Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Beaverton, MI
Schumacher Insurance has been a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions since 1953. Our agency specializes in tailoring personalized coverage for individuals and businesses across Beaverton and surrounding areas. With a team of licensed professionals, we offer expertise in property, casualty, life, health, and commercial insurance. Our commitment to exceptional customer service is reflected in our decades-long relationships with clients and our active involvement in the communities we serve. We pride ourselves on simplifying the insurance process through personalized guidance and competitive rates.By representing multiple top-tier insurance carriers, we ensure our clients receive optimal coverage that meets their unique needs. Our agency's longevity and reputation are built on integrity, reliability, and a deep understanding of local market requirements. We continuously strive to maintain our position as a leading independent insurance agency in Michigan through innovation and dedicated service.
Services
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Renters Insurance
Workers' Compensation
Surety Bonding
Property Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1953
Highlights and features
- We have over 70 years of experience serving Michigan communities
- Our team includes certified insurance professionals with local expertise
- We offer personalized coverage options from multiple top-rated carriers
- We provide 24/7 personalized customer support for urgent needs
- Our agency actively contributes to community development initiatives
What people say
Exceptional customer service
Knowledgeable local experts
Personalized coverage options
Community involvement
Responsive support team
Services
Personal Insurance
We provide comprehensive personal insurance solutions tailored to protect individuals and families. Our offerings include auto, home, renters, and recreational vehicle insurance. With flexible policy options and competitive rates, we help clients safeguard their personal assets while ensuring compliance with Michigan's insurance requirements. Our agents work closely with clients to create customized coverage plans that adapt to changing life circumstances.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance services protect businesses of all sizes across Mid-Michigan. We offer property, liability, auto, and workers' compensation coverage, along with specialized surety bonding solutions. Our experienced commercial team understands industry-specific risks and develops comprehensive protection strategies that support business continuity. We represent multiple carriers to ensure competitive pricing and optimal coverage for diverse business operations.
Life & Health Insurance
We offer life and health insurance products designed to protect families and individuals against unexpected events. Our solutions include term life policies, health coverage options, and supplemental insurance products. Our licensed agents help clients navigate complex insurance markets to find affordable protection plans that meet their financial security needs while providing peace of mind for their loved ones.
Workers' Compensation
Our certified workers' compensation specialists provide essential protection for Michigan businesses and their employees. We offer comprehensive coverage solutions that comply with state regulations while protecting employers from financial risks associated with workplace injuries. Our services include policy customization, risk assessment, and claims support to ensure businesses maintain safe working environments while managing insurance costs effectively.
Surety Bonding
We provide various surety bond solutions to meet business and legal requirements across Michigan. Our offerings include contract bonds, license and permit bonds, and court bonds tailored to specific industry needs. Our experienced team helps clients understand bonding requirements and secure appropriate coverage from trusted carriers, ensuring compliance with regulatory standards while protecting business interests.
People
Amy Tenwalde
Licensed Agent
A lifelong Beaverton resident with over a decade of insurance experience, Amy specializes in personal lines coverage. She holds an Associates degree in Small Business Management and combines local knowledge with personalized service to meet client needs.
Karolyn Smith
Licensed Agent
With over two decades of insurance experience in Central Michigan, Karolyn provides expert guidance in property and casualty insurance. Her community involvement and commitment to customer service make her a trusted advisor for Clare area clients.
Kelsey Redman
Commercial Lines Specialist
A certified workers' compensation expert since 2013, Kelsey brings specialized knowledge to commercial insurance clients. Her understanding of local business needs helps companies secure comprehensive protection tailored to their specific operations.
Patty Gerow
Office Manager
As a Certified Professional Insurance Agent with over three decades of experience, Patty oversees agency operations while maintaining direct client relationships. Her extensive knowledge contributes to the agency's consistent service excellence.
Tony Smith
Licensed Agent
A Beaverton native with prior underwriting experience, Tony combines technical insurance knowledge with community ties. His background in multiple insurance markets enhances his ability to provide well-rounded coverage solutions for personal and business clients.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (auto, home, life), commercial coverage (business property, liability), workers' compensation, surety bonds, and health insurance solutions tailored to Michigan residents and businesses.
How do you help find the best insurance rates?
As independent agents representing multiple carriers, we compare coverage options and pricing to find policies that balance protection needs with budget considerations for each client.
Do you serve areas outside Beaverton?
While based in Beaverton, we serve clients throughout Mid-Michigan including Clare, Gladwin County, and surrounding communities with both personal and commercial insurance services.
What are your business hours?
Our offices operate Monday through Friday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. Emergency contact options are available for urgent insurance needs outside regular business hours.
How does your claims assistance work?
Our team provides personalized claims support, guiding clients through the process and advocating for fair resolutions. We maintain direct communication with insurance carriers to ensure timely claim processing.
Reviews (5)
Jody Giles
Apr 27, 2022
Report
By far THE BEST INSURANCE AGENCY EVER! THANK YOU STEVE CARLAND for ALWAYS being there to help me with ALL of our insurance needs in life!
Katie Heppler
Jun 24, 2021
Report
Any time I have a question or need, Schumacher Agency has been there for me. They know exactly how to help, ask the right questions, and make you feel like you're a member of their "family". Couldn't be happier with their service.
Alea Bristal
Feb 27, 2021
Report
They have always been great with us. Called us when they saw a chance at a savings when we bought our new house (on Auto Insurance none the less!). When I dealt with our business insurance I dealt with Kelsey and she was ALWAYS great, quick and efficient. She goes beyond her job and is friendly & caring - always brings a smile to my face. I definitely recommend this company! Give them a shot at least. :)
Joshua Hoffman
Nov 24, 2020
Report
Always excellent customer service. Thanks, Amy, for knowledgeable advice and efficient response to my requests!
Trei Herbster
Nov 17, 2020
Report
Very Friendly, Professional, and Responsive. They do their best to give the most affordable quotes for Commercial and Personal insurance coverage!
