Business Details
Your Trusted Local Insurance Partner in Wisconsin
Established in 1867, Mt Pleasant-Perry Mutual Ins (MPPM) has built a legacy of providing reliable, economical insurance services across South Central and Western Wisconsin. Our merger with Middleton Insurance Company in 2020 strengthened our ability to serve 13 counties with personalized coverage tailored to individual needs. As a member of WAMIC, we combine over 150 years of industry expertise with a commitment to 'Neighbor Insuring Neighbor,' ensuring clients receive localized support and comprehensive protection.Our team of experienced agents specializes in home, auto, commercial, farm, and liability insurance, offering flexible policies that adapt to evolving risks. We prioritize transparency, community engagement, and client education, fostering long-term trust through responsive claims handling and proactive risk management solutions. With offices in Monticello and partner agencies statewide, we deliver accessible, cost-effective insurance that safeguards what matters most to Wisconsin families and businesses.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Farm Owners Insurance
Inland Marine Insurance
Liability Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Renters Insurance
Umbrella Liability
Builders Risk
Highlights and features
- We offer 148 years of Wisconsin-specific insurance expertise.
- Our local agents provide personalized policy customization and claims support.
- We maintain A+ ratings from the Wisconsin Insurance Security Fund.
- Our coverage adapts to unique rural and urban property needs.
- We guarantee competitive pricing through mutual company partnerships.
Associations and certifications
- WAMIC
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance protects against fire, theft, and natural disasters while covering personal belongings and liability claims. We offer customizable plans for houses, condos, and manufactured homes with optional coverage for grave markers, computer equipment, and identity theft. Policyholders benefit from claim-free discounts and up to 70% coverage for household property.
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance for rural and urban drivers, including antique vehicles and farm equipment. Policies include liability protection, collision coverage, and discounts for safety features like airbags. Customers with home insurance through qualifying mutual companies receive a 15% home-auto bundle discount.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial policies safeguard small businesses and rental properties with liability coverage, property protection, and farm-specific insurance. We offer tailored solutions for agricultural operations and family-owned enterprises, combining personal service with industry-specific risk management expertise.
Renters Insurance
This service protects renters' personal property against theft and damage while providing liability coverage. Policies cover furniture, electronics, and valuables not protected by landlords' insurance, with optional enhancements for high-value items like jewelry and collectibles.
Umbrella Liability
Our umbrella policies provide additional liability coverage beyond standard auto, home, or farm insurance limits. Coverage extends to libel, slander, and personal injury claims with options for $1-5 million in protection, including recreational vehicles and seasonal residences.
People
Jenny Gilbertson
Office Manager
Jenny oversees daily operations and client communications at MPPM's Monticello headquarters, ensuring efficient policy processing and customer service excellence.
Janice Maier
Office Assistant
Janice supports MPPM's administrative functions and client interactions, maintaining accurate records and facilitating smooth office operations.
Kristi Leonard
Agent/Office Assistant
Kristi provides insurance consultation and policy management services while assisting with office operations at MPPM's Blanchardville location.
Wendy Runkle
Company Manager
Wendy leads MPPM's strategic operations and merger integration efforts, maintaining the company's commitment to community-focused insurance services.
Eric Straehl
Agency Representative
Eric represents MPPM through Town and Country Insurance, delivering personalized insurance solutions to clients in southwest Wisconsin.
Questions
What areas does MPPM Insurance serve?
We provide coverage across 13 Wisconsin counties including Dane, Iowa, and Green counties, with local agents serving rural and urban communities.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a free quote online or contact our Monticello office directly to discuss personalized coverage options with a licensed agent.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We specialize in homeowners, auto, commercial, farm, renters, and umbrella liability insurance for Wisconsin residents and businesses.
Are there discounts available?
Yes! We offer home-auto bundle discounts, mature driver rates, and reductions for safety features like anti-lock brakes and airbags.
Can I pay my insurance premium online?
Yes, we provide secure online payment options for policyholders' convenience through our website portal.
