Business Details
29 Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Agency in Newtown, CT
Since 1997, Preferred Insurance Services has been a trusted local independent agency serving Newtown, Connecticut. Our mission is to provide unparalleled service and comprehensive coverage through our independent status, allowing us to offer competitive rates and tailored solutions. We specialize in personal lines insurance, including auto, home, motorcycle, boat, life, travel, and pet insurance, with a focus on meeting each client's unique needs. Our team takes pride in building long-term relationships and comparing national and regional carriers to ensure optimal coverage.We are committed to exceeding expectations through personalized service and a dedication to our community. With over 25 years of experience, we continue to establish ourselves as a reliable partner for all insurance requirements. Our independent status enables us to remain competitive while maintaining a client-centric approach. We value transparency, expertise, and the trust our clients place in us to protect their assets and future.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Condo Insurance
Renters Insurance
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Life Insurance
Travel Insurance
Pet Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1997
Highlights and features
- We offer 25+ years of experience in personalized insurance solutions
- Our independent status compares multiple carriers for optimal rates
- We build long-term relationships with personalized service
- We provide comprehensive coverage across 9+ insurance categories
- Our team specializes in Connecticut-specific insurance needs
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions protecting vehicles against accidents, theft, and natural disasters. Our policies include liability coverage, collision protection, and uninsured motorist provisions. Connecticut drivers benefit from competitive rates through our carrier comparisons while maintaining customizable coverage options tailored to individual driving records and vehicle values.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies safeguard properties against fire, weather damage, and liability claims. Coverage includes structural protection, personal belongings, and additional living expenses during repairs. We specialize in Connecticut-specific risks like severe storms while offering customizable riders for high-value items and specialty home features.
Boat Insurance
We offer specialized boat insurance policies covering watercraft damage, liability for accidents, and trailer protection. Policies address Connecticut's inland waterway requirements with options for fishing equipment, personal watercraft, and seasonal storage. Our independent status ensures competitive pricing across multiple marine insurance specialists.
Life Insurance
We provide term and permanent life insurance solutions ensuring financial security for beneficiaries. Our offerings include death benefit protection, cash value accumulation options, and policy riders for critical illness. Connecticut residents receive personalized assessments considering family needs, mortgage obligations, and long-term care planning.
Pet Insurance
Our pet insurance covers veterinary expenses for accidents, illnesses, and chronic conditions. Policies include wellness care options, breed-specific coverage, and prescription medication benefits. We partner with multiple providers to offer plans tailored to Connecticut pet owners' needs for dogs, cats, and specialty animals.
People
James Gulalo
Insurance Agent
James Gulalo brings 15+ years of insurance expertise to Preferred Insurance Services. Specializing in personal lines coverage, he helps Connecticut residents find optimal protection solutions. His client-first approach focuses on clear communication and thorough policy explanations.
Rebecca Hogenauer
Home & Auto Specialist
Rebecca Hogenauer specializes in home and auto insurance solutions with a decade of experience. She excels at matching Connecticut clients with customized coverage plans. Her expertise includes policy analysis, risk assessment, and explaining complex insurance terminology in accessible terms.
Questions
What insurance types do you specialize in?
We specialize in auto, home, motorcycle, boat, life, travel, pet, condo, and renters insurance for Connecticut residents.
How do you help clients save money?
Our independent status compares multiple carriers to find competitive rates while maintaining comprehensive coverage tailored to individual needs.
Do you offer a referral program?
Yes! Refer friends who purchase policies and receive $25 digital gift cards per referral with no limit on rewards.
What are your business hours?
Monday-Thursday 9AM-5PM, Friday 9AM-4PM. Contact via phone, email, or text during these times for assistance.
Can I get insurance quotes online?
While we don't provide instant online quotes, our agents offer personalized consultations to ensure accurate coverage recommendations and pricing.
Reviews (5)
Benjamin Stokes
Apr 13, 2022
Report
My wife and I have just switched our auto insurance policies to a new provider after working with Rebecca and are excited to start realizing our nearly 50% savings between our two vehicles. Rebecca's attention to detail, extremely fast turnaround time for all communications and transparency through all stages of the process is exactly what we have been lacking when dealing with our providers previously.
Not to mention, she really cared about saving us money which is such an added bonus. I would highly and happily recommend anyone I know to solicit her and her team's services and at least get a quote. because who doesn't love saving money?
Not to mention, she really cared about saving us money which is such an added bonus. I would highly and happily recommend anyone I know to solicit her and her team's services and at least get a quote. because who doesn't love saving money?
Renee
Feb 11, 2022
Report
We have been using Preferred Insurance for several years now. Rebecca is extremely professional and very responsive. She goes above and beyond to make her clients happy along with trying to save clients money. Customer service is top notch! Highly recommend for all of your insurance needs.
H.
Dec 15, 2021
Report
Need to get a home insurance before closing on a house. Found Preferred Insurance through a google search and it turns out to be the best decision. Rebecca is super responsive, professional and friendly! We got a quote within 30min after our first call and we are happy with the rate. She then took care everything that is required by the mortgage application. Such a great pleasure to work with. Thank you Rebecca. Highly recommended.
Rosa Nieves
Dec 10, 2021
Report
My previous car insurance agent retired last year and I was looking to lower my insurance. I was highly recommended to Rebecca and I'm very pleased with the service I received! Rebecca responded to me immediately, was professional and so personable. I enjoyed speaking with her and having all of my questions answered quickly. I literally had a new car insurance policy, with a better price, the coverage I needed, and documents signed within 24 hours. I really value customer service, and only would write this review when the assistance I receive is outstanding. I'm looking forward to working with Rebecca in the future!
Emily Spikoski
Dec 06, 2021
Report
We have been with Preferred for over 10 years, always satisfied! Rebecca is fantastic! She finds great deals, and perfect coverage. She is informative, helpful, very quick to respond, and makes us feel taken care of. Wonderful group! Highly recommend! ********
