Gibbel Insurance

Protect your home and personal belongings with comprehensive coverage for property damage, liability, and additional living expenses. Our policies include specialized protection for valuable items, natural disasters, and rental income loss. Designed for homeowners in Lititz and Lancaster County seeking reliable, customizable coverage.

Comprehensive auto coverage with liability, collision, and comprehensive protection for vehicles of all types. Available for personal and commercial use in Pennsylvania, including specialized coverage for high-value vehicles and business fleets. Discounts available for safe drivers and multi-policy holders.

Customizable insurance packages for Pennsylvania businesses including liability, property, workers' compensation, and business interruption coverage. Specialized policies for auto dealerships, landlords, and construction industry risks. Available with flexible payment options and expert claims support.

Term and permanent life insurance policies to protect families and business partners. Policies include death benefit protection, cash value accumulation options, and estate planning benefits. Available for individuals seeking coverage for young families or business succession planning.

Personal and small business health insurance plans with options for HMO, PPO, and high-deductible plans. Specialized Pennsylvania coverage including Medicare supplements and health savings accounts. Expert guidance for individuals in different life stages.

Fourth-generation leader of Gibbel Insurance with 25+ years of experience in the insurance industry. Specializes in commercial risk management and community-focused insurance solutions. Committed to maintaining the agency's local ownership and customer-first philosophy established in 1890.

We specialize in personal and commercial insurance including home, auto, life, health, business, flood, boat, and motorcycle insurance for clients in Pennsylvania.

Yes, we offer specialized landlord insurance policies that cover property damage, liability, and rental income loss for secondary homes in Pennsylvania.

Gibbel Insurance Agency has been serving clients since 1890, with four generations of family leadership maintaining our local commitment.

Yes, we provide tailored business insurance packages including liability, property, workers' compensation, and industry-specific coverage for Pennsylvania small businesses.

We offer evening and Saturday appointments by request. Emergency claims services are available through our 24-hour claim submission system.

As a locally owned agency since 1890, we combine personalized service with access to multiple carriers to find you optimal coverage at competitive rates.

While purchasing a new home, Gibbel Insurance was recommended by my real estate agent. I was looking into two other agencies when I originally talked to Bill Barshinger about setting up a homeowner's policy. Bill was the only agent to get back to me in a timely manner and provide me with an affordable policy. During a time when everything is automatic and owned by large corporations, it is refreshing to work with a local company and talk to local people.

While I hope I do not have to file any claims in the near future, I am confident that my future interactions with Gibbel Insurance will be as pleasant as my original interaction with Bill, and I will recommend their services.

Gibbel Insurance has been our insurance agency/broker for more than 14 years. They have always been responsive and provided great customer service. Carol is absolutely the best! She takes the time to answer your questions, explain coverage options and keeps your interest in mind all while remaining calm & professional. Rates are competitive and customized coverages are provided.

I've used Gibbel Insurance for years and years. Always a great company to deal with and so professional! Today I had the pleasure to start my day with Beverly Leontis! She emailed me reminding me of my upcoming auto policy renewal. She said she could save me hundreds and that's exactly what she did! . My upcoming bill was $845.00 for 6 months. now it's $495.00! With the same company no less! Happy Friday to me! Beverly was absolutely wonderful! Worked most of her day on my policy with the utmost professionalism and knowledge and a wonderful personality! Bev was my angel for today! Thank you Bev!

Having recently moved to Lititz from another state I was, of course, needing to establish new property, casualty and general liability personal insurance. My research identified a number of very reputable agencies in and around Lititz. I made inquiries to three and all came back promptly with very professional and competitive proposals. Then a friend asked if I had inquired with Gibbel Insurance here in town.

I had not, so I used their website to request a proposal. I soon received a phone call from Ethan who asked questions that gave him more details of my situation but also indicated he wanted to make sure he would have products that would offer a competitive proposal, which would be my fourth to consider. When I received Ethan's proposal soon after our phone call, it was clear that he had thoughtfully considered all of our personal insurance needs and proposed a company and products that were even more competitive than the others I had previously received.

I then researched the company he was proposing which confirmed they were in good standing with their business practices and customer service in the community. I can recommend the Gibbel agency without hesitation.

Mr. Gibbel was able to assist me in both my auto and homeowners insurance needs for years. I recommend Gibbel Insurance Agency to everyone! They care about their customers and take the time to make sure all your needs are taken care of in a timely and professional matter.

The level of service I receive from Gibbel Insurance Agency exceeds that of any vendor I've worked with. The team is top notch, and I cannot recommend them highly enough.