Business Details
43 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Reynoldsburg, OH
Arnold Insurance Agency has been a trusted partner for Ohio businesses and individuals since 1983. Our employee-owned agency specializes in commercial insurance, personal insurance, surety bonds, and risk management solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of contractors and small businesses. With over 40 years of experience, we collaborate with leading national and regional insurers to provide comprehensive coverage that simplifies claims and offers exceptional protection. Our team of certified professionals, including CRM, CIC, and CPCU agents, delivers personalized service without call centers, ensuring clients receive expert guidance and competitive rates. We pride ourselves on understanding the specific challenges faced by contractors, having protected over 1,000 contractors and secured $1 billion in construction project bonding annually.Our commitment to excellence extends to personal insurance lines, including auto, home, life, and recreational vehicle coverage, backed by decades of local expertise. As an independent agency, we prioritize client relationships over profits, offering free consultations and customized insurance strategies that align with business goals. Our office in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, serves clients statewide with office hours Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. We combine industry certifications, specialized risk management approaches, and direct marketing initiatives to deliver innovative solutions that address evolving insurance challenges. From cyber liability to inland marine insurance, our comprehensive offerings ensure clients receive tailored protection without compromising coverage quality.
Services
Commercial Insurance
Personal Insurance
Surety Bonds
Risk Management
Cyber Liability Insurance
Workers' Compensation
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Inland Marine Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1983
Highlights and features
- We have over 40 years of experience in Ohio construction insurance.
- Our team includes certified risk managers and industry specialists.
- We are an employee-owned agency committed to client relationships.
- We offer competitive rates through partnerships with top insurers.
- We provide personalized service without call center intermediaries.
Services
Commercial Insurance
Arnold Insurance Agency provides comprehensive commercial insurance for small to mid-sized contractors in Ohio. Our policies include general liability, business owners policies, and commercial auto coverage tailored to mitigate industry-specific risks. With over 40 years of experience, we ensure businesses receive customized protection that aligns with their operational goals while maintaining competitive pricing.
Surety Bonds
We specialize in surety bond solutions for construction projects across Ohio. Our services cover contract bonds, performance bonds, and miscellaneous bonding needs with relationships to 300+ underwriters. Certified agents provide expert guidance to secure bonding totaling over $1 billion annually for construction projects, ensuring compliance and financial security for contractors.
Risk Management
Our risk management services help businesses identify and mitigate potential threats through customized strategies. Certified risk managers with 45+ years of industry experience evaluate operations to implement proactive measures. This includes cyber liability protection, employment practices liability, and inland marine coverage for tools and equipment, reducing claims and enhancing business continuity.
Personal Insurance
We offer tailored personal insurance solutions including auto, home, life, and recreational vehicle policies. Our agents provide high-value home insurance, flood coverage, and personal umbrella policies to protect families across Ohio. With free consultations and partnerships with top insurers, we ensure clients receive comprehensive protection at competitive rates without compromising service quality.
Workers' Compensation
Our workers' compensation insurance protects Ohio businesses against claims for work-related injuries or illnesses. We provide policies that meet state requirements while offering additional protections through partnerships with leading insurers. Our team ensures streamlined claims processing and risk assessment services to minimize workplace liabilities and maintain regulatory compliance for contractors.
People
Mark Arnold
President
Founder of Arnold Insurance Agency since 1983, Mark grew the business to serve 400+ contractors annually and secure $1 billion in construction project bonding. He specializes in surety and construction insurance, combining industry expertise with personalized client relationships to deliver tailored insurance solutions across Ohio.
Harry Bound
Agent
Certified Risk Manager with 45+ years in surety and insurance. Harry graduated from Wittenberg University in 1970 and served on boards for Independent Insurance Agents of Columbus. He provides expert risk assessment and bonding solutions, leveraging extensive industry experience to develop customized insurance strategies for Ohio contractors.
Jason Daniels
Commercial Insurance/Bonding Agent
Jason graduated from the University of Dayton in 1998 and specializes in consultative sales for commercial insurance. He evaluates business risks to create tailored insurance and bonding programs across Ohio, focusing on construction and small business sectors. His approach combines risk management expertise with personalized service to protect client assets.
Amy Dillon
Personal Lines Specialist
Amy joined Arnold Insurance in 2019 with extensive experience in personal lines coverage. She specializes in home, auto, renters, farm, and boat insurance, helping Ohio residents find competitive rates. Her client-focused approach ensures personalized service for all personal insurance needs, from standard policies to specialized coverage options.
Nick Buss
Marketing Specialist
Nick graduated from Western Michigan University and manages digital marketing initiatives for the agency. He oversees website development, social media, lead generation, and direct marketing campaigns. His work enhances client engagement and supports sales teams through innovative digital strategies while maintaining the agency's online presence.
Questions
What types of insurance does Arnold Insurance Agency offer?
We provide commercial insurance, personal insurance, surety bonds, risk management, and workers' compensation coverage tailored to Ohio contractors and small businesses.
Do you specialize in contractor insurance?
Yes, we've protected over 1,000 Ohio contractors with tailored insurance and bonding solutions since 1983, securing $1 billion in annual construction project bonding.
What areas do you serve?
While based in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, we provide insurance and bonding services to clients statewide with local expertise and personalized support.
Are you an independent insurance agency?
Yes, we partner with leading national and regional insurers to offer competitive policies that balance comprehensive coverage with affordable pricing options.
What sets you apart from other agencies?
We're employee-owned with 40+ years of experience, certified risk management specialists, and a commitment to personalized service without call centers.
Reviews (5)
Hayden Basinger
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Recently started a commercial policy here. Within a few days Jason had a policy up and running for me with everything I requested in it. Everyone there has gotten back to me in no time if I've needed something. Would highly recommend!
Monique Davis
Oct 14, 2021
Report
I work at Setterlin Building Company and process the insurance paperwork for all of our subcontractors, suppliers, etc. I want to let you know that every time I have to submit a request for a renewal or anything else I'm ALWAYS given the most exceptional service from your agents. I mostly deal with Niki, Kim and Becky. Whenever I realize that your company is the producer, I can smile and breathe a sigh of relief, because I know that I will receive prompt service that is handled right the first time.
I believe in giving honor to whom honor is due. Today, I want to honor your company and specifically those ladies for maintaining such a high standard of quality service. I don't have the privilege of being able to say that about many others in your industry, but I truly appreciate the consistency of greatness that I receive from each of them. Please share my sentiments with them and their managers so they can be recognized for a job well done every time. Have a great day and stay safe! Regards, Monique S. Davis
I believe in giving honor to whom honor is due. Today, I want to honor your company and specifically those ladies for maintaining such a high standard of quality service. I don't have the privilege of being able to say that about many others in your industry, but I truly appreciate the consistency of greatness that I receive from each of them. Please share my sentiments with them and their managers so they can be recognized for a job well done every time. Have a great day and stay safe! Regards, Monique S. Davis
Becky Kristof-Bryner
Mar 03, 2021
Report
Hands down the best customer service you can get with the best knowledge around! Give them a call for your bonding, commercial & personal insurance needs
C. W. Cox
Nov 16, 2019
Report
I have received great service from Arnold Insurance Agency and recommend them to you if you are shopping for a new agency and insurance coverage. Mike has been easy to work with and provided us with good insurance coverage for both our home and auto needs along with decent rates, something my last agency was lax on.
David Burkholder
Aug 31, 2019
Report
BEWARE, ,, if you are making an honest claim without lawyers to fight it, ,d ealt with Mark Arnold, ,,,D avid at Rolling Acres Rental, ,
