Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Fenton, Missouri
Established in 1955, Siebert Insurance operates as an independent insurance agency dedicated to providing comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions. Our agency represents multiple carriers to ensure clients receive optimal coverage, competitive pricing, and exceptional service tailored to their unique needs. With decades of experience serving Fenton, Missouri, and surrounding regions, we prioritize personalized support through a dedicated team approach. Our expertise spans auto, homeowners, life, health, and commercial insurance, including specialized policies for businesses of all sizes.We maintain a client-centric philosophy, emphasizing transparency, risk management, and proactive consultation to protect individuals and enterprises. Backed by 70 years of local market knowledge, we offer 24/7 claim reporting assistance and streamlined policy management through our online support center. Our commitment to excellence has solidified our reputation as a trusted insurance partner across Missouri, Illinois, Kansas, Arizona, Arkansas, Ohio, Texas, and Florida.
Services
Auto Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Commercial Auto
General Liability
Workers Compensation
Life Insurance
Commercial Property
Renters Insurance
Business Owners Policy
Pet Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1955
Highlights and features
- We have 70 years of experience serving Missouri and surrounding states.
- Our independent agency offers multiple carrier options for optimal coverage.
- Dedicated team provides personalized insurance solutions and support.
- 24/7 claim reporting assistance available for policyholders.
- We serve clients across eight states including Missouri, Illinois, and Texas.
What people say
Knowledgeable agents
Personalized service
Competitive rates
Quick claims processing
Expert guidance
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance policies protecting drivers across Missouri and seven surrounding states. Our coverage options include liability protection, collision coverage, and uninsured motorist provisions tailored to individual driving needs. With access to multiple carriers, we help clients secure competitive rates while maintaining essential protections for personal vehicles.
Commercial Auto
Our commercial auto insurance solutions protect business fleets and company vehicles across multiple industries. Policies cover liability, physical damage, and cargo protection while complying with state-specific commercial vehicle regulations. We specialize in customized coverage for contractors, transportation companies, and businesses requiring specialized vehicle protection in eight states.
General Liability
We offer essential general liability insurance for businesses in Missouri and neighboring regions. Our policies protect against third-party claims involving property damage, bodily injury, and advertising liabilities. Tailored for restaurants, contractors, and retailers, our coverage includes legal defense costs and settlement provisions to safeguard commercial operations.
Workers Compensation
Our workers' compensation insurance meets legal requirements across eight states while protecting businesses from workplace injury claims. Policies cover medical expenses, rehabilitation costs, and lost wages for employees. We provide specialized solutions for high-risk industries while offering risk management resources to prevent workplace incidents.
Homeowners Insurance
We deliver comprehensive homeowners insurance covering primary residences in Missouri and surrounding areas. Our policies protect against fire, theft, and natural disasters while including liability coverage for property owners. With flexible deductible options and replacement cost guarantees, we ensure policyholders maintain financial security against unexpected property damage.
People
Tiffany Ruhland
President
Leading Siebert Insurance with over 25 years in the industry, Tiffany directs strategic growth while maintaining client-focused service standards across eight states.
Krista Siebert-Smith
Vice President
As Vice President, Krista oversees daily operations and ensures compliance with insurance regulations while maintaining the agency's 70-year legacy of excellence.
Bill Siebert
COO
Bill manages operational efficiency and technology integration, leveraging his 30+ years in insurance to enhance policyholder experiences and internal processes.
Karen Siebert
General Manager
Karen supervises client relations and team development, applying her extensive insurance expertise to maintain the agency's personalized service approach since 1955.
Joe Clay
CIO
As Chief Information Officer, Joe leads digital transformation initiatives while ensuring data security and technological advancements support the agency's 70-year mission.
Questions
How do I get an insurance quote?
Request a free quote online through our website or call 636-343-1000 for personalized assistance from our licensed agents.
What insurance types do you offer?
We provide auto, homeowners, life, health, commercial auto, general liability, workers' compensation, and specialized business insurance policies.
How do I file a claim?
Report claims 24/7 using the number on your policy documents or contact us directly at 636-343-1000 for immediate assistance.
Do you serve businesses outside Missouri?
Yes, we provide commercial insurance solutions across eight states including Illinois, Kansas, Texas, and Florida.
Can I manage policies online?
Access policy management tools through our online support center for document requests, payment processing, and coverage adjustments.
How long have you been in business?
Celebrating 70 years of service since our founding in 1955, we remain committed to Missouri communities and beyond.
Reviews (6)
Abdulloh Yo'Ldosh
May 08, 2022
Report
Brittany is professional and amazing in this business and she saved money for home and auto insurance for us with better coverage. Highly recommend. Thank you.
Caroline Whiting
Feb 12, 2022
Report
Brittany was amazing in her research which ultimately saved my family so much money! We saved money AND got better coverage! WIN WIN! She is expedient in her follow up and just an all around pleasure to do business with! Highly recommended!
Linda Hayes
Jan 16, 2022
Report
This is your go to insurance company i have been with them for years and they are extremely professional and very humble and treat you like family. Excellent customer service
Brent Pearson
Jul 07, 2021
Report
Tanya was awesome at recently helping me understand my insurance policy, and even followed up with me with an email and a phone call making sure that it was clear what I needed to do. I always appreciate the great communication and promptness of Siebert Agency! They are the best and I will send everyone I know there.
Danielle Ethridge
Jun 18, 2021
Report
Shelby Crawford is our agent and she's amazing! She has been great to work with and is always kind and professional. She saved us $1,000 a year while giving us better coverage. Our previous insurance was completely taking advantage of me and I barely had coverage without knowing. It is extremely important to find a trustworthy agent.
Tracey Simpson
May 21, 2021
Report
Switching to Siebert Insurance Agency, LTD has been 1 of THE BEST decisions I have made. Everyone that answers the phone is pleasant & helpful. Ashley Drennen has handled our insurance needs & goes above & beyond to make sure we have the best coverage. She takes her time to explain things & always updates us with new information. We were with State Farm for over 30 yrs & I'm glad we switched over. Thank you for providing quality service.
