Business Details
Your Trusted St. Louis Insurance Partner
Clayton-Hanley Insurance Service is an independently owned, veteran-operated insurance agency serving St. Louis and surrounding areas. Our team of licensed professionals brings decades of combined experience in providing personalized insurance solutions for individuals, families, and businesses. We partner with top-tier insurance carriers to offer comprehensive coverage options tailored to meet specific client needs while maintaining competitive pricing. Our commitment to exceptional customer service is demonstrated through our proactive approach to policy management, transparent communication, and 24/7 availability for claims assistance. As a locally rooted agency with deep community ties, we prioritize building long-term relationships with our clients, treating them as valued members of our extended family.Our team's diverse expertise spans all major insurance categories, including auto, home, boat, and specialty policies for unique life situations. We maintain active involvement in local communities through volunteer work and neighborhood engagement initiatives. Our operational philosophy centers on three core principles: offering choice through multiple carrier partnerships, delivering responsive service for policy adjustments and claims processing, and providing expert guidance to ensure informed coverage decisions. With over 30 years of continuous service to satisfied clients, we have established ourselves as a trusted insurance resource in the St. Louis region. Our office hours and communication channels are designed to accommodate client needs while maintaining professional standards of excellence.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowner Insurance
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
View All Insurance Products
Highlights and features
- We work with multiple insurance companies to provide coverage choices and competitive pricing
- Our team offers personalized service treating customers like family
- We provide expert guidance for all major insurance categories
- Our agency maintains active community involvement and local knowledge
- We offer comprehensive insurance solutions for all life stages
What people say
Excellent customer service
Best rates possible
Outstanding personal service
Genuine care and support
Trusted insurance partner
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance coverage tailored to individual driving needs and budget requirements. Our policies protect against liability, collision, and comprehensive risks while offering customizable options for additional protection. With access to multiple carriers, we help clients find optimal coverage at competitive rates while maintaining personalized service and claims support.
Homeowner Insurance
Our homeowner insurance policies protect residential properties against common risks including fire, theft, and natural disasters. We offer customizable coverage options for standard homes, vacation properties, and specialty dwellings while ensuring adequate protection for both structure and personal belongings. Our team provides expert guidance to help clients understand policy details and select appropriate coverage levels.
Boat Insurance
We specialize in boat insurance policies that protect watercraft owners against property damage, liability claims, and emergency assistance needs. Our coverage options address various vessel types and usage patterns while providing comprehensive protection for both on-water incidents and storage-related risks. We work with experienced marine insurance providers to ensure specialized coverage for recreational boaters.
Motorcycle Insurance
Our motorcycle insurance policies provide tailored protection for riders of all experience levels and bike types. Coverage includes liability protection, collision damage, and comprehensive coverage for theft or weather-related incidents. We help clients navigate state requirements while finding affordable policies that match their riding habits and equipment value.
View All Insurance Products
We offer access to a comprehensive range of insurance products through partnerships with multiple top-rated carriers. Our portfolio includes coverage for specialty vehicles, vacation homes, teen drivers, and new construction projects. As an independent agency, we provide unbiased recommendations to help clients select the most appropriate policies across all life stages and insurance needs.
People
Timothy Mossinghoff
President
Navy Veteran and Webster Groves resident with extensive insurance industry experience. Leads agency operations while maintaining active client relationships. Brings military discipline and local knowledge to insurance solutions.
Peggy Manes
Agent, CSR
Millstadt, Illinois resident with insurance expertise and community involvement. Combines gardening passion with customer service skills to provide personalized insurance solutions for families and individuals.
Tony Palazzolo
Independent Agent
Experienced insurance professional serving St. Louis area clients. Leverages local market knowledge and technical expertise to develop customized insurance strategies for personal and business needs.
Nicole Cox
Agent, CSR
South County resident and Lindbergh School District expert. Balances motherhood with insurance career to provide practical coverage solutions for families and food enthusiasts in the community.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, boat, motorcycle, and specialty insurance policies for individuals and families in Missouri and Illinois.
Why choose Clayton Hanley Insurance?
We combine local expertise with multiple carrier options to offer personalized service, competitive pricing, and comprehensive coverage solutions.
Do you serve areas outside St. Louis?
We insure clients in Missouri communities like Oakville and Imperial, plus Illinois locations including Edwardsville and Waterloo.
What payment options are available?
Contact your specific insurance carrier directly for payment options through their designated portals and service lines.
How do I file a claim?
Contact your insurance carrier directly using the claims numbers provided in your policy documents for immediate assistance.
Videos
Reviews (6)
Donald Steinburk
May 17, 2022
Report
Clayton Hanleys insurance specialists are very friendly and knowledgeable. They saved me over $400 on my auto insurance this year.
Patricia Herman
Mar 17, 2022
Report
I have been with Clayton Hanley for over 53 years. They have helped me out in so many ways, I can't even list them. Peggy Manes is my goto person and has been extremely helpful again in so many ways. I feel very lucky to be associated with such a great company. YOU WILL NOT GO WRONG if you are with Clayton Hanley Insurance Company. Peggy is always there to help you as many of her co-workers are. PATH
Harold Blackorby
Jun 12, 2021
Report
I appreciate their expertise in sorting through many, many insurance companies to find the best one for me. They are immediately responsive. They are one of the best insurance brokers in St. Louis.
Han Li
Dec 16, 2020
Report
I worked with Nicki Cox at Clayton Hanley and she was very responsive, detail-oriented, knowledgeable and helped guide me through my home buying experience. I would highly recommend her!
Brian Carosone
Nov 21, 2020
Report
I have been with them for 23 years, my wife has been with them since she was a kid. They are always looking out for us and trying to help us save money. Peggy is very responsive and helpful anytime we ask a question.
Dan S.
May 30, 2020
Report
Peggy has been assisting me for years with finding the best possible insurance coverage in a variety of areas. Clayton-Hanley always provides a service that is accurate, fast, and personal. They've just helped my wife and I to find a great policy on our first home at the best possible price - it was a huge relief to be able to count on someone for the research and planning as we dealt with other to-do lists for our move. I'd definitely recommend Clayton-Hanley!
