Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Menomonee Falls
Founded in 1975, Colonial Insurance has dedicated over four decades to providing comprehensive personal, business, and life insurance solutions. As a proud member of the Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin, we partner with leading insurance carriers to deliver tailored products and competitive pricing. Our commitment to personalized service ensures clients receive value-driven recommendations that protect their assets and future. With a 97% retention rate, we prioritize building long-term relationships through exceptional customer service, timely communication, and industry expertise.Our locally owned agency serves Wisconsin residents and businesses, offering independent advice to help clients navigate risk management. Our team of seasoned professionals combines deep regional knowledge with diverse insurance expertise to create customized coverage plans. We guide clients through every stagefrom initial consultation to claims resolutionensuring clarity and confidence in their insurance decisions.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Umbrella Insurance
Life Insurance
Business Insurance
Notary Services
Bond Services
Details
- Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
- Client-focused approach tailoring coverage to individual needs
- Local agents with 45+ combined years of Wisconsin insurance expertise
- 97% client retention rate demonstrating exceptional service consistency
- Competitive pricing through partnerships with multiple top-tier carriers
- Proven expertise in navigating complex insurance claims processes
Associations and certifications
- Professional Insurance Agents of Wisconsin
What people say
Exceptional service
Professional and responsive
Timely communication
Competitive pricing
Trusted advisory relationships
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your property against fire, theft, and weather damage with customized policies. We provide comprehensive coverage options for homeowners, renters, and condo owners. Our advisors help clients understand policy details and select appropriate coverage levels based on property value and risk factors.
Auto Insurance
Comprehensive protection for cars, trucks, motorcycles, and RVs from multiple carriers. We offer liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage tailored to driving habits and vehicle value. Our team compares rates to find affordable options while ensuring adequate protection for Wisconsin drivers.
Umbrella Insurance
Supplemental liability coverage beyond standard home and auto policies. Available in $1M and $2M limits, this protection extends to personal injury lawsuits and property damage claims. We help clients evaluate exposure risks and select appropriate coverage levels starting at $125 annually.
Life Insurance
Secure your family's financial future with term and permanent life insurance options. We offer flexible term coverage for specific timeframes and permanent policies with cash value growth. Our advisors help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts based on income replacement needs and long-term planning goals.
Business Insurance
Customized protection packages for businesses of all sizes. Includes property, liability, workers' compensation, and specialized coverage options. We assess operational risks to create comprehensive policies that protect against business interruptions, equipment damage, and liability claims.
People
Dan MacLeod
Principal Insurance Advisor
20+ years insurance experience, serving Menomonee Falls residents since 2012. Specializes in personalized insurance strategies and risk management solutions.
Jack Larsen
Personal and Commercial Insurance Advisor
9 years corporate risk management experience, transitioned to personal advisory role in 2020. Expertise in commercial insurance and asset protection strategies.
Don MacLeod
Senior Insurance Advisor
45-year insurance veteran with expertise in complex policy solutions and claim restoration. Active in local community charity initiatives and blood donation programs.
Chris Heller
Personal Insurance Advisor
Former math teacher with 36 years educational experience, applying analytical skills to insurance policy analysis and client education since 2021.
Julie Moll
Office Manager
20+ years insurance industry experience, managing policy administration and claims processing with specialized license credentials.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, auto, life, umbrella, business, notary, and bond insurance services tailored to Wisconsin residents and businesses.
Do you represent multiple insurance companies?
Yes, we partner with numerous top-tier national carriers to offer competitive rates and diverse coverage options.
Are you available for emergency claims assistance?
Our standard business hours are Monday-Thursday 8AM-4:30PM and Friday 8AM-1PM, with after-hours claims support available through our carrier partners.
Can you help with business insurance policy reviews?
Our commercial advisors conduct comprehensive policy evaluations to identify coverage gaps and optimize protection plans.
What makes your agency different from online insurers?
We provide personalized service with local Wisconsin expertise, offering tailored solutions rather than standardized online quotes.
Do you offer policy payment plans?
Payment options vary by carrier, but we work with providers offering flexible payment arrangements for our clients.
Reviews (7)
Diana J.
Jun 20, 2022
Report
Don MacLeod has been a blessing to work with over the past 15+ years! As a single mom, I was trying to navigate the insurance system (*gulp*) and I found Don to be knowledgeable, supportive, kind and efficient. He was a word-of-mouth referral. He was always there to answer questions and still is! You send an email after-hours, you get an immediate system reply! He follows up when he says he will.
Oh and his son Dan has been helping me lately and he is a chip off the old block! (I'm not calling you an "old block" Don, but you know what I mean! ) If you need insurance of any kind--you'd be foolish not to use Colonial! They are the type of people that if they can't help you (which is likely impossible), they would find someone who can. I have NO doubt! Thanks Don, Dan and the Colonial Insurance staff! We love you at the Joy house! (Both of my sons, now adults, are with Colonial Insurance as well!)
Oh and his son Dan has been helping me lately and he is a chip off the old block! (I'm not calling you an "old block" Don, but you know what I mean! ) If you need insurance of any kind--you'd be foolish not to use Colonial! They are the type of people that if they can't help you (which is likely impossible), they would find someone who can. I have NO doubt! Thanks Don, Dan and the Colonial Insurance staff! We love you at the Joy house! (Both of my sons, now adults, are with Colonial Insurance as well!)
Tucson Trail Investments
Jun 20, 2022
Report
Dan, Jack and the rest of the Colonial Team have been a great partner for not only our business but personal insurance as well. They are quick to respond and steer you in the right direction providing you with the proper type and amount of insurance. Building business is about partnership and we are glad we found Colonial Insurance Agency!
Theresa Pivotto
Jun 19, 2022
Report
Shopping for insurance is something we never do very often but should. One call to Colonial Insurance is all it took because they represent multiple companies and found us the best deal. Wish I would have done it sooner. They are very friendly and professional. Thank you Jack!
Eric Kovacevich
Jun 18, 2022
Report
I always feel assured Colonial has my best interest in picking proper coverage for me and my business. Straight shooters with no sales pressure!
Randy & Ashley Durham
Jun 17, 2022
Report
Jack has been a Godsend for our insurance needs, helping us cover everything from our home to our car, our business and our RV. When we first made the switch to Colonial, Jack actually realized we weren't even properly covered for our farm with our previous insurance company and he absolutely was instrumental in protecting our family.
Michael Cappozzo
Jun 17, 2022
Report
Jack made switching insurance providers simple and painless! Unrivaled service - I know when I refer someone to Colonial, they will have the same experience I did.
Jason Franzke
Jun 16, 2022
Report
I worked with Jack and he was great at explaining everything to me. We got a great deal through a phenomenal company and couldn't be happier!
