparency, practical coverage, and tailored guidance to meet the unique needs of our clients. As a trusted Brotherhood Mutual partner, we specialize in church and ministry insurance while offering comprehensive business, camp, employee benefits, life, Medicare, and personal insurance products. Our independent agency collaborates with top-rated carriers like Liberty Mutual and Acuity to ensure competitive pricing and customized protection.Led by co-owners Anthony and Nell Gillen, we emphasize relationship-driven service, combining local expertise with nationwide resources to deliver reliable, no-nonsense insurance advice. Whether you operate a business in Branson, manage a nonprofit in Cape Girardeau, or need home coverage in Ozark, our team provides in-person, phone, or online support to simplify the insurance process. Our commitment to community extends to educational resources, risk management tools, and a streamlined claims process, ensuring clients feel confident and supported in their coverage decisions.
Services
Business Insurance
Camp Insurance
Employee Benefits
Life Insurance
Medicare Plans
Personal Insurance
Church Insurance
Nonprofit Insurance
Commercial Umbrella
Cyber Liability
Highlights and features
- We are a family-owned agency with over 200 years of combined insurance experience.
- We specialize in church and ministry insurance as a leading Brotherhood Mutual partner.
- Our flexible service options include in-person, phone, and 24/7 online portal access.
- We work with top-rated carriers to ensure competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage.
- Our team provides localized expertise for Missouri businesses, nonprofits, and families.
Associations and certifications
- Brotherhood Mutual
What people say
Excellent customer service
Willing to answer all questions
Best options for protection
Most value for money
Personalized attention
Services
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect Missouri companies with tailored policies including general liability, workers' compensation, and commercial property coverage. We help businesses mitigate risks through customized plans that adapt to specific industry needs. Our team collaborates with top-rated carriers to ensure comprehensive protection and competitive pricing for local enterprises.
Church Insurance
Specialized church insurance programs address the unique needs of faith-based organizations, including property protection, liability coverage, and employee benefits. As a leading Brotherhood Mutual partner, we provide risk management resources and tailored policies for congregations across Missouri. Our expertise ensures religious institutions receive comprehensive protection for facilities and operations.
Medicare Plans
We offer personalized Medicare solutions including Advantage, Medigap, and Part D prescription drug plans for Missouri residents. Our local specialists provide one-on-one consultations to help clients navigate coverage options and find cost-effective solutions. We simplify the enrollment process while ensuring clear understanding of policy details and benefits.
Camp Insurance
Our camp insurance policies protect seasonal and year-round recreational facilities with liability, property, and program-specific coverage. We partner with carriers like Brotherhood Mutual and GuideOne to create customized solutions for Missouri's outdoor organizations. Our team understands the unique risks associated with camp operations and recreational activities.
Employee Benefits
We design comprehensive employee benefit packages for Missouri businesses, including health insurance, retirement plans, and group life coverage. Our approach focuses on creating competitive benefits that support workforce wellness and retention. We work with employers to develop cost-effective solutions tailored to company size and industry requirements.
People
Anthony Gillen
Co-Owner
Anthony Gillen co-leads Fortner Insurance with a focus on personalized client relationships and strategic risk management. He brings extensive insurance expertise and a commitment to community service, ensuring clients receive practical coverage solutions. His approach emphasizes clear communication and long-term trust-building.
Nell Gillen
Co-Owner
Nell Gillen co-owns Fortner Insurance, combining industry knowledge with a personal touch in serving Missouri clients. She specializes in understanding client needs and connecting them with appropriate coverage options. Her leadership emphasizes integrity and tailored insurance guidance for families and organizations.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide business, church, camp, employee benefits, life, Medicare, and personal insurance solutions across Missouri.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote online through our website or contact us directly at 417-882-5560 for personalized assistance.
Do you serve areas outside Springfield?
Yes, we work with clients statewide including St. Louis, Kansas City, Joplin, Branson, and surrounding regions.
What makes Fortner Insurance different?
We combine family-owned service with 200+ years of experience, offering independent carrier options and localized expertise.
How do I file a claim?
Visit our claims page for carrier contact details or call our office for step-by-step assistance with the claims process.
Reviews (6)
Patricia Cole
Oct 31, 2021
Report
We have been with Fortner for at least 10 years. The insurance increases every year, so last year I talked to the agent about switching to another company. He advised he didn't think it would make any difference and sounded to me as if he just didn't want to go to the trouble to do that. This year I am calling and checking other agencies to see if I get a better response.
Chris Golden
Aug 18, 2020
Report
Was quoted quotes for home and auto when it came time to sign they tried to increase the auto quotes 600 dollars more then wanted then brought it down still 84 dollars more no big deal then sends a message to raise homeowners by 128 dollars
Ryan Lucas
Jun 19, 2020
Report
I called in to my agent Karla a couple weeks ago and requested that we put full coverage on a truck that I was trying to rent for the weekend. She called me back explaining that since it was a flatbed the underwriters would not put full coverage on it considering that it was a commercial vehicle. I had big plans for memorial weekend to haul our camper back home and if I didn't get this vehicle insured my plans would have been spoiled. After putting more effort into it She called me back and said that she was able to get the underwriter to cover my truck that I was renting. Very pleased with her and her efforts!
Faina Phi Callery
May 24, 2020
Report
When I was in need for a better insurance plan for my auto, I contacted Fortner Insurance through their website. An agent by the name of Mindy was quick to respond, and had everything sorted out exactly to perfection! I strongly recommend them for your peace of mind.
Merrill Drummond
Nov 29, 2017
Report
The team at Fortner has always been willing to answer all of our questions, even if it involves research, and suggest what would be the best options for us to get the most value and protection for our money. They have offered excellent customer service and we are very pleased with our insurance company. Bill and Merrill Drummond
Kenny Coates
Nov 26, 2016
Report
Fortner Insurance has proven to be a valuable asset to my business by providing me with needed coverage at rates that just blow everyone else out of the water. If you're a business owner, do not get coverage until you've given Anthony Gillen a call at Fortner Insurance Services. Arrow Heating & Air Conditioning Service
