Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Risk Management Partner in Indianapolis
Founded in 1884, Gregory & Appel Insurance has built a legacy of delivering tailored risk management solutions to businesses, employees, and individuals. As a family-owned and employee-owned company, we prioritize client needs over external shareholder interests, ensuring personalized service and long-term partnerships. Our commitment to innovation and data-driven strategies helps clients reduce total cost of risk while strengthening organizational resilience. With over 140 years of experience, we combine industry expertise with a proactive approach to address evolving risks. Our team of advisors specializes in enterprise risk management, employee benefits consulting, and private client wealth advisory services.

Guided by core principles of belonging, giving, insight, innovation, and growth, we invest 10% of pre-tax profits annually into community initiatives. Our leadership team brings decades of experience in insurance, finance, and operations, fostering a culture of continuous development for both clients and colleagues. Headquartered in Indianapolis, we serve clients nationwide through a collaborative network of risk management experts. Our dedication to transparency, client education, and community impact distinguishes us as a trusted partner in navigating complex risk landscapes.
Services
Risk Management Insurance Market Selection Employee Benefits Consulting Private Client Wealth Advisory Claim Advocacy Enterprise Risk Management Benefit Plan Benchmarking
Highlights and features
  • We have over 140 years of experience in risk management solutions.
  • Our family-owned structure prioritizes client needs over shareholder interests.
  • We invest 10% of annual pre-tax profits into community initiatives.
  • Our team provides proactive guidance with data-driven risk strategies.
  • Employee-owned culture fosters long-term client partnerships and innovation.
Services
Risk Management
Our risk management services identify business vulnerabilities and implement data-informed strategies to reduce total cost of risk. We strengthen organizational resilience through customized enterprise risk frameworks. Our advisors help clients navigate complex insurance markets for comprehensive protection.
Employee Benefits Consulting
We design competitive employee benefits packages that balance workforce needs with cost control. Our data-driven approach optimizes total rewards programs to attract and retain talent. Services include health plan benchmarking and retirement strategy development for employers.
Private Client Wealth Advisory
Personalized wealth advisory services protect individual and family assets through holistic risk strategies. We address personal liability coverage, estate planning, and investment management. Our advisors deliver tailored solutions for high-net-worth clients.
Insurance Market Selection
We leverage industry relationships to secure optimal insurance coverage across multiple markets. Our brokers analyze client needs to match policies with specialized carriers. Services include commercial property, casualty, and specialty insurance placement.
Claim Advocacy
Our claim advocacy team ensures fair and timely insurance claim resolution. We represent clients throughout the claims process, working with insurers to maximize recoveries. Services include documentation review and negotiation support for business and personal claims.
People
Andrew Appel
CEO & Chairman
Andrew Appel leads Gregory & Appel with a focus on client empowerment and industry innovation. He champions diversity initiatives and community engagement. With expertise in organizational development, he guides strategic growth while maintaining the company's family-owned values.
David Fischer
President
David Fischer drives revenue growth with a background in international sales and technology. A former Marine Corps officer, he brings leadership experience to risk management solutions. He focuses on strategic partnerships and operational excellence across insurance sectors.
Erika Cuadrado
EVP Marketing
Erika Cuadrado shapes brand strategy and marketing innovation at Gregory & Appel. She transforms traditional insurance marketing through digital engagement. Her leadership emphasizes client-centric communication and market differentiation in competitive insurance industries.
Tim Hicks
EVP, Chief Operating Officer
Tim Hicks oversees property & casualty operations with a commitment to client service excellence. He ensures operational efficiency while maintaining personalized insurance solutions. His Hoosier roots and 20+ years in insurance inform strategic decision-making for business continuity.
Sarah Robison
EVP, Chief Financial Officer
Sarah Robison provides financial leadership with 25+ years in corporate finance. She drives strategic growth through fiscal management and team development. Her expertise in scaling organizations supports Gregory & Appel's expansion while maintaining financial integrity across risk management services.
Questions
What risk management services do you offer?
We provide enterprise risk management, insurance market selection, claim advocacy, employee benefits consulting, and private client wealth advisory services tailored to business and individual needs.
How do you help businesses reduce insurance costs?
Our data-driven strategies identify coverage gaps and inefficiencies while negotiating with carriers to optimize premiums. We implement risk mitigation programs that lower total cost of risk over time.
Are you an independent insurance agency?
Yes, we're independently owned and represent multiple insurance carriers to provide unbiased recommendations that match client-specific requirements across commercial and personal lines.
What makes your employee benefits consulting unique?
We combine market benchmarking with workforce analytics to create competitive benefits packages that control employer costs while improving employee satisfaction and retention rates.
Do you serve clients outside Indiana?
While headquartered in Indianapolis, we serve businesses and individuals nationwide through our network of risk management professionals and insurance brokerage partnerships.
Reviews (5)
Steve Thais
May 13, 2018 Report
Brad Loheide at Gregory and Appel is an execllent insurance agent! He is very knowledgeable, great customer service, and has assisted with proctecting our business for several years. Highly recommended Brad for all your insurance needs.
Aly Riley
May 12, 2018 Report
I was in my first very serious car accident that caused me to lose my car and have lots of unexpected medical expenses. Gregory & Appel was so quick to respond to me after my accident and gave me such exceptional care. Every employee I worked with knew all about my case and always had answers for my questions. What I appreciated most was that while helping me throughout my claims they educated me and explained things in terms that I could understand. I would highly recommend Gregory & Appel to anyone looking for insurance coverage!
Sarah Cotterill
May 03, 2018 Report
Tremendous customer service and very responsive. Support provided during auto claim helped in stressful time.
Joseph Atha
Apr 22, 2018 Report
I have a full service property management company, and have referred clients to Brad at Gregory & Appel. He has always been very professional and responsive, and has worked with my clients to provide the best possible coverage to protect themselves and their investments. I highly recommend this company To anyone who has an insurance need (which is just about everyone).
Stony Creek Handyman Llc
Dec 22, 2017 Report
Brad Loheide is honest and upfront! I would recommend him to anyone! If he cannot help you he will find someone that can. That type of service is hard to find!