Business Details
44 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Webster, NY
Founded in 1982, Steinmiller Insurance has served thousands of customers across Upstate New York for over four decades. Our commitment to excellence in sales and personalized service has been the cornerstone of our success. As an independent agency, we prioritize client needs over carrier interests, offering comprehensive coverage solutions tailored to individual and business requirements. Our team of experienced professionals, including third-generation family members, specializes in navigating complex insurance landscapes to secure optimal policies.We maintain a local presence in Webster, NY, fostering community relationships while leveraging industry expertise to deliver competitive pricing and exceptional client support. Our approach combines decades of experience with proactive policy monitoring to ensure ongoing value and protection for every client.
Services
Business Insurance
Auto Insurance
General Liability
Home Insurance
Workers Compensation
Condo Insurance
Renters Insurance
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1982
Highlights and features
- We've provided quality insurance service to Upstate New York since 1982
- Our family-owned agency maintains a high standard of excellence in personalized service
- We work with multiple carriers to find coverage that fits your unique needs
- Our team includes third-generation insurance professionals with specialized expertise
- We proactively monitor policies to ensure ongoing competitive pricing and protection
What people say
Excellent customer service
Knowledgeable and responsive
Saved money on policies
Highly recommend
Personalized attention
Services
Business Insurance
We provide comprehensive business insurance solutions including auto fleets, general liability, and workers compensation. Our policies protect against property damage, legal claims, and employee-related risks. With specialized programs for contractors, medical device manufacturers, and professional offices, we help businesses manage risk while maintaining compliance with state regulations.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance covers standard residences, high-value properties, condos, and rental units. Policies protect against structural damage, personal liability, and loss of use. We offer tailored solutions for unique properties and provide guidance on coverage options like flood insurance and umbrella policies to ensure complete protection.
Auto Insurance
We offer auto insurance for personal and business vehicles, including cars, boats, motorcycles, and RVs. Our policies meet legal requirements while offering customizable options for collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage. We help clients find competitive rates and specialized programs for high-risk drivers and unique vehicles.
Umbrella Insurance
Our umbrella insurance provides additional liability protection beyond standard policy limits. This coverage applies to both personal and business risks, protecting against major claims that could threaten financial stability. We help clients assess appropriate coverage levels based on their specific assets and risk exposure.
Workers Compensation
We offer workers compensation insurance covering job-related injuries, illnesses, and fatalities. Our policies comply with state requirements while providing benefits for medical expenses, lost wages, and rehabilitation. We serve industries including construction, manufacturing, and professional services with customized safety programs and risk management solutions.
People
Gary Steinmiller
Founder & Chairman
With 45+ years in insurance, Gary established Steinmiller Insurance in 1982. He built the agency on personal service principles and now oversees strategic direction while trusting daily operations to his daughters.
Kristen Steinmiller
President
President with 20+ years experience specializing in commercial and personal policies. She focuses on building client relationships and maintaining the family culture that defines Steinmiller Insurance's service approach.
Robyn Steinmiller
Vice President
Licensed since 2004, Robyn specializes in property, casualty, and health insurance. She emphasizes clear communication and accessibility, working with clients through multiple contact channels to simplify insurance decisions.
Laurie Sweet
Account Executive
With 30+ years in insurance, Laurie leverages long-term client relationships to deliver personalized service. She focuses on maintaining Steinmiller's reputation for honesty and reliability while ensuring client satisfaction.
Mike Shay
Commercial Lines Consultant
Specializing in advanced commercial coverage since the 2000s, Mike develops risk management solutions for contractors, manufacturers, and medical device companies. He focuses on cyber liability and safety programs while maintaining personalized client support.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer auto, home, business, boat, motorcycle, RV, flood, life, health, umbrella, and specialty insurance for weddings and professional liability.
Why use an independent insurance agent?
Independent agents compare multiple carriers to find coverage that fits your needs at competitive prices, rather than representing a single insurance company.
Do you serve businesses?
Yes, we provide business insurance including general liability, workers compensation, commercial auto, and specialized coverage for contractors and manufacturers.
Do you offer policy reviews?
Yes, we proactively review policies at renewal to ensure continued competitive pricing and appropriate coverage levels for changing needs.
Reviews (7)
Kristen Calkin
Apr 21, 2022
Report
I've been a customer with Steinmiller Insurance for over a decade. I'm always impressed with how efficient, friendly and helpful they are. They've seamlessly handled changes in our policies following the purchases of new homes and new vehicles. I know I can trust them to handle whatever issues arise and that with one phone call or text they take care of what we need. I can't imagine having anyone else handle our insurance needs!
Michelle Halling
Jun 14, 2021
Report
Great people here! Always helped me out tremendously, even if it was my stupid mistake. Will always come here to these wonderful people!
Anna Monroe
Apr 03, 2021
Report
Robin has saved me so much money. My car insurance has been going up as my boys started driving. Robin has found new rates for me that were cheaper than my first policy. When I have a question, she gets back to me immediately.
Bob Parina
Apr 03, 2021
Report
Great company to work with. I have been with them for 25 some years. They take care of all my insurance needs.
Melissa Marsocci
Mar 21, 2021
Report
Steinmiller Insurance is a true class act! I cannot say enough good about their organization, and the individuals who are apart of it!
Seana Lindenthaler
Jun 21, 2020
Report
We worked with Steinmiller Insurance on the house insurance for our first home. They were extremely helpful, knowledgeable and fast. Thank you!
Laura Harris
Dec 25, 2018
Report
The staff is professional, knowledgeable and always friendly. I can always feel confident when referring someone to the Steinmiller Agency that they will be very well taken care of.
