Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Partner in Sauk City
Meyer Insurance is a third-generation family-owned independent insurance agency founded in 1919. We prioritize personalized service, working exclusively for our clients rather than insurance companies, to deliver tailored insurance solutions. With over a century of experience, our team combines deep industry expertise with a commitment to community service. We offer comprehensive personal and commercial insurance products, including home, auto, life, and business coverage, while maintaining a client-centered approach rooted in honesty and integrity. Our agency has been actively involved in local governance and community development for generations, reflecting our dedication to both professional excellence and civic responsibility. 
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Insurance Check-Up
Farm Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Policy Renewals
Claims Assistance
Risk Assessment
Details
- Year established: 1919
Highlights and features
- Third-generation family-owned agency with century-long expertise
- Personalized insurance solutions tailored to individual client needs
- Independent agency representing multiple carriers to find best coverage
- Deep community involvement and local market knowledge
- Experienced team with specialized insurance designations
What people say
Personable and compassionate
Best to solve problems
Saved $500 annually
Friendly and trustworthy
Excellent staff
Services
Home Insurance
We provide comprehensive home insurance solutions for homeowners, renters, condominium owners, and mobile home residents. Our policies protect against property damage, liability claims, and personal belongings loss. With customized coverage options, we ensure your home is protected against unexpected events while offering competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships.
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance services cover cars, motorcycles, boats, ATVs, and snowmobiles with flexible coverage options. We offer premier, preferred, and standard tier policies tailored to individual driving records and needs. Our team helps clients navigate coverage requirements while finding cost-effective solutions that protect both vehicles and drivers.
Life Insurance
We offer level term, universal life, and group life insurance policies to protect families and businesses. Our solutions provide financial security for dependents, business continuity planning, and estate protection. With personalized policy recommendations, we help clients create lasting legacies while addressing immediate financial obligations.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions include property, liability, workers' compensation, and business auto coverage. We serve diverse industries with risk management strategies tailored to specific business needs. With specialized commercial agents on staff, we help businesses protect assets, employees, and operations through comprehensive insurance packages.
Insurance Check-Up
We offer free insurance check-ups to assess existing coverage adequacy for both personal and business policies. Our licensed agents review current policies, identify gaps, and recommend improvements. This service ensures clients maintain optimal protection levels while maximizing cost efficiency through our multi-carrier representation.
People
Lise Meyer-Kobussen
President
Third-generation owner with 40+ years in insurance. Licensed professional focusing on client relationships. Active in community development and insurance industry leadership. Manages agency operations since 1999.
Diane Boettcher
Agent
Over 30 years experience specializing in farm policies. With Meyer Insurance for 20+ years. Background in agricultural operations. Handles specialized insurance needs for farming operations.
Jolene Sonday
Agent
Licensed property/casualty agent with 25+ years experience. Specializes in personal lines and agency technology. Returned to Sauk Prairie after decade in Minnesota insurance industry. Holds relevant insurance designations.
Chris McDonald
Commercial Agent
Commercial insurance specialist with 35+ years experience. Holds CPCU, AU, and AINS designations. Focuses on business risk management. Provides tailored solutions for Wisconsin businesses.
Tammy Frey
Claims Agent/HR
Insurance professional with 20+ years experience. Handles claims processing and HR operations. SHRM-CP certified with business administration degree. Joined agency in 2024 to expand service capabilities.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, auto, life, business, farm, and commercial insurance with specialized coverage options.
Why choose an independent agency?
We represent multiple carriers to find optimal price/coverage combinations tailored to your specific needs.
How are you different from other agencies?
Third-generation family-owned business with personalized service and deep community knowledge since 1919.
Do you serve businesses outside Sauk City?
We serve clients across Wisconsin with specialized insurance solutions for various industries.
How do I file a claim?
Call us at 608-643-3000 with loss details prepared, including police reports and property descriptions.
Do you offer policy reviews?
Yes, we provide free insurance check-ups to assess coverage adequacy and identify potential improvements.
Reviews (6)
Julie Rose
Feb 28, 2022
Report
Love Meyer Insurance. Knowledgeable, great pricing, awesome agent, Joni Neill. Can't say enough good about this insurance agency.
Anjuli Gundrum
Feb 12, 2022
Report
I was referred to Meyer by a friend who was very pleased with their customer service. Joni was incredibly helpful in transferring over my insurance and helping me get requoted.
Julie Rose
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Sales clerk knew absolutely nothing. Couldn't a swer any questions. Didn't offer to find anyone else that might be able to help either. Typical camping world!
Elizabeth Kirschbaum
May 29, 2021
Report
The staff welcomes you like your "family ", you're not just a client, so glad I decided to seek them out, great savings on policies!
Betty Frey
Dec 31, 2020
Report
Very helpful and proven trustworthy. Fast service - they get things done! Really kind and friendly people. Just too bad we didn't find them sooner.
Sherri L. Roberts
Nov 16, 2020
Report
They are very personable and compassionate. Always do their best to solve any problem. Can't say enough good things about this business
