Business Details
4 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Lancaster, OH
At Wentz Insurance, we are committed to understanding your unique needs and crafting personalized insurance strategies designed to protect what matters most. With decades of combined experience, our team prioritizes service excellence, integrity, and dignity in every client interaction. We believe in challenging conventional wisdom to deliver tailored solutions that address both immediate and long-term goals. Our mission is to build lasting relationships by providing comprehensive coverage options for individuals and businesses. We specialize in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, ensuring clients receive policies that align with their specific circumstances.By focusing on client satisfaction and leveraging our industry expertise, we aim to simplify the insurance process while offering competitive pricing. Our local knowledge of the Lancaster, Ohio area allows us to address regional risks effectively. We operate with transparency, ensuring clients understand their coverage details and feel supported throughout their policy term. Our team remains accessible to answer questions and provide guidance, treating every client as a valued partner rather than a transaction. Through continuous monitoring and policy adjustments, we help clients maintain optimal protection as their lives and businesses evolve.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Liability
Cyber Liability
Commercial Property
Umbrella Insurance
Recreational Insurance
Professional Liability
Details
- Year established: 2022
Highlights and features
- Decades of combined insurance experience serving Lancaster, Ohio
- Personalized policies tailored to individual and business needs
- 24/7 client support for policy questions and claims assistance
- Local expertise addressing regional risks and requirements
- Transparent pricing with competitive rate comparisons
What people say
Friendly Service
Stress Free
Greatest people
Best prices
Timely response
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions that protect drivers against liability, collision, and unexpected roadside emergencies. Our policies include customizable options for medical payments, uninsured motorist protection, and emergency road service. With personalized rate comparisons and expert guidance, we help clients find coverage that balances protection and affordability while meeting Ohio's legal requirements.
Business Liability
Our business liability insurance safeguards companies against financial risks from lawsuits, property damage, and bodily injury claims. We offer tailored policies covering public liability, professional liability, and specialized risks for contractors and cyber operations. Our team helps businesses understand coverage limits and select appropriate protections to secure assets while maintaining operational continuity.
Life Insurance
We offer term and permanent life insurance solutions designed to protect families and businesses from financial hardship. Our policies address funeral costs, debt coverage, and long-term financial planning needs. We guide clients through policy selection, beneficiary designation, and coverage amounts to create customized plans that provide peace of mind for loved ones.
Home Insurance
Our home and renters insurance policies protect against property damage, personal liability, and loss of personal belongings. We provide coverage for structural elements, temporary housing during repairs, and valuable possessions. Our agents help clients understand policy details, select appropriate coverage limits, and implement risk mitigation strategies specific to their Lancaster area properties.
Commercial Property
We offer specialized insurance for commercial properties covering buildings, equipment, and inventory against fire, theft, and natural disasters. Our policies include business interruption coverage to protect income during recovery periods. We work with clients to assess property values, implement risk management strategies, and ensure adequate protection for their operational assets.
People
Alan Wentz
President, Property/Casualty & Life/Health Agent
Alan leads our agency with over 20 years of insurance experience, specializing in property/casualty and life/health coverage. He focuses on building client relationships and ensuring comprehensive protection strategies.
Jared Wentz
Property/Casualty Agent
Jared provides expert guidance on property and casualty insurance, helping clients navigate coverage options. His client-first approach ensures personalized solutions for individuals and businesses in Lancaster.
Mike Dickson
Property/Casualty & Life/Health Agent
Mike combines technical expertise with personalized service, specializing in both property/casualty and life/health insurance. He helps clients protect personal and business assets through tailored coverage plans.
Paula Hawk
Property/Casualty Agent
Paula offers dedicated support for property/casualty insurance needs, focusing on clear communication and thorough policy explanations. Her local knowledge enhances coverage recommendations for Lancaster residents.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, business liability, cyber liability, commercial property, umbrella, recreational, and professional liability insurance for individuals and businesses in Lancaster, Ohio.
How can I get a quote?
Request a quote by calling (740) 653-5535 or completing our online form. Our agents will contact you within 24 hours to discuss coverage options and pricing.
Do you offer specialized business insurance?
Yes, we provide tailored commercial insurance including liability, cyber, professional liability, and property coverage with risk assessment specific to your industry and operational needs.
Are your agents licensed locally?
All our agents are licensed in Ohio and specialize in local insurance requirements. Our team includes experts in property/casualty, life/health, and commercial insurance categories.
How do claims work?
Contact us immediately after an incident. We'll guide you through documentation, coordinate with insurers, and ensure timely processing while keeping you informed throughout the claims resolution.
Can I adjust my coverage later?
Yes, we monitor your policy annually and recommend adjustments as life changes occur. Our team helps update coverage limits, add endorsements, or modify policies to match evolving needs.
Reviews (5)
Stephanie Haydocy
Mar 25, 2022
Report
Best insurance place I have had. They offer an incentive for current policy owners who refer people. Please mention my name if you sign up with them. At least call them for a quote. I know that I was pleasantly surprised.
Jeff Currence
Apr 08, 2021
Report
Jared has done an excellent job handling all of our insurance needs. We couldn't have asked for any better!
Benjamin Currence
Apr 03, 2021
Report
Jared was quickly able to give me the assistance that I needed! Dealing with insurance is usually stressful and honestly annoying, but this isn't the case when dealing with Jared!
Bill
Dec 24, 2020
Report
I've been a customer here almost as long as the company has been in business. Our home and vehicles are insured with them. Other companies have admitted they can't match the rates. They have always taken good care of us and I can find no reason take my business elsewhere.
Frank Romano
Jun 02, 2020
Report
I havent been with them long. And i carry an SR22 bond. Its wonderful they got my rate down. From 163.00 at a different company. To 101.00 quoted by Wentz. But my 1st bill is 121.00 so there were hidden costs they didnt mention. So not hapoy about that. But overall im satisfied.
