Business Details
49 Years
experience
Your Trusted Partner for Comprehensive Insurance Solutions
Shepherd Insurance has been building lasting relationships and delivering tailored insurance solutions for over 45 years. Founded in 1977 in Carmel, Indiana, we have grown into one of the nations top 50 independent insurance agencies, representing over 200 carriers to create custom coverage for individuals and businesses. Our expertise spans commercial, personal, employee benefits, and financial services, with a focus on protecting clients from lifes uncertainties. With 40+ offices across seven states and 550+ employees, we combine local service with national resources.Our leadership team, including CEO Quinn Shepherd, brings decades of industry experience and a commitment to innovation, earning recognition as a Top Workplace for five consecutive years. We prioritize community involvement through initiatives like Operation Shepherding, dedicating time and resources to support the regions where our clients and employees live. Client testimonials highlight our dependable service, industry knowledge, and ability to adapt to evolving needs, reflecting our core values of trust, relationships, and excellence.
Services
Commercial Insurance
Personal Insurance
Employee Benefits
Financial Services
Medicare Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1977
Highlights and features
- We have over 45 years of experience in customized insurance solutions.
- Our access to 200+ carriers ensures tailored coverage for unique needs.
- Recognized as a Top Workplace for five consecutive years.
- Client testimonials highlight dependable service and industry expertise.
- We operate 40+ offices across seven states with 550+ employees.
What people say
Dependable and knowledgeable
Next to none
Invaluable partners
Professional service
Pioneers in healthcare insurance
Services
Commercial Insurance
We design custom commercial insurance solutions for businesses of all sizes, addressing property, liability, and operational risks. Our team analyzes industry-specific challenges to create policies that protect assets and ensure continuity. Clients benefit from access to 200+ carriers and specialized expertise in sectors like healthcare, construction, and manufacturing.
Personal Insurance
Our personal insurance services protect individuals' assets and lifestyles through home, auto, and umbrella policies. We assess clients' unique needs to provide comprehensive coverage that adapts to life changes. With local agents and national resources, we offer competitive rates and personalized service for homeowners, drivers, and high-net-worth individuals.
Employee Benefits
We create dynamic employee benefit packages that attract talent and support workforce wellness. Services include health insurance design, retirement planning, and compliance assistance. Our specialists work with employers to balance cost-effectiveness with comprehensive coverage, offering innovative solutions for small businesses and large corporations alike.
Financial Services
As an independent wealth advisory firm, we help clients maximize their financial future through retirement strategies, investment management, and estate planning. Our advisors provide personalized guidance to align financial goals with risk management, integrating insurance solutions to protect and grow assets across generations.
Medicare Insurance
We assist seniors in navigating Medicare options, offering plan comparisons and enrollment support. Our specialists explain coverage nuances and cost considerations to help clients choose policies matching their healthcare needs. Local offices provide ongoing assistance with policy management and claims resolution.
People
Quinn Shepherd
CEO | Managing Partner
Quinn Shepherd leads Shepherd Insurance with 43 years of industry experience, overseeing 40+ offices and 550+ employees. He focuses on mergers and acquisitions while maintaining the company's family-oriented culture. A Ball State University graduate, Quinn actively contributes to community boards and founded Operation Shepherding.
Dave Shepherd
Founder | Chairman
Dave Shepherd established the company in 1977 and grew it into a top 50 U.S. agency. He emphasizes client relationships over commissions and has received industry hall of fame honors. Dave remains active in strategic direction and mentoring leadership teams.
Jeff Kweder
Lead President | Partner
Jeff Kweder oversees strategic direction and key accounts with 35+ years at Shepherd. He founded the employee benefits division and serves on insurance association boards. Jeff graduated from Ohio State University and focuses on mid-sized to large business solutions.
Steve Gregory
President of Employee Benefits
Steve Gregory leads employee benefits strategy with 32 years of experience in health plan design and risk management. He advises on alternate funding strategies and serves on nonprofit boards. Steve holds Indiana University degrees and specializes in employer-sponsored wellness programs.
Fred McClaine
Senior Consultant
Fred McClaine specializes in business risk management, including cyber liability and medical malpractice. With 35+ years in insurance, he previously led Indiana's largest agency and now focuses on Midwest medical professional liability. Fred holds leadership roles in healthcare associations.
Questions
What types of insurance does Shepherd Insurance offer?
We provide commercial, personal, employee benefits, financial services, and Medicare insurance tailored to individual and business needs.
Does Shepherd Insurance operate nationwide?
Yes, we serve clients across the U.S. with 40+ offices in seven states and nationwide carrier partnerships.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Contact your local Shepherd Insurance office or use our online claims submission tools for prompt assistance.
Are specialized insurance programs available?
Yes, our Specialty division offers programs for unique risks including niche industries and high-net-worth individuals.
Does Shepherd offer Medicare insurance options?
Yes, we provide Medicare insurance guidance through dedicated specialists and local office support.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Chris Norris
Apr 29, 2021
Report
Ben Coe from Shepherd has been nothing but helpful since the moment we first spoke. He was able to provide great suggestions for coverage, while still providing great prices. He was even able to give advice outside of the policies we spoke about which was much appreciated. Highly recommend!
Virginia Brown
Apr 10, 2021
Report
Ben Coe is the BEST! He's very professional, and a pleasure to work with. He always answers all my questions with a prompt response, via email and/or phone call. He is extremely helpful and knowledgeable! I highly recommend Ben for all your insurance needs! Virginia Brown Carmel, IN
Steve Rich
Mar 01, 2021
Report
My wife and I are extremely satisfied with the professionalism and incredible service we received from Ben Coe at Shepherd Ins. Ben returns calls and emails swiftly and also has amazing insight of what coverage is best suited for our needs. Ben even went over and beyond to provide us with some coverage we were not able to receive elsewhere. Ben has great ideas on how to provide the best coverage for the best price with great insurance carriers. We truly feel wonderful about our decision to do our business directly with him!
Steve Wilson
Dec 05, 2020
Report
I can't say enough about my experience with Ben Coe. He's incredibly quick to respond and always has insight into any question I've asked. After talking with several brokers, I can honestly say that Ben is the sharpest insurance agent I've ever worked with. My wife and I now use Ben for our home, auto, umbrella, and life policies and couldn't be happier!
Valerie Hinkle
May 08, 2020
Report
Couldn't be happier with my decision to move all of my family's insurance to Ben Coe with Shepherd Insurance. Not only was he able to save us money, but we added extra protection without sacrificing any coverages. We couldn't have found a better agent for all of our needs.
Gavin Fox
Nov 25, 2019
Report
I started working with Ben Coe of Shepherd Insurance in March 2017. I work in the professional services industry as a CPA. In my 10+years in public accounting, I have never received the level service like I have from Ben. Ben is responsive, caring, and an advocate for me and my family. Ben has gone above and beyond my expectations, is everything I would want in an insurance agent. Beyond that, Shepherd Insurance has saved me money too. Seems too good to be true, but it is. Please reach out to Ben Coe, the rates are extremely competitive and the service is extraordinary.
James Northard
Jun 01, 2019
Report
I couldn't be happier with my decision to have Ben Coe as my agent. He is quick to answer any questions day or night and has always looked for the best coverage options for my auto and home policies. Ben has been my agent for six years now and I'm looking forward to working with him for many more years to come.
