Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Geneva, OH
Crawford Agency has served Ashtabula County and Northeast Ohio for over 80 years with comprehensive insurance solutions. As a locally owned independent agency, our team of experienced professionals specializes in home, auto, business, and life insurance tailored to individual client needs. Founded in 1944, we maintain a legacy of personalized service, treating clients like family while providing expert guidance through evolving insurance landscapes.Our staff combines decades of collective experience with ongoing industry education to ensure clients receive optimal coverage. We prioritize transparency in policy details and maintain proactive communication to address changing insurance requirements. With multiple generations of leadership, we've built enduring relationships through reliability and community-focused service that extends beyond standard insurance offerings.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Commercial Package Policies
Details
- Year established: 1944
Highlights and features
- We've provided insurance expertise in Northeast Ohio for over 80 years
- Our team includes agents with 25-50 years of industry experience
- We offer personalized policy reviews and annual coverage updates
- We maintain direct client communication channels with prompt responsiveness
- Our agency has multi-generational leadership continuity since 1944
What people say
Impeccable service
Best coverage available
Responsive follow-up
Confidence in coverage
Personalized approach
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance policies protect against property damage and personal belongings loss while offering customizable options for homeowners and condo residents. We provide all-risk dwelling coverage, personal liability protection, and specialized endorsements for unique needs. With over 80 years of local experience, we ensure comprehensive protection that adapts to changing homeowner requirements while maintaining competitive pricing through multiple carrier partnerships.
Auto Insurance
We offer comprehensive auto insurance solutions covering liability, collision, and comprehensive damages with options for uninsured motorist coverage and specialized protections. Our policies include gap coverage, rental reimbursement, and automobile death benefits while providing personalized risk assessment to match individual driving needs with optimal coverage levels and deductibles.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance packages protect operations with general liability, property insurance, and workers' compensation while offering specialized industry-specific solutions. We provide tailored coverage for commercial vehicles, professional liability, and umbrella policies with expert consultation to address unique business risks across various sectors including hospitality, healthcare, and manufacturing.
Life Insurance
We offer term life, whole life, and universal life insurance policies to ensure financial security for loved ones with options for disability coverage and voluntary payroll deduction plans. Our agents provide personalized guidance to create protection strategies that cover outstanding debts, replace income, and support long-term financial planning objectives.
People
Jim Crawford
President/Agent
Second-generation insurance professional with 50 years of agency experience, now semi-retired but maintaining active client relationships while overseeing strategic direction.
Mike Goddard
Vice President/Agent
30-year agency veteran and step-son of Jim Crawford, managing commercial lines while balancing family life and personal interests in golf and family time.
Patricia Traylor
Commercial Lines Manager/Agent
40-year insurance professional with 25 years at the agency, specializing in commercial risk management while maintaining notary public certification and active community involvement.
Kimberly Domino
Personal Lines Manager/Agent
30-year agency team member holding CISR certification, focusing on personal lines with dedication to customer service excellence while balancing family commitments.
Doug Alvord
Life Insurance Agent
40-year life insurance specialist providing retirement planning solutions and annuity products, combining industry expertise with personal financial planning experience.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, auto, business, and life insurance with specialized commercial packages for specific industries like restaurants and healthcare providers.
Why choose Crawford Agency over other insurers?
Our 80+ years of local experience, personalized service approach, and multi-carrier partnerships provide tailored solutions with responsive agent support.
Do you serve areas beyond Geneva, OH?
We primarily serve Ashtabula County and Northeast Ohio, maintaining deep local knowledge while serving clients across the region.
What sets your business insurance apart?
We offer specialized industry packages with expert consultation to create comprehensive protection plans tailored to specific business operations and risks.
Can I get a free insurance quote?
Contact us directly through our website contact form or by phone to receive personalized coverage assessments and competitive quotes.
Reviews (6)
Carole Klaue
Jan 05, 2022
Report
I have been a customer since the 1970 or 1971. I love seeing the same faces for years. So friendly and like family. Best prices and great advice on plans. When some thing happens, they take care of you and get right on it. We have never been disappointed in this business.
Tony Capo
Jan 04, 2019
Report
Courteous, professional, and honest. Our family has been with the Crawford Agency for well over 25 years. A cornerstone of the community and all around great people. Thank you!
Dave Johnson
Dec 25, 2018
Report
The Crawford Agency has always met my needs for insurance providing great, personal service and coverage at a reasonable price. Whenever I had a claim they always handled promptly and looked ok for my interests
Bill Bousquet
Nov 01, 2018
Report
Very! Service minded, always polite and Helpful. Mike and his office people are very knowledgeable and Great people to work with.
John
Sep 04, 2018
Report
Crawford Agency is a great insurance company to work with. Always able to answer any questions I have. Great people and very knowledgeable.
Heaven Laird
Jan 02, 2018
Report
Crawford is great and a one stop shop for all of your insurance needs! My agent has gone above and beyond! We have our auto, home, and commercial through them! Have been with them for 8+ years!
