Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Trusted Insurance Solutions in Columbus, OH
Established in 1968, Putnam White Lewis Insurance Agency has served Ohio businesses, individuals, and families for over 57 years. As an independent agency, we represent multiple insurance carriers to provide tailored coverage options that meet diverse client needs. Our team of licensed professionals prioritizes client education and risk management, ensuring clients understand their policies and protections. We combine industry expertise with personalized service to deliver innovative insurance solutions. Our reputation is built on responsive customer support, creative problem-solving, and a commitment to putting clients first. With offices in Columbus and Lancaster, we serve local communities while maintaining a broad network of carrier partnerships.Our focus on quality coverage extends across personal lines like home, auto, and life insurance, as well as commercial policies for businesses of all sizes. We specialize in niche areas including classic car insurance, flood protection, and hospitality industry coverage. Our commercial offerings address cyber liability, directors and officers liability, and specialized property protections. Through decades of service, we have developed a deep understanding of Ohio's unique insurance landscape, enabling us to provide context-specific advice and solutions that protect clients' assets and futures.
Services
Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Business Owners Insurance
Cyber Liability Insurance
Hospitality Insurance
Flood Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Life Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1968
Highlights and features
- We represent multiple insurance carriers to find the best coverage for your needs
- Our team includes licensed insurance advisors with decades of local expertise
- We prioritize client education and transparent policy explanations
- We offer specialized insurance solutions for unique assets like classic cars
- Our independent agency model ensures unbiased recommendations
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance protects your residence and belongings against damage, theft, and unexpected events. We provide comprehensive policies that help homeowners recover after incidents like fires or storms. With customizable coverage options, we ensure your home - and your peace of mind - remain protected.
Business Owners Insurance
This tailored solution combines essential coverages for businesses into one policy. We help protect commercial properties, vehicles, and operations with customized plans that address specific industry risks. Our approach ensures business owners have comprehensive protection while maintaining cost-effectiveness through bundled services.
Cyber Liability Insurance
Designed for modern businesses, our cyber liability insurance safeguards against data breaches and digital threats. We provide coverage for cyber attacks, network security failures, and data privacy violations. Our policies help businesses maintain continuity while complying with evolving digital security requirements and protecting sensitive customer information.
Classic Car Insurance
Specialized coverage for classic and collectible vehicles recognizes their unique value. We offer policies that protect against damage, theft, and accidents while accounting for these vehicles' appreciation potential. Our program includes agreed value coverage and special provisions for show participation and limited use driving.
Hospitality Insurance
Customized protection for hotels, bed and breakfasts, and other hospitality businesses. Our policies cover property damage, guest liabilities, and operational risks specific to the hospitality industry. We address unique exposures like guest property loss, food service liabilities, and business interruption during seasonal operations.
People
Jeff Lewis
President
Jeff Lewis leads the agency with decades of insurance expertise, focusing on strategic growth and client satisfaction. He oversees operations while maintaining hands-on client relationships, ensuring the agency's continued commitment to quality service and community involvement.
Richard DJ White
Vice President
Richard 'DJ' White brings extensive industry experience to his role, specializing in commercial insurance solutions. He works closely with business owners to develop comprehensive risk management strategies while maintaining the agency's tradition of personalized service.
Tine Landholt
Customer Service Representative
Tine Landholt provides expert policy support and claims assistance to clients in Columbus. With years of experience in insurance operations, she ensures timely responses to client inquiries while maintaining the agency's high service standards.
Dawn Layne
Customer Service Representative
Dawn Layne supports clients with policy management and coverage questions in Columbus. Her focus on clear communication helps clients understand their insurance protections while ensuring efficient service delivery.
Suzanne Miller
Customer Service Representative
Suzanne Miller serves Lancaster clients with personalized insurance support. She specializes in policy administration and client education, helping individuals and businesses make informed coverage decisions while maintaining the agency's service excellence.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (home, auto, life, classic car) and business insurance (general liability, cyber liability, commercial property) with specialized options for hospitality and flood coverage.
How are you different from other agencies?
As an independent agency, we represent multiple carriers to find optimal coverage. Our 57+ years of local experience and client-first approach ensure personalized, unbiased recommendations.
How can I get an insurance quote?
Request a quote through our website, call either office location, or visit us in person. Our team will review your needs and provide customized coverage options.
Do you serve businesses outside Columbus?
Yes, we serve businesses throughout Ohio from our Columbus and Lancaster offices, with specialized expertise in commercial insurance for various industries.
What are your office hours?
Our offices operate Monday-Thursday 9am-5pm and Friday 9am-4pm. We offer after-hours contact options for urgent insurance matters.
Can you help with specialized insurance needs?
Yes, we specialize in unique coverages including classic car insurance, flood protection, and hospitality industry policies tailored to Ohio's specific risk environments.
Reviews (4)
Clear Water Prowash
Jan 18, 2022
Report
As a power washing business, I want to make sure Clear Water Prowash and Deck Escapes Staining and Beyond has the ultimate business insurance coverage for our clients. Demi has been wonderful to work with at Putnam White Lewis insurance. She always returns my calls quickly if she isn't immediately available. She explains things clearly and gets things done rapidly. Demi is an important part of our team. Thank you for the fantastic customer service!
Barbara Paplaczyk
Jul 21, 2021
Report
I have been with this agency for a long time. I now have Karen and she is professional, caring, takes care of your needs promptly. Karen is the best!
Dan Cf
May 04, 2021
Report
Non-responsive to the point of unethical. I attempted to get my insurance policies corrected for 2 years. I repeatedly attempted contact with my assigned agent, through emailed and voicemail messages, to no avail. With all other options exhausted, I reached out to my insurance company who quickly began to resolve my concerns. My policies were corrected and I was offered the opportunity to move to an agency who will, hopefully, value my business.
Tami Gunther
Mar 22, 2021
Report
Suzanne is very knowledgeable and always prompt in returning emails and answering any questions that I have. I've been doing business with the company for over 20 years. Always exceptional service!
