Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Lima & Bluffton, Ohio
Founded in 1906, Webb Insurance Agency has grown from a single policy sold by Glen C. Webb to the largest independent insurance agency in West Central Ohio. With 30+ experienced professionals across two offices in Lima and Bluffton, we specialize in personal, commercial, life, and group insurance solutions. Our five dedicated departments deliver tailored coverage through a risk-evaluation approach, combining century-old expertise with modern insurance needs. We prioritize personalized service, competitive pricing, and comprehensive protection for individuals and businesses alike. 
Services
Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Health & Group Benefits
Claims Services
Details
- Year established: 1906
Highlights and features
- Over 115 years of continuous insurance expertise in West Central Ohio
- 30+ experienced professionals across five specialized insurance departments
- Personalized risk assessment and coverage recommendations
- Access to multiple top-tier insurance carriers for competitive pricing
- Locally-owned agency with deep community knowledge
What people say
Knowledgeable agents
Personalized service
Competitive rates
Efficient claims process
Local expertise
Services
Personal Insurance
Protect your personal assets with customized coverage for homes, vehicles, and valuable possessions. We offer policies for auto, motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles, and personal liability. Our agents help Ohio residents secure comprehensive protection tailored to their lifestyle and property needs.
Business Insurance
Comprehensive risk management solutions for businesses of all sizes. Our commercial insurance includes property, liability, professional liability, and specialized coverage for equipment and operations. We develop customized protection plans to safeguard Ohio businesses from industry-specific risks and potential financial losses.
Life Insurance
Secure your family's financial future with term and permanent life insurance options. We offer individual and group life policies, including payroll deduction plans for businesses. Our agents provide guidance on fixed whole life, universal life, and annuity products to meet diverse estate planning and income protection needs.
Health & Group Benefits
Complete health insurance and employee benefit solutions for individuals and businesses. Our offerings include medical, dental, vision, disability, and long-term care coverage. We help Ohio employers design competitive benefit packages while assisting individuals with personalized health insurance selections and account management.
Claims Services
Dedicated claims assistance for policyholders experiencing covered losses. Our team streamlines the claims process for personal and commercial insurance holders, providing timely evaluation and resolution. We advocate for clients to ensure fair treatment and efficient processing through their insurance carrier.
People
Glen C. Webb
Founder
Established the agency in 1906 by selling the first policy in Lima, Ohio. His entrepreneurial spirit laid the foundation for a century of growth and community-focused insurance services.
Kaydrie Rayle
Personal Lines Manager
Leads the personal insurance department with expertise in home, auto, and specialty coverage. Provides tailored solutions for individual policyholders across West Central Ohio.
Michelle Early
Commercial Lines Manager
Manages business insurance solutions with specialized knowledge in commercial liability and risk assessment. Helps Ohio businesses protect assets through comprehensive coverage strategies.
Mark Altstaetter
Life Insurance Agent
Offers expert guidance on life insurance products including term, whole life, and annuities. Specializes in helping clients create financial security plans for their families.
Rebecca Waggamon
Health Insurance Agent
Provides health insurance solutions and manages employee benefit programs. Assists individuals and employers in navigating medical coverage options and retirement planning.
Questions
What types of insurance does Webb Insurance Agency offer?
We provide personal insurance (home, auto, boats), business insurance (property, liability), life insurance (term, whole life), health benefits, and claims services for Ohio residents and businesses.
How can you help small businesses with insurance needs?
Our commercial insurance team conducts risk assessments to create customized protection plans covering property, liability, equipment, and professional liability for businesses of all sizes.
Do you offer life insurance for families?
Yes, we offer term life, whole life, and universal life insurance policies to protect families financially, including payroll deduction options for business employees.
What health insurance options are available?
We provide individual and group health plans, dental, vision, disability coverage, and medical savings accounts tailored to personal and employer needs across Ohio.
Where are your offices located?
Our main office is at 212 W. High St., Lima, OH 45801, with a branch at 105 S. Main St., Bluffton, OH 45817, serving West Central Ohio communities.
Reviews (4)
D. Rittner
Mar 17, 2022
Report
Can't get anywhere with them. Had no record of my appointment when I arrived. Failed to call back and more.
Christina Wildermuth
Sep 27, 2021
Report
Webb insurance found the best policy for my young son. It was a quick and easy process. I can rest at night knowing he has the proper coverage at the best price. Thank you Webb for your help.
Stephanie Platt
May 05, 2021
Report
I've been a Webb customer for over a year now and it is nothing short of a great experience. They treat you like family and do everything they can to help you out! Michael Sarno is my agent and Emily Erb is the one who assists on everything, if you need anything give them a call! They find the lowest prices and best quality!
Holly Platt
Feb 09, 2021
Report
Very friendly customer service. Emily Erb helped me with all my questions and made me feel at ease with my concerns. She explained everything very well and seemed very knowledgeable. Thank you!
