Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Independent Insurance Experts in Tulsa, OK
All American Insurance has served Tulsa, Oklahoma and surrounding areas for over 35 years as an independent insurance agency. We represent multiple carriers to help clients secure optimal coverage at competitive rates while prioritizing personalized service and community education. Our team focuses on understanding individual and business insurance needs across Oklahoma, Missouri, and Texas, offering tailored solutions backed by decades of industry expertise. We maintain partnerships with top-rated companies to ensure comprehensive protection against unforeseen events. Our commitment to client satisfaction includes 24/7 claims support and a one-on-one service approach that prioritizes policyholder interests over insurance company agendas.Licensed professionals handle auto, home, business, and specialty insurance lines with transparent communication and ethical practices. We emphasize long-term relationships through ongoing policy assessments and competitive market comparisons. Our staff maintains industry knowledge through continuous training while adhering to strict professional standards. The agency's multilingual capabilities and local market understanding enhance service delivery across diverse client bases.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Business Insurance
Commercial Auto
Workers Compensation
Commercial Property
Personal Umbrella
Motorcycle Insurance
Renters Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer 35+ years of insurance expertise with multiple carrier partnerships
- Our team provides personalized policy comparisons and cost optimization analysis
- Licensed professionals serve Oklahoma, Missouri, and Texas markets
- 24/7 claims support with dedicated policyholder advocacy
- We maintain industry-leading knowledge through continuous professional development
What people say
Very knowledgeable
Saved me $500 annually
Personal service approach
24/7 claims support
Trustworthy comparison
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions protecting personal and commercial vehicles across multiple states. Our policies include liability coverage, collision protection, and uninsured motorist provisions while offering discounts for safe drivers and multi-policy bundling. Our team compares rates from top-rated carriers to ensure optimal coverage at competitive prices.
Homeowners Insurance
Our homeowners insurance policies protect residential properties against fire, theft, and natural disasters with customizable coverage options. We offer standard HO-3 policies and premium HO-5 plans with additional protections for high-value items. Policyholders benefit from deductible reduction options and guaranteed replacement cost coverage.
Business Insurance
We design comprehensive business insurance packages protecting commercial operations from industry-specific risks. Our offerings include general liability, property insurance, and business interruption coverage tailored to each client's operational profile. Specialized policies address cyber liability, professional errors, and equipment breakdowns for diverse business sectors.
Commercial Auto
Our commercial auto insurance covers business vehicles including trucks, delivery fleets, and service vehicles. Policies include liability protection, physical damage coverage, and cargo insurance with options for high-risk drivers and specialized equipment. We offer flexible terms for small businesses and large commercial operations.
Workers Compensation
We provide mandatory workers' compensation insurance covering job-related injuries and illnesses across various industries. Our policies meet state requirements while offering additional protections for high-risk occupations. We partner with carriers offering safety training programs and claims management support to reduce workplace incidents.
People
Levi Thetford
President
Levi Thetford leads All American Insurance with over two decades of insurance expertise. He specializes in risk assessment and policy optimization, maintaining multiple industry certifications. His client-focused approach emphasizes transparent communication and comprehensive coverage analysis.
Rebekkah Madole
VP/Insurance Producer
Rebekkah Madole manages commercial insurance accounts with specialized knowledge in business risk management. She holds advanced certifications in commercial liability coverage and has developed customized insurance solutions for Oklahoma businesses since 2010.
Matthew Madole
Insurance Producer
Matthew Madole focuses on personal insurance lines with expertise in auto and home coverage optimization. He has earned recognition for exceptional client service and maintains active licenses in multiple states to better serve regional clients.
Jocelyne Sanchez
Insurance Producer
Jocelyne Sanchez specializes in specialty insurance products including motorcycle and recreational vehicle coverage. She provides multilingual support and has developed expertise in unique asset protection strategies for diverse client needs.
