Browse the Top 4 Insurance Companies Serving Westerville, OH

Kalmbaugh Insurance offers personalized insurance solutions across home, auto, business, and specialty coverage areas in Westerville, Ohio. With 50 years of local expertise and a team holding national certifications, we provide customized policies through top-rated carriers while maintaining a client-first approach to claims advocacy and service.

Associated Insurance Agencies is an independent insurance provider offering auto, home, commercial, life, health, and specialty insurance products. Based in Westerville, Ohio, we serve clients across Ohio and Florida with personalized coverage solutions. Our team of 50+ advisors partners with over 20 insurers to deliver tailored protection and exceptional service.

Benchmark Insurance is an independent agency offering tailored employee benefits and business insurance solutions. With over 40 years of experience, we provide personalized service through principal-led account management and access to top carriers. Our expertise spans health insurance, COBRA administration, and compliance support for businesses in Central Ohio and nationwide.

Phelps Financial Service specializes in financial planning, insurance solutions, and risk management tailored for non-profits, churches, and individuals. Our mission focuses on mitigating risks through customized insurance products, proactive risk management strategies, and comprehensive disaster recovery plans. With over 25 years of experience, we help clients protect their assets and achieve long-term financial security.