Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions Since 1922
Mennonite Insurance Services has served the insurance needs of Mennonite, Mennonite Brethren, Brethren in Christ, and other Anabaptist communities since 1922. We specialize in providing competitively priced home, auto, church, and specialty insurance products while maintaining a commitment to financial responsibility and Christian values. Our experienced team understands the unique risks faced by our faith-based clients, offering personalized service grounded in over a century of mutual aid tradition. As a licensed independent agency, we represent multiple top-tier insurance carriers to meet diverse coverage needs across the West Coast. Our company actively supports disaster relief and community development initiatives through partnerships with Mennonite Disaster Service and West Coast Mennonite Central Committee. With offices in Reedley, California, we serve clients in Arizona, California, Oregon, and Washington through a dedicated staff of bilingual insurance professionals.Our leadership includes seasoned industry veterans holding professional designations like CPCU and CISR, ensuring expert guidance for policyholders. Through monthly newsletters and proactive outreach, we keep clients informed about evolving insurance needs, including specialized coverage for home-based businesses and recreational vehicles. Our mutual insurance company structure reflects our core value of sharing burdens, as emphasized in Galatians 6:2, creating stronger relationships between policyholders and providers. This commitment to excellence has earned us an AM Best financial strength rating of B++ (Good), demonstrating our long-term stability and reliability for both individuals and churches.
Services
Homeowners Insurance
Auto Insurance
Church Insurance
Rental Insurance
Earthquake Insurance
Flood Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Condo Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1922
Highlights and features
- We offer over 100 years of experience serving Anabaptist communities
- Our team provides tailored insurance solutions for Mennonite and Brethren churches
- Bilingual Spanish-speaking agents available for client convenience
- Professional staff holds industry designations including CPCU and CISR
- Actively supports disaster relief and community development initiatives
Associations and certifications
- A.M. Best (B++ rating)
- California Department of Insurance (License #0B72783)
What people say
Great people, great services
Excellent... reliable agent
Professional and caring
Services
Homeowners Insurance
We provide comprehensive homeowners insurance tailored to Anabaptist communities, covering structural damage, personal property, and liability protection. Our policies include specialized options for mobile homes, second dwellings, and earthquake coverage. With over 100 years of experience, we offer competitively priced solutions that align with our mutual aid values.
Church Insurance
Our church insurance program protects Anabaptist congregations with property, liability, and vehicle coverage specifically designed for religious organizations. Policies include protection for buildings, equipment, and outreach programs while supporting financial responsibility and community values through our mutual insurance model.
Auto Insurance
We offer customized auto insurance solutions for personal and non-commercial vehicles, including specialized coverage for motorcycles and antique cars. Our policies provide liability protection, collision coverage, and roadside assistance while maintaining affordability for Mennonite and Brethren communities across the West Coast.
Flood Insurance
Flood insurance policies protect homes and properties against water damage from natural disasters, covering structural components and personal belongings. We help Anabaptist communities prepare for unexpected weather events with affordable coverage options that complement standard homeowners' policies.
Earthquake Insurance
Earthquake insurance provides critical coverage for seismic damage not included in standard policies, protecting homes and properties against repair costs and personal property losses. We offer this specialized coverage to help Mennonite and Brethren communities maintain financial stability after major earthquakes.
People
Kevin Lucke
President/CEO
Kevin Lucke joined Mennonite Insurance in 2024 with 32 years of P&C insurance experience. He holds CPCU and AIM designations and graduated from George Fox University with a business degree. Kevin brings leadership expertise across claims, underwriting, and executive functions.
Dalia Jimenez
Licensed Agent
Dalia has served Mennonite Insurance since 1996 with over 30 years in the industry. Holding CISR designation, she provides bilingual Spanish insurance solutions for property, casualty, life, and health. Dalia focuses on meeting clients' needs while building strong community relationships.
Yolanda Hernandez
Licensed Agent
Yolanda has worked in insurance since 2003, joining Mennonite Insurance in 2006. With CISR designation and a business degree, she provides bilingual Spanish services focused on personalized insurance solutions for community members across Arizona and California.
Claudia Fletes
Licensed Agent
Claudia has over 25 years of insurance experience, rejoining Mennonite Insurance in 2003. She helps clients save on insurance while managing underwriting responsibilities and building community connections through personalized service and bilingual Spanish capabilities.
Marcus Mahling
Sales and Marketing
Marcus joined Mennonite Insurance in 2023 bringing diverse experience from claims restoration, agency ownership, and insurance sales consulting. He specializes in connecting with new clients and building relationships that support our community-focused insurance mission.
Questions
What areas do you serve?
We provide insurance services to Mennonite and Anabaptist communities in Arizona, California, Oregon, and Washington states.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We specialize in homeowners, auto, church, and specialty insurance including flood, earthquake, and umbrella coverage for both individuals and congregations.
How does your mutual insurance model work?
As a mutual insurance company, policyholders are also owners who share in decision-making and benefit from our financial strength and community-focused approach.
Do you offer bilingual services?
Yes, we have licensed agents who speak both English and Spanish to better serve our diverse client base.
How do you support Anabaptist communities?
We partner with Mennonite Disaster Service and West Coast Mennonite Central Committee, contributing $10,000 annually to support relief efforts and community development.
Videos
Reviews (3)
Ivanna Rouppet
Feb 04, 2022
Report
Love that Mennonite Insurance services always are polite and answer my questions so that I can understand.
Jennifer Powers
Aug 11, 2016
Report
Jerry is excellent over at Mennonite Insurance Services, Inc if you are looking for a auto quote in Reedley, CA there is a reliable agent for you!
Sheila H.
Jun 27, 2016
Report
I would like to express our gratitude to Mennonite Aid Plan for their swift response to a claim we were forced to file due to a burglary of our home while we were gone. We discovered our daughter's wedding rings were among the missing items, We were trying to determine what we should do since we figured it would take awhile to process and we knew the rings might have to be reordered and resized.
We didn't have to make any decision. To our amazement Mennonite aid Plan processed the claim and we were able to replace the rings along with other items that were stolen. Mennonite Aid Plan helped make a difficult situation less stressful due to their quick and efficient response!
We didn't have to make any decision. To our amazement Mennonite aid Plan processed the claim and we were able to replace the rings along with other items that were stolen. Mennonite Aid Plan helped make a difficult situation less stressful due to their quick and efficient response!
