Browse the Top Insurance Companies Serving Bay Shore, NY

See what insurance companies serving Bay Shore, NY offer, from auto and home insurance to life and business coverage. Review company profiles, read customer feedback, and contact providers that match your insurance requirements.
Brooks-Waterburn
Westbury, NY 11590 (18.0 mi)
50+ Years
7 reviews
Brooks-Waterburn
Westbury, NY 11590 (18.0 mi mi)
50+ Years
7 reviews
Brooks-Waterburn provides comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses throughout Long Island. Specializing in auto, home, life, and commercial insurance, we offer tailored policies designed to meet specific needs without overcoverage. Our client-focused approach emphasizes transparency, competitive pricing, and expert guidance through complex insurance decisions.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Immediate service Knowledgeable staff Detailed quotes
Multy Cover
50+ Years
Emergency
5 reviews
Multy Cover
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 (8.5 mi mi)
50+ Years
Emergency
5 reviews
Multy Cover provides comprehensive insurance solutions for individuals and businesses. Established in 1975, we offer personalized coverage options across auto, home, commercial, life, and specialty insurance lines. Our independent agency model allows comparison shopping across multiple carriers to find optimal protection at competitive rates.
Auto Insurance Boat Insurance Commercial Insurance
Excellent customer service Significant cost savings Personalized attention
3 reviews
Aspen Agency
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 (8.5 mi mi)
31 Years
3 reviews
Aspen Agency is an independent insurance provider serving Long Island and New York State. We specialize in auto, home, commercial, and specialty insurance products from top-rated carriers. Our client-first approach focuses on personalized coverage solutions, competitive pricing, and exceptional service.
Auto Insurance Contractors Insurance Home Insurance
Saved money on premiums Quick to help with questions Phenomenal service for 11 years
Coste Agency
Holbrook, NY 11741 (10.6 mi)
50+ Years
2 reviews
Coste Agency
Holbrook, NY 11741 (10.6 mi mi)
50+ Years
2 reviews
Coste Agency provides comprehensive personal and commercial insurance services to residents and businesses in Holbrook, NY and surrounding areas. Since 1948, we've specialized in auto, home, life, flood, aircraft, and umbrella insurance policies tailored to individual client needs. Our independent agency model allows us to offer competitive rates through multiple insurance carriers while maintaining personalized service.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Flood Insurance
American Professional Agency
Amityville, NY 11701 (9.5 mi mi)
43 Years
1 review
American Professional Agency specializes in professional liability insurance for mental health professionals. The company provides tailored coverage solutions for psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, and allied health practitioners through A-rated carriers. With personalized underwriting and 24/7 customer support, the agency maintains industry-leading endorsements and serves as a trusted risk management partner.
Professional Liability Insurance Risk Management Resources Telehealth Coverage
Exceptional customer service Knowledgeable underwriters Prompt response times
6 reviews
Marlin Insurance Agency
Shirley, NY 11967 (20.4 mi mi)
40 Years
6 reviews
Marlin Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance provider on Long Island since 1986, offering personalized auto, home, life, and commercial insurance solutions. We specialize in finding competitive rates while maintaining personalized service through live representatives. Our proactive approach includes policy reviews and prompt resolution of client requests.
Auto Insurance Homeowners Insurance Commercial Insurance
Excellent customer service Best prices for insurance Timely information access
TIB Transportation Insurance Brokers specializes in comprehensive insurance solutions for the passenger transportation industry. We provide tailored coverage including commercial auto, workers' compensation, and cyber insurance to protect transportation businesses nationwide. Our expertise ensures clients receive specialized programs backed by a national network of carriers and dedicated support.
Commercial Auto Insurance Workers Compensation Commercial Umbrella
Great work and prompt problem-solving Professional and helpful staff 25 years of excellent service
2 reviews
Alan R Mott Agency
Huntington, NY 11743 (13.6 mi mi)
50+ Years
2 reviews
Alan R Mott Agency specializes in marine insurance solutions for pleasure and commercial vessels. With 50+ years of experience, we offer personalized coverage for boats, yachts, personal watercraft, and commercial marine operations. Our services include liability protection, property damage coverage, and specialized endorsements tailored to maritime risks.
Boat Insurance Yacht Insurance Personal Watercraft Insurance
Not rated yet
Mauser & Tobin
Garden City, NY 11530 (20.3 mi mi)
50+ Years
Not rated yet
Mauser & Tobin is an independent insurance agency offering personalized and business insurance solutions in Garden City, NY. With over 90 years of experience, we specialize in tailored coverage for homes, vehicles, and commercial operations, representing top carriers to meet diverse client needs. Our focus on transparency, expertise, and client-centric service ensures comprehensive protection and peace of mind.
Personal Insurance Business Insurance Home Insurance
Eastern Classic Coverage Insurance specializes in customized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses across multiple states. We provide industry-specific risk management through personalized service, leveraging deep market expertise and relationships with top-rated carriers. Our focus on unique client needs ensures tailored coverage for real estate, contractors, food services, and high-value assets.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Promptly respond Saved me thousands Quality service
West Islip (3.4 mi) Brentwood (3.9 mi) Hauppauge (7.3 mi) Ronkonkoma (8.5 mi) Sayville (8.6 mi) Smithtown (9.3 mi) Amityville (9.5 mi) Melville (10.1 mi) Holbrook (10.6 mi) Centereach (11.9 mi)