Browse the Top Insurance Companies Serving Oak Creek, WI

See what insurance companies serving Oak Creek, WI offer, from auto and home insurance to life and business coverage. Review company profiles, read customer feedback, and contact providers that match your insurance requirements.
Badger Mutual Insurance Company
Milwaukee, WI 53233 (10.8 mi mi)
Emergency
7 reviews
Badger Mutual Insurance Company provides personalized commercial and personal insurance solutions across seven states. Specializing in restaurant, rental property, cyber liability, and commercial package policies, we combine regional expertise with a people-first approach. Since 1887, our mission has been to deliver compassionate, reliable coverage through local agents who understand individual client needs.
Automobile Insurance Homeowners Insurance Renters Insurance
Responsive, quick turn-around Seamless and smooth process Excellent response on my claim
7 reviews
Colonial Insurance
50+ Years
7 reviews
Colonial Insurance delivers personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Wisconsin. Since 1975, we've provided home, auto, life, umbrella, and business insurance tailored to client needs. Our independent approach ensures competitive pricing and comprehensive coverage through partnerships with multiple carriers.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Umbrella Insurance
Exceptional service Professional and responsive Timely communication
4 reviews
G2 Insurance Services
Brookfield, WI 53005 (17.2 mi mi)
22 Years
4 reviews
G2 Insurance Services offers comprehensive personal and commercial insurance solutions in Brookfield, Wisconsin. Established in 2004, we specialize in tailoring coverage for auto, home, life, health, and business insurance needs. Our client-focused approach combines industry expertise with personalized service to deliver optimal protection.
Business Insurance Personal Auto Home Insurance
Excellent customer service Prompt and attentive Saved money annually
4 reviews
Insurance Outfitters
Cedarburg, WI 53012 (29.0 mi mi)
50+ Years
4 reviews
Established in 1957, Insurance Outfitters serves Cedarburg, WI as a family-owned independent insurance agency. Offering personalized home, auto, and business insurance solutions, we leverage relationships with 20+ top-rated carriers to secure competitive rates. Our third-generation team combines local expertise with nationwide resources to protect Ozaukee County residents' most valuable assets.
Homeowners Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
Knowledgeable, personalized service Competitive rates Assistance with policy transitions
Frydach Insurance
22 Years
Emergency
4 reviews
Frydach Insurance
Germantown, WI 53022 (26.7 mi mi)
22 Years
Emergency
4 reviews
Frydach Insurance is a Wisconsin-based independent insurance firm offering tailored auto, home, business, and specialty insurance solutions. We provide personalized service through partnerships with over 20 insurers, ensuring competitive rates and comprehensive coverage. Our 24/7 emergency support and deep community ties distinguish us in delivering reliable, customer-focused insurance services.
Car Insurance Home Insurance Collector Car Insurance
Hassle-free process Quick and responsive Best agent ever
Vizance
Hartland, WI 53029 (28.5 mi)
48 Years
6 reviews
Vizance
Hartland, WI 53029 (28.5 mi mi)
48 Years
6 reviews
Vizance is a full-service insurance and employee benefits agency offering tailored risk management solutions. Founded in 1978, we combine personalized service with industry expertise to protect businesses and families through customized insurance programs, proactive claims management, and compliance guidance. Our client-first approach emphasizes accessibility, transparency, and long-term partnership.
Business Insurance Claims Management Employee Benefits
Personalized solutions Knowledgeable team Proactive approach
1 review
MGIC Investor Service
Milwaukee, WI 53202 (10.8 mi mi)
50+ Years
1 review
MGIC is a leading mortgage insurance provider offering innovative solutions to lenders nationwide. We specialize in risk management through tailored MI products, underwriting expertise, and educational resources. Our services empower financial institutions to expand homeownership opportunities while maintaining portfolio stability.
Mortgage Insurance Solutions Portfolio Lending Underwriting Support
Not rated yet
Central States Insurance Agency
Milwaukee, WI 53226 (10.8 mi mi)
45 Years
Not rated yet
Central States Insurance Agency provides tailored insurance solutions for individuals and businesses across Wisconsin and the Midwest. We partner with leading carriers to offer competitive rates on auto, home, life, health, commercial, and specialty insurance policies. Our independent agent model ensures clients receive unbiased advice and comprehensive coverage options.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Community Insurance Information Center
Milwaukee, WI 53217 (10.8 mi mi)
48 Years
Not rated yet
Community Insurance Information Center provides free insurance education and consumer advocacy services in Greater Milwaukee. Established in 1978, we help residents understand auto and property insurance through personalized counseling, community outreach, and partnerships with local organizations. Our programs are funded by the Wisconsin Insurance Alliance and supported by the state's Office of the Commissioner of Insurance.
Auto Insurance Guidance Property Insurance Education Consumer Counseling
HNI CO
10 Years
Not rated yet
HNI CO
New Berlin, WI 53151 (13.9 mi mi)
10 Years
Not rated yet
HNI partners with high-performing companies to implement de-risking strategies that reduce insurance costs and improve organizational resilience. We offer tailored insurance solutions, employee benefits programs, and cybersecurity risk management services. Our proactive approach helps businesses break free from the 'Insurance Dependency Trap' through strategic planning and education.
Insurance Solutions Employee Benefits Cybersecurity Services
Milwaukee (10.8 mi) South Milwaukee (1.7 mi) New Berlin (13.9 mi) Brookfield (17.2 mi) Waukesha (20.5 mi) Menomonee Falls (23.9 mi) Mequon (24.3 mi) Burlington (25.4 mi) Germantown (26.7 mi) North Prairie (27.6 mi)