Business Details
42 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Marshfield, WI
Since 1984, Marshfield Insurance has served as a trusted independent insurance agency dedicated to providing personalized solutions for individuals and businesses. Founded by Roger Arnoldy and now led by second-generation principals Nick and Ryan Arnoldy, the agency has grown to become the largest insurance office in the Marshfield area with three locations across Wisconsin. Our team of over 27 licensed professionals represents more than 45 A-rated insurance companies, offering comprehensive coverage options for home, auto, life, health, business, and farm insurance. We prioritize community engagement, maintaining a customer-first approach that has earned us recognition as the Marshfield Chamber of Commerce Small Business of the Year.With decades of combined experience, we leverage industry expertise to deliver tailored insurance strategies while maintaining the personalized service of a family-owned business. Our commitment to technological innovation ensures efficient policy management while preserving the human touch that distinguishes our client relationships. Through strategic expansions and acquisitions, we've extended our service reach across multiple states while maintaining deep roots in Central Wisconsin.
Services
Health Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Farm Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1984
Highlights and features
- Family business operating for two generations with deep community roots
- Professional team of 27+ educated agents with specialized expertise
- Award-winning agency recognized by Marshfield Chamber of Commerce
- Three convenient locations serving Central Wisconsin communities
- Community-focused approach prioritizing local needs and relationships
Associations and certifications
- AM Best
What people say
Top notch customer service
Knowledgeable expertise
Prompt and professional
Lifelong customer
Professionalism and honesty
Services
Health Insurance
Health insurance protects against medical expenses from routine check-ups to major hospitalizations. Our agents help clients navigate options from 50+ A-rated carriers to find affordable policies matching their specific needs. We specialize in individual, family, and group health plans with access to prescription coverage and preventive care benefits.
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance safeguards against financial losses from vehicle accidents, theft, or damage. We offer liability coverage, collision protection, and comprehensive policies tailored to individual drivers and commercial fleets. Our agency helps clients secure competitive rates while ensuring adequate protection for their specific driving needs and vehicle types.
Business Insurance
Business insurance protects companies from industry-specific risks through customized policies. We provide property coverage, liability protection, workers' compensation, and specialized programs for diverse sectors including manufacturing, healthcare, and agriculture. Our agents work closely with business owners to create comprehensive risk management strategies that evolve with their operational needs.
Home Insurance
Home insurance covers property damage from perils like fire, storms, and theft while providing liability protection. We offer standard policies with optional endorsements for flood coverage, identity theft protection, and equipment breakdowns. Our agents help homeowners in Central Wisconsin and beyond secure appropriate coverage levels for their specific property characteristics and risk profiles.
Life Insurance
Life insurance provides financial protection for dependents through death benefit policies. We offer term and permanent life insurance options to meet diverse needs, including family security, estate planning, and business succession. Our agents help clients evaluate coverage amounts and policy types that align with their long-term financial goals and family circumstances.
People
Nick Arnoldy
Owner, Commercial Risk Agent
Nick Arnoldy leads Marshfield Insurance as principal owner with over 20 years of industry experience. Holding CIC, CPIA, and CRM designations, he specializes in commercial risk management while overseeing agency operations. Nick continues the family legacy established by his father Roger in 1984.
Roger Arnoldy
Founder
Roger Arnoldy founded Marshfield Insurance in 1984 after a decade in property and casualty insurance. He built the agency from a small life/health practice into Central Wisconsin's largest insurance office. His leadership established the family business model continued by his sons Nick and Ryan.
Ryan Arnoldy
Commercial Risk Agent
Ryan Arnoldy joined the agency in 2003, bringing expertise in commercial insurance solutions. As co-owner since 2016, he focuses on business client relationships while maintaining the agency's commitment to personalized service and community involvement.
Cory Hoffmann
Commercial Risk Agent
Cory Hoffmann serves as Commercial Risk Agent with specialized knowledge in business insurance programs. Holding the CIC designation, he helps Wisconsin businesses develop comprehensive risk management strategies tailored to their specific industry requirements and operational challenges.
Kassi Pagel
Benefit Producer
Kassi Pagel brings over a decade of insurance experience to her role as Benefits Agent. She specializes in employee benefit programs, helping businesses design competitive health and retirement packages that support workforce retention and satisfaction.
Questions
How do I get a home or auto insurance quote?
Request a quote online through our website or contact our Marshfield office directly at 715-387-4443. Our agents will help you compare options from multiple carriers to find the best coverage at competitive rates.
What types of business insurance do you offer?
We provide comprehensive commercial coverage including property insurance, liability protection, workers' compensation, and specialized programs for industries like manufacturing, healthcare, and agriculture. Our agents create customized risk management solutions for Wisconsin businesses.
Do you serve areas outside Marshfield?
Yes, we serve all of Central Wisconsin with additional offices in Wisconsin Rapids and Neillsville. Our services extend to multiple states through our network of 50+ A-rated insurance carriers.
Are your agents licensed and certified?
All our agents are properly licensed with many holding professional designations like CIC (Certified Insurance Counselor) and CPIA (Certified Professional Insurance Agent). Our team maintains ongoing education to stay current with industry developments.
What makes Marshfield Insurance different from other agencies?
As a second-generation family business, we combine local expertise with nationwide resources. Our 30+ years of experience, 27+ team members, and commitment to personalized service distinguish us as Central Wisconsin's largest independent insurance agency.
How do claims work with Marshfield Insurance?
Contact our office directly at 715-387-4443 to report a claim. Our experienced claims specialists will guide you through the process, working to resolve issues efficiently while protecting your interests with our carrier partners.
Reviews (7)
Bartholomew Forman Bart
Mar 16, 2022
Report
Long time customer. I've always been impressed with their professionalism and honesty. They have been quite helpful to me, especially recently.
Doug Seubert
Mar 24, 2020
Report
My hone owners insurance is affordable and they work directly with my mortgage company so I never have to worry. All the information is shared and the payments get made automatically. It makes things a lot easier on me.
Cathy Hetzel
Feb 13, 2020
Report
'Marshfield Insurance knows their field and can be counted on to provide fast efficient service. Have enjoyed working with them because they can be depended on.
MarciaMarie Meshak
Jan 06, 2020
Report
You emailed me asking for me to rate you.here it is. I was treated so poorly when I needed assistance with an ice dam last winter. I moved by insurance to another agency, that agent guided me through questions before he was even my agent. Very sad! Sure miss the GREAT agent I used to have. Ann you are very missed. Marshfield Insurance your customer service now, Does NOT even come close to what Ann used to provide.
Marshfield Glass
May 24, 2019
Report
Our experience with Marshfield Insurance has been nothing short of fantastic. We find great comfort in knowing they're always just a quick phone call or email away. They're timely, efficient, and incredibly friendly.
Season Felland
Apr 26, 2019
Report
I have had a great experience with marshfield insurance. They are always supportive when I have had questions. In 4 years I have had no issues. I would definitely recommend marshfield insurance to anyone looking for a great insurance company.
Aaron Strack
Apr 15, 2019
Report
I have had good service for years. Any claims or changes I make are done promptly. Also any changes in business coverage they keep me up to date. Very happy with service