Zachary Madole
CSR
Zachary Madole handles policy administration and client relations with a focus on efficient claims processing. He maintains industry certifications in customer service excellence and has streamlined policy management processes since joining the agency in 2018.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, motorcycle, commercial auto, workers compensation, commercial property, personal umbrella, and renters insurance for clients in Oklahoma, Missouri, and Texas.
Are you licensed in multiple states?
Yes, our agents maintain active licenses in Oklahoma, Missouri, and Texas to serve clients across these regions with consistent insurance solutions and regulatory compliance.
How quickly can I get insurance coverage?
We offer same-day policy issuance for most personal insurance products and can typically establish business coverage within 24-48 hours after completing risk assessments.
Do you provide 24/7 claims support?
Yes, we offer 24-hour claims reporting through our partner carriers with dedicated adjusters available to assist policyholders at any time.
Can you help lower my current insurance rates?
Our team specializes in policy comparisons and has reduced premiums for 85% of clients through carrier switching and coverage optimization while maintaining adequate protection levels.
What sets you apart from other agencies?
As an independent agency with 35+ years of local experience, we combine multi-carrier options with personalized service to deliver customized insurance solutions focused on client needs rather than company profits.
Videos
Reviews (7)
Tulsa Cannabis Staffing Solutions
Jun 14, 2022
Report
THIS PLACE IS A BUNCH OF BALONEY! SCAM ARTISTS! LIARS! THEY TOOK MY MONEY FOR BUSINESS INSURANCE AND GOT ME INSURANCE THAT DIDN'T EVEN ACCEPT BY TYPE OF BUSINESS AND WOULDN'T REFUND MY MONEY! HEY OWNER, I KNOW WHO WROTE MY POLICY AND SHE'S THE ONLY ONE THAT ANSWERS THE PHONE AND I KNOW SHE STILL WORKS THERE. LIAR. Response to you: (since I can't respond directly to your response, I will edit to include here) I have all the paperwork to support my claim.
You are really saying several months! Ha! They cancelled my insurance a month later. I got the paperwork and that's why the carrier refunded me for YOUR mistake. And I have the emails to prove who wrote my policy and she's the same JO that answers the phone. And NO ONE told me anything about a non-refundable fee, you were the first to say it. Your just trying to cover your a$$. I'll let the Insurance Commission deal with it from here on out. I have all the proof.
You are really saying several months! Ha! They cancelled my insurance a month later. I got the paperwork and that's why the carrier refunded me for YOUR mistake. And I have the emails to prove who wrote my policy and she's the same JO that answers the phone. And NO ONE told me anything about a non-refundable fee, you were the first to say it. Your just trying to cover your a$$. I'll let the Insurance Commission deal with it from here on out. I have all the proof.
Cristy
Jun 14, 2022
Report
Had higher expectations until I had an issue but I never read all the bad reviews until now. Then realized many had the same issue as me. Very disappointed in this place!
T. C. Ray
Nov 11, 2021
Report
For construction insurance, it's the best place to go with the most affordable rates for the established contractor or those just starting out. However for auto insurance, their prices and coverage isn't the best in town.
Michael Robinette
Sep 18, 2021
Report
They are awesome professional and curtious and had a insurence policy for a reasonable price would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for car insurance.
Mary Ann Elam
Aug 13, 2021
Report
Critical: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value This is the worst Insurance Agency. They don't want to services existing customers! I have called at least 4 times to have a lienholder removed. I get my policy and it's still there. That is not a difficult thing to do.
MrLonghorn
Dec 16, 2020
Report
They help me out I giving me my policy number and the number to call road hazard so I could get my keys out of my truck with no damage to the vehicle. I'm very pleased by having All American Insurance as my insurance provider. I will definitely keep doing business with this company.
Yari Tahnee Cabrera Westerheidy
Nov 29, 2020
Report
I had to get a quick house insurance quote and Jocelyn was able to email it to me and I was able to sign and upload them right back! Super convenient as attentive to time sensitive requests. Awesome service.
