Business Details
29 Years
experience
Emergency
services
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Reynoldsburg, OH
John W Neighbarger Insurance Agency has served the Greater Columbus Area for over 40 years, delivering personalized insurance solutions with unwavering commitment to client satisfaction. Founded in 1997 by John Neighbarger, a second-generation insurance professional holding Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and Life Underwriter Training Council Fellow (LUTCF) designations, our agency combines deep industry expertise with a local touch. We specialize in auto, homeowner's, boat and marine, life, and business insurance, partnering with Erie Insurance to offer exclusive benefits like rate-lock guarantees and guaranteed dwelling replacement coverage.Our team prioritizes direct communication, ensuring clients interact with the same familiar faces for policy changes, claims, and consultations. With a focus on tailored coverage and transparent service, we protect what matters most to individuals and businesses across Reynoldsburg and surrounding communities. Our dedication to proactive risk management and policy reviews ensures clients remain prepared for evolving challenges, solidifying our reputation as a trusted insurance partner in Central Ohio.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowner's Insurance
Boat & Marine Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1997
Highlights and features
- We offer 40+ years of insurance expertise with certified professionals.
- Our team provides personalized service with consistent client contact.
- We partner with Erie Insurance for exclusive rate-lock guarantees.
- We specialize in tailored coverage for individuals and businesses.
- Our agency maintains proactive policy reviews for evolving needs.
Associations and certifications
- Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC)
- Life Underwriter Training Council Fellow (LUTCF)
What people say
Exceptional insurance solutions
Personalized service
Free quotes available
Reliable claims process
Certified professionals
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies provide comprehensive protection for vehicles and drivers. We offer liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage options tailored to individual needs. With flexible payment plans and partnerships with carriers like Erie Insurance, clients receive competitive rates and exclusive benefits such as 24/7 claims support. Our team ensures policyholders understand their coverage details and available discounts.
Homeowner's Insurance
We provide guaranteed dwelling replacement coverage and rate-lock guarantees for homeowner's insurance. Policies protect against property damage, theft, and liability while offering customizable options for unique home features. Our agency works closely with clients to assess risk factors and recommend appropriate coverage limits, ensuring homes remain protected against unforeseen events in Central Ohio.
Business Insurance
Our business insurance solutions protect companies of all sizes in Columbus and surrounding areas. We offer general liability, commercial property, workers' compensation, and professional liability coverage. Policies address specific industry risks while ensuring compliance with state regulations. Our team provides risk assessments and policy reviews to help businesses maintain continuous protection against evolving threats.
Life Insurance
We offer term, whole, and universal life insurance policies to secure families' financial futures. Our certified agents help clients evaluate coverage needs based on income, debts, and long-term goals. Policies provide death benefits for mortgage protection, education funding, and estate planning. We guide clients through policy selection and beneficiary designation to ensure comprehensive financial protection.
Boat & Marine Insurance
Our boat and marine insurance policies protect various watercraft types including sailboats, motorboats, and yachts. Coverage includes damage protection, theft recovery, and liability insurance. Policies account for seasonal usage patterns and storage requirements. Our agency ensures boat owners understand coverage limitations and recommended safety measures to maintain policy validity.
People
John W. Neighbarger
Owner
Second-generation insurance professional with CIC and LUTCF certifications. Founded the agency in 1997 after growing up in the industry. Specializes in personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Central Ohio.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, homeowner's, boat & marine, life, and business insurance solutions tailored to individual and commercial needs.
How can I get a free quote?
Contact us via phone or our website's request form to receive a personalized, no-obligation insurance quote within one business day.
Do you offer 24/7 claims support?
Yes, through our partnership with Erie Insurance, clients can file claims 24/7 via phone at (800) 367-3743 after regular business hours.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, checks, cash, automatic bank withdrawals, and online payments for Erie, Progressive, and Hagerty policies.
Are there any exclusive benefits for policyholders?
Erie Insurance clients receive rate-lock guarantees and guaranteed dwelling replacement coverage on homeowner's policies.
How do I refer a friend for rewards?
Mention our referral program at policy renewal to receive a gift card when your referred friend purchases a qualifying insurance policy.
Reviews (6)
Abick
Apr 26, 2022
Report
Mr. Neighbarger has been my insurance agent for over 20 years. He and the others in the office have always been prompt in responding to calls. Everyone is friendly and pleasant. All claims have been handled promptly. Even more, when I've called with an issue I didn't know how to handle they have been helpful with advice and assistance. They are truly nice people. As long as they want my business, they'll have it.
Michael Benson
Apr 14, 2022
Report
Absolutely top quality from the top down.customer service gets an extra star for how much they stepped up for my claim.
Neal Resnik
Feb 25, 2022
Report
Working with John and Debbie has been excellent. John brings over 25+ years of insurance expertise to his customers and is very much a one on one, personal approach to all of his clients. If you have auto insurance, car insurance or even insurance needs your business, give John a call!
Michael Wood
Jun 23, 2020
Report
Been with John and Erie since 2001. Quick service, very professional. Getting to deal with a real agent and not a call center or computerized system makes for fewer mistakes and is super easier on me, the customer. I know I can call John and get what I need.
James Waymire
May 31, 2020
Report
Great experience for home and auto. Will never look for another insurance agency as long as John and Erie are in business.
Victoria M.
May 18, 2019
Report
God awful insurance company. Quoted me, has me switch, pay over $200 then 2 weeks later CANCELLED MY POLICY.
