Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Door County, WI
Schmitz Insurance has been a trusted name in the insurance industry since 1936, serving Door County and surrounding areas with unwavering commitment. As a third-generation family-owned agency, we pride ourselves on delivering personalized insurance solutions tailored to the unique needs of individuals and businesses. Our team of licensed advisors works diligently to simplify the insurance process, offering comprehensive coverage options for home, auto, business, and employee benefits. With over 80 years of local expertise, we prioritize building lasting relationships through transparency, integrity, and exceptional service.Our independence allows us to partner with multiple reputable carriers, ensuring clients access competitive rates and customized policies. We remain deeply rooted in the community, dedicating ourselves to understanding evolving risks and providing proactive guidance. Our mission is to empower clients with confidence, knowing their assets and futures are protected through strategic, cost-effective insurance solutions tailored to their specific circumstances.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Owners Insurance
General Liability Insurance
Group Health Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Cyber Liability Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Employment Practice Liability Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1936
Highlights and features
- Third-generation family-owned agency with deep community roots
- Licensed advisors specializing in customized insurance solutions
- Proactive risk management guidance tailored to local needs
- Independence allows partnership with multiple reputable carriers
- 88 years of Door County insurance expertise ensuring policyholder confidence
What people say
Personalized attention
Knowledgeable agents
Prompt claim resolution
Competitive pricing
Local expertise
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your primary residence with comprehensive home insurance coverage. We offer policies that safeguard against property damage, liability claims, and personal belongings loss. Our advisors help clients understand specific risks in Door County's unique environment while ensuring proper coverage limits. Policies include protection against common perils like storms, fire, and theft while offering optional endorsements for specialized needs.
Business Owners Insurance
Tailored insurance solutions for small to mid-sized businesses. Our BOP policies combine property, liability, and business interruption coverage into streamlined packages. We specialize in understanding industry-specific risks across Door County's diverse business landscape, including retail, hospitality, and contracting sectors. Policies adapt to evolving operational needs while maintaining cost-effectiveness.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive auto insurance coverage for personal and commercial vehicles. We provide liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options while helping clients navigate Wisconsin's specific requirements. Our comparative market analysis ensures competitive rates while maintaining adequate protection levels. We specialize in finding solutions for unique vehicles and high-risk profiles.
Group Health Insurance
Customizable health insurance plans for businesses seeking to attract and retain talent. We offer solutions ranging from basic coverage to comprehensive plans with dental and vision components. Our approach balances employee needs with employer cost considerations while ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. We provide ongoing support for policy renewals and modifications.
Cyber Liability Insurance
Specialized coverage against data breaches and cyber threats. Our policies address modern business risks including network security failures, data loss, and privacy violations. We help businesses establish risk management protocols while providing financial protection against cyber incidents. Coverage adapts to evolving technology landscapes and industry-specific compliance standards.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide comprehensive personal and business insurance solutions including home, auto, motorcycle, business owners, general liability, cyber liability, employment practice liability, and employee benefits coverage.
Why choose Schmitz Insurance over national carriers?
As a local, independent agency since 1936, we offer personalized service with multiple carrier options, deep community knowledge, and tailored solutions that national carriers cannot match.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote through our website, call us directly at 920-743-5561, or visit our Sturgeon Bay office for personalized assistance with our insurance advisors.
What areas do you service?
We primarily serve Door County and Kewaunee County, including Sturgeon Bay, Baileys Harbor, Fish Creek, Sister Bay, and Algoma, with broader Wisconsin coverage capabilities.
Are you available for after-hours emergencies?
While standard office hours are Monday-Friday 9-5, we have systems in place for urgent insurance needs and provide contact information for critical after-hours situations.
Reviews (3)
Cynthia Dukerschein
Jun 20, 2020
Report
Phil is always friendly and prompt--he answered me right away when I expected I wouldn't hear anything until Monday at least, and he found the best deal for our circumstances, the same way he's handled all of our needs.
Jerry Bloom
Feb 05, 2020
Report
Phil's efficiency with seeking the best quotes for me with my rental property gives me peace of mind that he continually has my best interest at heart.
Laurie Dufek
Nov 18, 2018
Report
I had a crack in my windshield and within a day of contacting Phil, I got a call from the company that fixes the windshield- Precision Auto Glass. They were able to come out to my house within a few days- waiting for the weather to be warm enough. They were very professional and friendly, explaining everything they did. The best surprise was finding out that I didn't even have to pay a deductible! Thanks for the great service!
